ARBORIST CALLS
Zcash protocol calls, distilled
Call-by-call summaries of the Arborist calls hosted by the Zcash Foundation every two weeks. Open a card for the summary of each agenda item.
ZSA catches up to NU6.3, Epoch team joins
ZSA finished catching up to NU6.3, and Shielded Labs launched Epoch, a post-quantum research team.
- QEDIT's ZSA work was aligned to NU6.3 and is moving to a dedicated branch in the Zcash repository.
- The Crosslink FeatureNet restarted with a BFT bootstrap and a 10% finalizer fee.
- Zakura's 400 zat minimum fee differs from the ZIP, and Zebra has not yet made a decision.
- A contradiction between ZIP 218 and ZIP 237 was raised that would remove 0.67 ZEC from issuance in NU7.
Zebra 6.4.2 advised, NU7 on November 5
An update to Zebra 6.4.2 was recommended, and Crosslink launched a new, feature-complete FeatureNet.
- Zebra advised using 6.4.2, which fixes a DoS vulnerability, and 6.4.x nodes will halt on November 2.
- The NSM's ZIP 235 and 237 were merged into Zebra and Zakura for NU7.
- Crosslink opened a new FeatureNet with activation phases and a finalizer fee.
- Zakura wants to lower the minimum fee to 400 zat, which requires coordination with wallets.
NSM reissuance set for February 2031
The NSM vote chose the option that keeps halvings, and reissuance will start in February 2031.
- In the NSM vote, the ZIP-234 option that keeps halvings was supported, and the reissuance date was set to February 2031.
- Shielded Labs will implement ZIP-234 and 235 in Zebra and Zakura by September 30.
- Crosslink finished the finalizer fee and the Ironwood merge ahead of its first network restart at the end of September.
- Nym released a mixnet SDK module for Zcash wallets and the Swizzle crate.
Major overhaul of Zebra's transaction type
Zebra merged a transaction type refactor of more than 5,000 lines, with fixes still needed before the next release.
- Zebra's Transaction now wraps the zcash_primitives type, and a fix for a consensus difference is blocking the next release.
- Zallet Beta 3 fixed the miner migration problem and findings from the Least Authority audit.
- Kris proposed reviewing the ZIP-248 draft for merging and the idea of setting the minimum fee in USD.
- Zaino is finishing a modularization refactor that makes indexes optional.
Debate over the fee parameter change process
A procedural debate broke out over reflecting fee parameters in implementations before a ZIP existed.
- Mark posted a 2000-series ZIP draft that lowers the marginal fee from 5000 to 1000 zat.
- Zakura raised the weight cap tenfold and a PR was also sent to Zebra, and Daira pointed out that the specification should come first.
- Zebra 6.3.0 includes sync and peer scoring security fixes and an experimental lightwallet-compatible gRPC server.
- Erys presented a grant proposal to specify constant-time operations in Rust cryptographic code.
Three Zebra security patches in a row
Zebra shipped three patches in two weeks, and the migration to Ironwood continued.
- Zebra's consensus fixes include banning peers that send invalid shielded proofs and checking ZIP-317 before expensive verification.
- Wallet D 0.5.0 was the Ironwood-compatible version, followed by 5.1 and 5.2, and two major providers updated.
- Zallet Beta 2 was released, and fixes for the security audit findings were delivered.
- Crosslink is improving syncing with weekly releases and is preparing for the August 26 workshop.
ZcashD retires, Ironwood imminent
ZcashD retired and its repository was archived, and the Ironwood mainnet activation is imminent.
- Zebra shipped five releases since the last call, and 6.0.0 fully supports Ironwood on mainnet.
- About 61% of the organizations contacted reported migrating, and nearly all mining hashpower moved to the new software.
- The ZcashD repository was archived a few days ago.
- Crosslink users slashed an unresponsive finalizer with a new tool, and BFT resumed.
NU 6.3 testnet targeted for July 1
Activation of the NU 6.3 testnet, which includes Ironwood, was targeted for July 1.
- The NU 6.3 deployment and the draft ZIP for the v6 transaction format were merged, and the testnet activation height is undecided.
- Zebra increased the non-finalized state reorg window from 100 blocks to 1000 blocks.
- Zallet Alpha 4 is complete, and testing of ZcashD wallet.dat migration was requested.
- Runtime Verification presented a grant proposal for Lean formal verification of Zebra's arithmetic and parsing layer.
NU 6.2 activation and Ironwood
After the Orchard pool disabling soft fork and the NU 6.2 activation, the move to Ironwood was announced.
- Zebra carried out the Orchard pool disabling soft fork on June 2 and the NU 6.2 activation on June 3.
- Pacu presented the move from Orchard to Ironwood in late July as the target line for ZcashD deprecation.
- Mark reported the first priority-fee (4x marginal fee) transaction sent through a wallet feature.
- Daira said a time for turning off Sprout must be set and recommended moving funds out through ZcashD now.
Dynamic fees: wallet experiments begin
Shielded Labs began priority-send fee experiments with wallets and proposed changes to ZIP-317.
- Six to seven wallets agreed to experiment with 4x priority sends and short expiry times.
- A proposal was made to change the ZIP-317 marginal fee from 5000 to 1000 and the weight cap from 4 to 10.
- The Crosslink FeatureNet went through a BFT stall and a long PoW fork, and the team decided to decouple reboots from network state.
- Zaino 3.1 was released, and achieving feature parity to deprecate lightwalletD became the top goal.
Talks on speeding up ZcashD deprecation
As AI-driven security findings continued, options for bringing forward the ZcashD deprecation schedule were discussed.
- Zebra 4.3.1 was released, and an additional release to address security advisories was announced.
- Daira explained the verification bugs fixed in ZcashD 6.12.0 and 6.12.1 and said deprecation must be hastened.
- Pacu said the frictionless transition is being dropped and deprecation will be brought forward, centered on core use cases.
- The Crosslink FeatureNet went live on April 16, and six people made 91 commits and used a custom UDP transport layer.
Crosslink always-on net and ZEC rewards
Crosslink moved to an always-on feature net with roughly six-week seasons and a ZEC rewards system.
- After the prototype's last workshop, Crosslink moved to an always-on feature net and allocated 25 ZEC to the first season.
- A difficulty adjustment bug caused by the genesis timestamp led to resetting and relaunching the network.
- Zebra speeds up CI builds with dynamic linking of RocksDB and is collecting performance improvement PRs.
- Maven rain presented a grant proposal to formally verify the Halo 2 Orchard gadgets in Lean 4.
Zebra and ZcashD security patches in quick succession
Zebra 4.3 fixed two CVEs, and ZcashD also patched a Sprout proof vulnerability.
- Zebra 4.3 fixed two CVEs that could cause a chain split or a node crash and includes ZIP-235.
- ZcashD 6.12 closed a vulnerability that let invalid Sprout proofs enter the chain.
- str4d began a three-month sabbatical, so the Zaino chain index integration work needs community help.
- ZIP-316 revision 2 creates two unified address prefixes, ZU and TU, and supports P2SH viewing keys.
Zebra 4.2.0, integration tests in place
Zebra 4.2.0 was released, and an integration testing setup tying together the whole z3 stack is now in place.
- Zebra 4.2.0 includes expanded RPCs and zcashd-level mempool policy.
- ZODL built z3 stack CI with an integration test repository and is working on NU7 ZIPs in parallel.
- Kris asked for feedback on ZIPs PR 1206, which proposes revision 2 of the unified address standard.
- Mark withdrew the dynamic fee ZIP and decided to start by building an RPC for a mainnet fee sensor.
Mood leans toward holding off ZSA mainnet activation
On the NU7 vote results, the direction discussed for ZSA was to keep it behind a feature flag and on testnet.
- QEDIT proposed keeping the ZSA code behind a feature flag and deferring the mainnet activation decision.
- Pacu said ZcashD deprecation is at the earliest around September 2.
- Kris said they intend to put together NU7 with a minimal composition and propose it within a week or two.
- Shielded Labs split the ZIP-234 and ZIP-235 PRs so that 233 and 235 can proceed first.
Zebra 4.1, switch to OpenRPC
Zebra released 4.1.0 and moved from OpenAPI to OpenRPC support.
- Zebra added the get transaction out RPC and a policy for AI agent code submissions.
- The former ECC team is now called ZODL, and str4d got the z3 integration test framework in order.
- Daira said a plan was agreed so that wallets that support ZSA and those that do not cannot tell Orchard v6 transactions apart.
- Shielded Labs planned seasonal testnets that open anew at each milestone and donation-based rewards.
Shielded coinbase block on mainnet
The Zebra team mined a shielded coinbase block directly on mainnet to verify it.
- Zebra 4.1 includes new Prometheus metrics and mempool script checks aligned with ZcashD.
- With the ZIP-213 implementation, a shielded coinbase block was created and tested on mainnet.
- PRs piled up on the easy issues of the Zallet contributor board, and a draft get wallet status API was posted.
- It was suggested that a ZIP or process document is needed to set the NU7 build flag rules for the whole stack.
New transaction format and consensus accounts
The former ECC team presented draft ZIPs for an extensible transaction format and consensus accounts.
- Zebra 4.0.0 was released, and the Shielded Labs DNS seeder was added to the default peer list.
- ZIPs PR 1156 contains a new transaction format that lets NU7 features be split into smaller releases.
- A consensus accounts ZIP that generalizes the lockbox is also being drafted.
- Adding a separate engineer vote and for-and-against opinion papers to the NU7 sentiment poll was discussed.
Zebra pushes shielded coinbase
Zebra pushed ZIP-213 shielded coinbase mining and pre-Canopy block support.
- Zebra is working on a PR to support mining with shielded coinbase (ZIP-213) and on pre-Canopy subsidy support.
- Zaino is nearly done with the work needed for Zallet support ahead of its first official release.
- QEDIT is nearly finished addressing str4d's review of the Orchard ZSA PR.
- The next Crosslink milestone is targeted for January 28, and a review by a mechanism design expert is underway.
ZcashD retirement timeline and dynamic fees
A retirement roadmap anchored to ZcashD end-of-support dates and a dynamic fee design were presented.
- Pacu pointed to January 21 as the end of support for ZcashD 6.10 and September 9, 2026 as the next end-of-support point.
- The trial period of running ZcashD and the new stack side by side was estimated at about 16 weeks.
- Mark presented a design that recalculates the ZIP-317 marginal fee from the median of recent blocks.
- Nate said they would personally convene a discussion on a shared feature testnet for ZSA, Crosslink and Tachyon.
ZIP-233 merged, Zebra 3.0
The ZIP-233 implementation PR was merged into Zebra, and the 3.0 stable release will come within days.
- Shielded Labs' ZIP-233 implementation PR was merged into Zebra, and the Zebra 3.0.0 stable release is coming soon.
- Wallet developers were told they must update the consensus branch ID before NU6.1 activates.
- QEDIT added a finalize operation to the ZSA testnet and demonstrated issuance, transfer, burn and finalization.
- The external NSM development team ends in late November, and Shielded Labs takes over the ZIP-234 and 235 work.
ZcashD retirement delayed to early 2026
Emergency response to the price surge pushed the ZcashD retirement steps back to early 2026.
- Zebra published a release candidate for NU6.1, and initial sync dropped from 24 hours to about 8 hours.
- Pacu said the ZcashD retirement steps slip to after early 2026 because of urgent response work.
- Work to put transparent data into compact blocks is under way in lightwalletd and Zaino.
- Crosslink finished milestone 4a and moved to its own BFT implementation; the 4b workshop is targeted for early December.
Zebra 3 RC cuts sync time sharply
The Zebra 3 release candidate is out, and a full sync now takes 8 to 16 hours.
- The Zebra 3 RC was published for NU6.1, and a full sync took 8.5 to 16 hours.
- ECC focused on fixing wallet-backend bugs after the surge of new Zashi users.
- In the Crosslink demo a node joined the roster through PoW headers, and a workshop was announced for October 22.
- An issue was raised to prepare an emergency patch for Crosslink that turns PoS off and returns to PoW.
NU6.1 lockbox P2SH address generated
The P2SH address keys for lockbox disbursements are done, so the NU6.1 release is imminent.
- Str4d ran the key-generation procedure with the key-holding organizations, and the P2SH address was created.
- The NU6.1 activation height was due to be reflected in ZIP 255 that day.
- Zallet's default confirmations were set at 3 for trusted UTXOs and 10 for untrusted UTXOs.
- A health-check endpoint for Kubernetes was merged into Zebra.
Zallet alpha released
The Zallet alpha is out and can be installed as a Docker image or Debian package.
- ECC released the Zallet alpha, with a Docker image and a Debian package.
- Cross-chain payments through NEAR arrived in Zashi.
- Zebra backs up the last 100 blocks of the non-finalized chain to a file and restores them on restart.
- Investor feedback on Crosslink's 30-day unbonding design was discussed.
Orchard ZSA spec completion report
Qedit said Orchard ZSA is complete by the spec and will go into review soon.
- Qedit said Orchard ZSA is spec complete and will soon turn to review.
- Zebra replaced Sapling verification with librustzcash and added support for environment-variable configuration.
- Daira Emma suggested drawing on Penumbra's private design for Crosslink staking.
- Whether to ship the quantum-resistance change alongside NU7, and whether it is a consensus change, was discussed.
Small NU7 proposal draws pushback
ECC-side participants opposed Shielded Labs' proposal for a smaller NU7.
- Shielded Labs proposed a smaller NU7 centered on NSM and explicit fees.
- Daira Emma opposed it, saying the benefit is small and moving transaction format changes forward is risky.
- Kris worried that a plan including all transaction format changes is risky for zcashd.
- Zebra 2.5.0 deployed NU6.1 to testnet, and Qedit's Halo 2 PR was merged.
zcashd 6.3.0 prepares for NU6.1
zcashd 6.3.0 was released, with NU6.1 testnet activation and the NSM merge under way.
- ECC released zcashd 6.3.0 for the NU6.1 testnet.
- Shielded Labs' core NSM PR was merged into librustzcash.
- Zebra 2.5.0, containing the NU6.1 testnet activation height, was due for release that day.
- A new core team member, Schell, joined ECC, growing the staff by a third.
Debate over per-organization Zebra forks
A proposal to develop post-NU7 upgrades in per-organization forks sparked debate.
- A DB upgrade bug in Zebra 2.4.0 led to that release being withdrawn and 2.4.1 being issued.
- ECC said it plans the NU6.1 mainnet activation for October or November.
- Zaino restructured non-finalized and finalized state as first-class objects.
- Arya said forks are fine but releases from each fork are costly.
Zebra 2.4 DB upgrade announced
With the Zebra 2.4 release announced, backing up state was advised because of the DB upgrade.
- Zebra 2.4 includes a DB upgrade, so state must be backed up in order to roll back.
- Prometheus metrics become enabled by default in Zebra.
- Zaino is finishing the representation of non-finalized and finalized state and improving its error-handling structure.
- The NSM PR is waiting for ECC review, so the security audit schedule slipped.
Zebra RPC expansion and IPv6 default
Zebra added value pool queries and mempool change notifications, and IPv6 is now on by default.
- Zebra added value pool queries to getblock and introduced a mempool change notification method.
- Newly configured Zebra has IPv6 addresses enabled by default.
- The zcash_script Rust implementation is compared against the C++ result and logs a warning on mismatch.
- Qedit reported a ZIP change for issuance key rotation and the Halo 2 ZSA PR.
NU6.1 lockbox multisig keys requested
Testnet multisig key generation for the NU6.1 one-time lockbox disbursement was requested.
- Kris asked the lockbox key-holding organizations to generate testnet multisig P2SH keys.
- A NU6.1 network upgrade variant was added to Zebra and the lockbox disbursement PR was opened.
- ECC implemented the NU6.1 lockbox one-time disbursement consensus change in zcashd.
- The Zallet alpha is to include zcashd wallet migration and z_sendmany.
Crosslink Milestone 2 complete
Crosslink Milestone 2 is done, creating a one-way link from PoS to PoW.
- Shielded Labs finished Crosslink Milestone 2 and put tokenomics at the top of its priorities.
- Qedit opened the first Zebra PR that verifies ZSA transactions.
- Str4d pointed out that the NSM Zebra PR must sit behind a flag so it cannot affect mainnet.
- Zingo Labs released Excavator v0.
NU7 delay strains ZCG finances
The NU7 delay increased ZCG's burden of funding ZSA, and a clearer schedule was requested.
- ZCG said it has funded Qedit at $105,000 per month for five months.
- Kris answered that the NU7 schedule cannot be set on the spot and that ZSA PR review is slow.
- With Crosslink Milestone 2 in its final stage, a mainnet shadowing workshop was announced.
- Zebra 2.3.0 was released and Zsend was merged into Zallet.
zcashd-to-Zebra migration tool proposed
A draft migration tool that moves zcashd block data into Zebra state was shown.
- Str4d opened an initial example that turns a zcashd node into Zebra state, as PR 9472.
- OpenRPC support was added to Zallet so the RPC schema can be queried.
- In Zebra 2.3 the RPC endpoint of the Docker image is disabled by default.
- Crosslink's BFT blocks now carry a real payload containing an array of PoW headers.
Quantum-resistant design explained in detail
Str4d explained in detail the design for hardening note commitments against quantum attacks.
- zcashd 6.2.0 was released, and an upgrade was advised ahead of the end of support for 6.1.0.
- The Zallet team said it is migrating zcashd wallet.dat with the Zewif tool.
- Str4d said there is still a chance to align the FROST key structure with quantum resistance.
- Str4d wants to ship this change with NU7 and said the only consensus change is shielded coinbase.
Note construction change for quantum readiness
A proposal to change note construction so notes remain usable after quantum computers was introduced.
- Daira Emma introduced a proposal to change Orchard note construction to make post-quantum use possible.
- FROST key generation also needs to change to match, and Daira Emma agreed to handle the fix.
- Zebra Docker was changed so the RPC endpoint is disabled by default.
- Zallet syncs the chain using Zingo as a data source and has begun work on z_send.
ZIP security and privacy sections debated
The lack of security and privacy sections in most NU7 candidate ZIPs was discussed.
- Shielded Labs finished Crosslink Milestone 1 and set June 1 as the target for Milestone 2.
- Zallet now syncs the chain using Zaino as a library.
- Kris acknowledged that ZIP 231 has no security and privacy section and agreed to add one.
- Jason said that day was the last day of the community notetaker.
NU7 config flag convention discussed
The account metadata key ZIP 325 and the config flag approach for NU7 were discussed.
- ECC wrote ZIP 325, which defines account metadata keys.
- The mobile SDK now fetches and submits transactions over Tor.
- Zebra finished score-based peer banning and was asked to document it.
- Daira Emma strongly objected to livestreaming the Arborist call on X.
Zebra 2.2.0 released
Zebra 2.2.0 was released and the FROST client and server went into audit.
- Zebra 2.2.0 includes a branch ID consensus rule check and the switch to jsonrpsee.
- Zallet began actually serving some zcashd RPC APIs.
- The FROST audit began, and a presentation is scheduled for the February 19 community call.
- The generalization of Zcash note encryption for ZSA was merged upstream.
NU7 October at earliest, Sprout alternative
An outlook that NU7 comes in October at the earliest and a ZSA-based Sprout redemption idea were discussed.
- Str4d said a network upgrade including ZSA is hard before October.
- Josh proposed extending the lockbox by one year and either putting it in NU7 or splitting it into a separate upgrade.
- ECC presented a plan to turn Sprout balances into a synthetic asset via ZSA and redeem it for ZEC.
- Zallet aimed to have its surrounding infrastructure in place by the end of February.
NSM "burn" terminology dispute
A terminology dispute arose over what NSM's "burn" does to the supply cap.
- Zebra moved its JSON RPC server to a new framework and skipped redundant verification.
- zcashd 6.1.0 was released, and 6.0.0 loses support in about two weeks.
- The FROST DKG implementation is done, leaving only adding a broadcast channel and the audit.
- Dodger agreed to the term "retraction" proposed by Kris instead of "burn".
Positive ZSA audit, NU7 scope discussed
The ZSA audit came back positive, and the scope of ZIPs to include in NU7 was discussed.
- It was reported that Least Authority's ZSA audit report came back without major issues
- The PCZT v1 format is finished and the first crate release is coming up
- Zebra 2.1.0 fixed a mempool bug in consensus branch ID validation
- Daira said they support ZIP-233 and ZIP-234 but oppose ZIP-235
NSM poll, skepticism about ZIP-235
An NSM poll got under way, and some argued that ZIP-235's benefit is low relative to its complexity.
- In the ZecHub poll, 20 active community members unanimously supported including NSM in NU7
- Arya expected the ZIP editors to recommend including ZIP-233
- Some argued ZIP-235 is better added as a standard rule after NU7
- The FROST server was changed to authenticate with key pairs, so it no longer needs a database
NU6 activation on November 23 approaches
NU6 is set to activate on November 23, and the NSM ZIP schedule was adjusted.
- NU6 is set to activate on Saturday, November 23, so ZF and ECC agreed to watch it together
- Kris judged that ZIP-233 and ZIP-234 are polished enough to go into NU7
- They decided to move the NSM ZIP-234 activation height to a later point
- For Zaino, a structure was raised of building a semantics-focused gRPC and layering JSON RPC on top of it
NU7 ZIP draft deadline nears
Ahead of the NU7 ZIP draft deadline, a scaled-down NSM proposal and a Sprout deactivation proposal emerged.
- It was announced that Zebra 2.0.0 panics at NU6, so 2.0.1 must be used
- ECC started a binary tentatively named Zallet as the zcashd wallet replacement
- The NSM team proposed an alternative of including only the ZIP-233 burn feature in NU7
- Daira submitted a ZIP that blocks v4 transactions, effectively switching Sprout off
ZSF renamed NSM, NU7 candidate
ZSF was renamed NSM, and there was an intention to put it forward as an NU7 candidate.
- zcashd 6.0.0 was released with NU6 support, and upgrading before November 5 was recommended
- ZSF is renamed Network Sustainability Mechanism, using the terms burn and reissue
- Daira and Kris objected to the burn terminology and to the ZIP consensus rules
- ZIPs must be submitted as PRs by November 5 to have a chance of inclusion in NU7
Cause of the testnet stall identified
The cause of the testnet stall was explained, and preparation for the zcashd 6.0.0 release was wrapped up.
- The testnet stall came from a difference in header sync combined with a block time limit bug
- ECC said the 6.0.0 release is the version that sets the NU6 activation height
- Sean Bowe left ECC and will research Zcash scalability under independent funding
- Kris and Daira differed on how far to keep zcashd wallet RPC compatibility
CLI wallet and Zaino indexer architecture agreed
Participants agreed on the Zaino indexer architecture for the CLI wallet that replaces zcashd.
- Least Authority's preliminary NU6 audit report had two suggestions on documentation and error handling
- Zingo Labs adjusted the grant to drop wallet development and take on only the Zaino indexer
- Most agreed with a structure in which Zaino also provides the lightwallet gRPC
- The ZSA team said it is discussing the Orchard ZSA audit with Least Authority
NU6 testnet activated, mining stopped
NU6 activated on testnet, but the miners disappeared and the chain stalled.
- The NU6 testnet activation succeeded and zcashd 5.10.0 was released
- Existing testnet miners did not upgrade, so the chain stalled and needed recovery
- Zebra 1.9.0 came out with the testnet activation height
- Shielded Labs said it plans to build a Crosslink prototype in stages
Crosslink v1 requirements published
zcashd 5.10.0-rc1 came out, and Zooko presented the Crosslink v1 requirements.
- zcashd 5.10.0-rc1 contains the full NU6 consensus rules and 2 security patches
- From NU6, blocks must claim all fees and balance exactly
- Zooko published the target feature list for Crosslink v1 and asked for input
- ECC put full transparent wallet history recovery into the SDK
NU6 testnet activation delayed
The NU6 testnet activation was postponed, and the ZSA fee structure was discussed.
- The NU6 testnet activation was pushed back until after zcashd debugging and private testnet verification
- Zebra implemented the lockbox funding stream and the ZIP-236 coinbase balance rule
- Zooko joined Shielded Labs as head of product and announced TFL collaboration
- Vanilla ZSA can be deployed after an audit, and fees are expected to be paid in ZEC
NU6 lockbox implementation and zcashd deprecation
NU6 lockbox implementation is progressing in both nodes, and collaboration on the zcashd deprecation was discussed.
- ECC and ZF are implementing the lockbox feature so that only a configuration value needs to change
- Opinions were raised that the August 8 NU6 testnet activation is a tight schedule
- ECC merged Tor-based exchange rate lookup into the Rust crates
- ZCG will attend the Arborist Call from now on to introduce proposals
Zebra 1.8.0 and the scanner split
Zebra 1.8.0 came out, and NU6 testnet activation was added to the agenda.
- Zebra 1.8.0 was released with the default free action limit changed to 0
- The Zebra scanner was split into a separate binary and returns only txids
- August 8 was mentioned as the target date for NU6 testnet activation
- ECC said it will publish its roadmap next week after the July summit
ZSF excluded from NU6, ZSA encryption dispute
ZSF will not be in NU6, and opinions differed on ZSA verified encryption.
- It was confirmed that the ZSF team is not targeting NU6 and announced this on the forum
- FROST 2.0.0-rc0 was released with no_std support and simplified serialization
- Zebra split the scanner out of Zebrad and previewed the 1.8.0 release
- Daira and Kris voiced concern that the issuer key could become a honeypot
NU6 ZIP deadline and the Dev Fund
A deadline for NU6 ZIP submissions was proposed, and the design space for the Dev Fund lockbox was discussed.
- Kris proposed getting the NU6 ZIPs to proposed status by the July 16 ZIP editors' meeting
- Daira will share a design space document for the Dev Fund lockbox approach on the forum
- ECC will lower the default free action limit to 0 in the next zcashd release
- Str4d finished a prototype that looks up exchange rates over Tor via Arti
zcash script API simplified
Conrado's simplified zcash script API entered the review stage.
- zcash script was changed to compute the sighash through a callback instead of a transaction pointer
- zcashd 5.9.1 came out including the TEX address validation API for Binance
- For Zashi exchange rate lookup, signed data and a lightwalletd proxy are being considered in parallel
- ECC described a plan to run the Rust script interpreter in parallel for verification in NU6
Memo key: note plaintext vs KDF debate
Participants debated whether to put the memo bundle key in the note plaintext or derive it with a KDF.
- Zebra 1.7.0 was released with regtest and custom testnet support
- The proposal to extend Zebra's end-of-support period was withdrawn and reverted to 16 weeks
- At Binance's request, ECC will add a TEX address check RPC to zcashd
- Many attendees thought the original design of putting the key in the note plaintext is simpler
Memo bundle design overview published
The requirements and a draft design for the NU6 memo bundle were presented for the first time and discussed.
- Zashi 1.0 Android launched and recorded roughly 1,600 installs
- The memo bundle proposal replaces the 512-byte per-output memo with a 32-byte key
- Zebra's minimal regtest works and Windows support was restored
- The ZSA team began building a testnet for ZSA
NU6 candidates and the zcashd deprecation plan
Participants held a long discussion of NU6 candidate features, the ZIP process and the zcashd deprecation schedule.
- zcashd 5.9.0 RC1 was tagged, with the final version due the next day
- ZSA, ZSF, an explicit fee field and the memo bundle were mentioned as NU6 candidates
- ECC said it put a June transient testnet for NU6 on its roadmap
- They decided to hold an additional NU6 meeting and make the zcashd deprecation an agenda item at every call
Zashi 1.0 iOS launched
Zashi 1.0 for iOS launched on the App Store, and resuming ZSF work was discussed.
- Zashi 1.0 iOS is out on the App Store, and the Android version is in testing
- Zebra's ZSF implementation is 60-70% complete, with the goal of progressing before the halving
- The ZSA team is finishing backward compatibility work and began discussing a protocol audit
- A PR with network parameters for custom testnets was opened in Zebra
Routine zcashd maintenance release announced
Orchard support stabilization is in its final stretch, and a zcashd maintenance release was announced.
- Orchard support in ECC's mobile SDK has entered the final stabilization stage
- A zcashd maintenance release is coming soon to update librustzcash and extend the EOS
- An OpenAPI specification generator for the Zebra RPC was added and the regtest work continues
- The FROST re-randomized paper was published on ePrint
ZSA stablecoin roadmap discussion
The ZSA team said it will include stablecoin support in its 2024 roadmap.
- Zebra 1.6.0 was released and Windows support in zcash script was restored
- zcash_address 0.3.2 recognizes ZIP-320 TEX addresses and returns an unsupported error
- Daira reported having a Comet BFT technical meeting with Zaki Manian
- The ZSA team proposed exchange compatibility and verifiable encryption for issuers as 2024 work
FROST 1.0 release and TEX addresses
The stable FROST 1.0.0 was released, and the Binance response was settled on a TEX address approach.
- FROST 1.0.0 fixed a vulnerability where DKG commitment lengths were not verified (reported by Trail of Bits).
- ECC expects Zashi 1.0 in late March, and security audits are underway starting with iOS.
- The Binance response will be finalized using the TEX-encoded address approach of ZIP-320.
- The ECC and Zebra teams held a first meeting on the features needed to replace zcashd.
Asset swap ZIP-228 draft submitted
QEDIT submitted an asset swap ZIP draft, and Daira became an ECC engineering manager.
- QEDIT posted the asset swap draft as ZIP-228, PR 780.
- A gRPC frontend is being attached to the Zebra scanner, and a Docker Compose file is being added.
- QEDIT's transaction testing tool was requested to be merged upstream.
- Daira became ECC's R&D engineering manager and steps down as a ZIP editor at the end of February.
Nate leaves ECC; TFL overview
Nate said they are leaving ECC, and an overview of the Trailing Finality Layer and Crosslink was presented.
- Nate said they will leave ECC after Zeboot next week.
- Crosslink is a hybrid design that combines PoW and BFT to obtain finality.
- The team decided to call for proposals for a new HRP for the UA revision that uses Must Understand metadata.
- FROST will soon make its 1.0.0 stable release, and review of ZIP-312 is underway.
Binance exchange address proposal approved
Binance technically approved the exchange address proposal, but development was put on hold until its review is complete.
- Binance passed the technical review but will approve development only after its compliance review is finished.
- An experimental, test-only built-in mining feature was added to Zebra.
- ZIP-317 and Orchard support in the SDK is expected within a week or two.
- Jon showed a revocable payment method with a zksend demo based on Sui zkLogin.
zcashd maintenance and NU6 deadline discussion
Discussion that the NU6 deadline makes the move to Zebra urgent led to a decision to recruit a task force to maintain zcashd.
- Kris said the move to Zebra is needed within 5-6 months for NU6 before the halving.
- Zebra 1.5.0 included an MVP for scanning the blockchain with Sapling viewing keys.
- The ZSF 60/40 fee split was estimated at about 800 ZEC per year, or $24,000.
- An in-depth Crosslink presentation by the TFL team will be given on the February Arborist call.
First mainnet block mined with Zebra
Marek shared the first case of mining a mainnet block with Zebra, and FROST 1.0.0-rc.0 was released.
- Zebra 1.5.0 will include experimental shielded scanning and network fixes following Ziggurat.
- FROST 1.0.0-rc.0 was published and is collecting API feedback.
- Crosslink stays safe as long as only one of its two subprotocols is secure.
- Str4d said mempool spam has almost disappeared since mid-November.
DZFE working group decided
ECC is pursuing a working group for technical decentralization, and news on Zebra 1.4.0 was shared.
- The ECC SDK does not yet support Orchard or ZIP-317, and Orchard support is the top priority.
- The official repositories for the Zashi app and the SDK were moved to the Electric Coin Company organization.
- Eiger started the ZSF implementation in Zebra, and Pili will be the point of contact for collaboration on Zebra.
- TFL Book 0.1.0 was released, putting Crosslink into the documentation.
ECC emergency mode officially ends
ECC declared the end of emergency mode, and the NU5 retrospective will begin in four weeks.
- Emergency mode ended after all three wallets shipped SDK 2.0 and users regained access to their funds.
- Zebra 1.4.0 puts the mining RPCs in the production build and embeds the proving parameters.
- The FROST audit report was published on the NCC site.
- QEDIT is building a pseudo-v6 transaction tool for testing ZSA in Zebra.
Zebra 1.3.0 and SDK 2.0.3
Zebra 1.3.0 fully supports Spend-before-Sync, and the SDK 2.0.3 release is imminent.
- Zebra 1.3.0 put the progress bar in the default build and fixed a mining RPC performance bug.
- Edge's Paul Puey said Edge will follow the SDK's supported scope and aims for a store release early next week.
- QEDIT posted ZSA circuit optimization PRs to halo2 and orchard.
- The Crosslink draft now includes a liveness argument, and the simulator simtfl was published.
Crosslink design first shown
Daira introduced the Crosslink design that improves on ebb and flow, and the NU5 retrospective schedule will be revisited in four weeks.
- zcashd 5.7.0 was released, and 5.6.1 halts at EOS on October 11.
- The activation timing and rationale for issuance curve smoothing, one of the three ZSF ZIPs, was discussed.
- An opinion was raised that including v6 transactions, ZSA and ZSF would fill the upgrade complexity budget.
- The Minor Grants vote has 20 applications totaling over $225,000 against a budget of $75,000.
Mobile SDK 2.0 RC3 released
The iOS and Android SDKs reached the RC3 stage, and the official 2.0.0 release is set for Monday.
- SDK 2.0.0 uses a fixed fee of 10,000 zatoshi, with ZIP-317 postponed to the next release.
- The zcashd update bundles the proving parameters in the binary, so no separate download is needed.
- Zebra finished spend-before-sync support and is starting work on a Sapling scanning wallet.
- Adi joined the ZIP editors, making the editors Daira, Str4d, Conrado, Adi and teor.
Deirdre leaves; SDK release candidate imminent
The mobile SDK release candidate is imminent, and Deirdre said they are leaving the Zcash Foundation.
- Deirdre leaves the ZF after their last day on September 13 and also steps down as a ZIP editor.
- Zebra 1.2 added an automatic DB upgrade framework and subtree root support.
- Adding ZIP editors and formalizing editor-consensus decision-making were proposed.
- Jack Gavigan put Detection Keys and Liberated Payments on the formal agenda.
ZIP-317 wallet outreach discussion
A discussion that wallet vendors need to be contacted ahead of ZIP-317 enforcement led the ZF to take it on.
- Zebra reduced its DB from 278GB to 244GB by deduplicating note commitment trees.
- Zooko said they are taking over ECC engineering management and product after Nick's departure.
- The FROST audit found only medium and low issues, all of which were fixed.
- The second round of ZF Minor Grants opened, supporting up to $25,000.
SDK fast spending and ZIP-317 support
ECC said it will soon release Spend-before-Sync and ZIP-317 support in the mobile SDK.
- The SDK changes to show a transaction proposal first and create the transaction after approval.
- Zebra stopped storing note commitment trees per height and posted a PR to clean up existing trees.
- Nate is designing a trailing finality protocol for the move to PoS.
- Shielded Labs will post the first ZSF ZIP draft to the forum next week.
Spend-before-Sync completed
ECC finished the Rust work for Spend-before-Sync, and Zebra 1.1.0 was released.
- ECC finished the Rust components of Spend-before-Sync and announced crate publication next week.
- lightwalletd's getsubtreeroots had a bug that returned an empty result when given 0.
- Zebra 1.1.0 refuses to start on an invalid subcommand and upgrades the DB while running.
- The FROST audit found no critical issues, and the final report is targeted for the end of August.
Ledger app lacks ZIP-32 support
An audit of the Ledger app raised the issue that it does not support ZIP-32 key derivation.
- Taylor Hornby pointed out that the Ledger app is based on BIP-32, which breaks seed compatibility.
- Shielded Labs started ZSF development, with writing two ZIPs as its first goal.
- Zebra 1.0.1 fixed connection security bugs and panics and reduced CPU usage.
- The Ziggurat red team found 4 Zebra bugs, and the late slot moves to 21:00 UTC.
Zebra audit report published
NCC Group published the final Zebra audit report, and the zcashd 5.6.1 hotfix was released.
- zcashd 5.6.1 fixed a note commitment tree bug in the Orchard wallet introduced in 5.6.0.
- The Zebra audit found one medium-severity issue, and the rest were low or informational.
- QEDIT changed how nullifiers are derived for ZSA split notes and prepared a circuit PDF.
- Daira announced that they are looking for a third ZIP editor volunteer.
Zebra 1.0.0 official release
The stable Zebra 1.0.0 was released, and zcashd 5.6.0 was published the day before.
- zcashd 5.6.0 was released as the first of three steps to resolve emergency mode.
- Zebra 1.0.0 was published on crates.io and Docker Hub.
- Nighthawk released a Zcash testnet block explorer.
- A change to the late slot time was postponed until after Zcon.
ECC restructuring and zcashd 5.6.0
ECC's restructuring was mentioned, and zcashd 5.6.0 is being prepared around the fast sync API.
- The ZF decided to bring forward a second minor grants round for affected staff.
- Applying multi-scalar multiplication to FROST group commitments made it more than 50% faster.
- QEDIT proposed 1 ZEC for ZSA issuance and a transfer fee indistinguishable from ZEC's.
- Nighthawk unveiled infrastructure with four clusters in North America, Europe, Asia and Brazil.
Zebra rc.8 and ZSA stablecoins
The Zebra audit is wrapping up without major problems, and the possibility of ZSA stablecoins was discussed.
- Zebra rc.8 added a feature that stops running 16 weeks after release, like zcashd.
- zcashd 5.5.1 fixed a ZIP-317 fee calculation error and a crash bug.
- The core features of the FROST library are complete and will soon be audited.
- It was decided to begin discussions on coordinating network upgrades among organizations starting in June.
zcashd 5.5.0 and ZIP-317
zcashd 5.5.0 was released with ZIP-317 proportional fees, and the Zebra audit entered its second phase.
- zcashd 5.5.0 includes ZIP-317 fees and a unified approach to wallet transaction creation.
- Zebra entered audit phase 2 and implemented a default that shuts down after 120 days, like zcashd.
- Equilibrium said there are about 200 mainnet nodes, with Zebra under 10%.
- QEDIT posted its ZSA asset swap plan on the forum, targeting a testnet before Zcon4.
ZIP-317 in zcashd 5.5.0
The zcashd 5.5.0 release candidate, which includes the ZIP 317 changes, was approved and is due for release next week.
- The zcashd 5.5.0 release candidate was approved and is expected to ship early next week once CI passes.
- The Zcash Foundation published all FROST implementations on crates.io, and the IRTF chair passed the specification.
- The Zcash R&D category on the Zcash forum was opened for anyone to read and will be used as a technical collaboration space.
- The NU5 retrospective was postponed until after June, and the team discussed overhauling the network upgrade process before NU6.
DAGSync non-linear sync design
The DAGSync design for fast sync was shared, and it was corrected that Zelcash/Flux, not Firo, had been confusing the network.
- Kris described a sync approach that fetches recent blocks first instead of syncing linearly, so existing notes can be spent right away.
- Whether to put ZIP 317 fee enforcement in zcashd 5.5.0 was not yet decided because wallet adoption is lacking.
- As audit findings, Zebra limited the number of unconfirmed chains and excluded fake nodes from its address book.
- With no dedicated maintainer for lightwalletd, the team will discuss having ECC and ZF take it on together.
Halborn vulnerability and network monitoring
After the response to the memory exhaustion vulnerability was completed, the Ziggurat crawler and public network monitoring were discussed.
- The memory exhaustion DoS vulnerability found by Halborn was disclosed, and ECC and ZF finished the mitigation work.
- The Zebra audit has so far turned up only low-severity or informational issues.
- The Ziggurat crawler saw about 6000 nodes, but it was pointed out that Firo nodes may be mixed in.
- The team will schedule a meeting with the ECC infrastructure team to discuss open-sourcing the monitoring tools.
Orchard circuit layout bug fix
A Halo 2 circuit layout bug that made Orchard proofs fail on 32-bit environments was resolved and will be included in the next crates.
- A circuit layout bug that relied on an unstable sort function blocked Orchard spends in 32-bit wallets, but no funds were lost.
- zcashd 5.5.0 supports ZIP 317 in both the wallet and block generation and is due for release in 3 to 4 weeks.
- The FROST crates were published as 0.1.0, and the RFC is going through review by the CFRG chair.
- The first results of the Zebra security audit came in and are being turned into issues; the auditor is NCC.
Feature-specific testnets and Zebra rc5
Zebra became ready for mining pool testing, and how to stand up feature-specific testnets was discussed at length.
- Zebra rc5 finished the mining-related RPCs, so mining pools can now test it.
- zcashd 5.4.1 fixed a problem where settings for features slated for deprecation did not take effect in the config file.
- Zebra said it implements only ZIP-317 and has already implemented the block construction part.
- The Zcash Foundation launched Minor Grants of up to $25,000 each, with a total of $75,000.
Zebra mining success and zcashd 5.4.0
Testnet blocks were successfully mined with Zebra, and zcashd 5.4.0 exposed the total supply and the transparent pool balance.
- The Zebra team mined several blocks on the testnet using a modified s-nomp and a CPU miner.
- zcashd 5.4.0 shows the total supply and transparent pool size in getblockchaininfo on reindexed nodes.
- Some RPCs slated for deprecation, such as getnewaddress, are now disabled by default, and 5.5.0 centers on ZIP 317 support.
- ZIP-216 is being applied retroactively, and QEDIT submitted a PR implementing ZSA transfers.
zcashd 5.4.0 and supply tracking
zcashd added tracking of the total chain supply and the transparent pool balance, and unclaimed fees were confirmed at about 368.58 ZEC.
- zcashd tracks the transparent pool and chain supply, and unclaimed fees were confirmed at 368.5844552 ZEC.
- Zebra added RPCs for mining pools, including getblocksubsidy and the getblocktemplate proposal mode.
- FROST specification v12 was released and is going through the IRTF approval process.
- Wolfram Blockchain Labs introduced a plan to integrate Zcash into the Wolfram Language.
612-byte ZSA note ciphertext
A 32-byte ZSA asset identifier is added to the note ciphertext, and Zebra released rc.3.
- QEDIT said it will grow the ZSA note plaintext from 580 to 612 bytes while keeping the memo at 512 bytes.
- Zebra rc.3 includes RPCs for mining pools and ZIP 317-based transaction selection.
- Kris described the shardtree structure, which updates the note commitment tree out of order.
- Str4d proposed implementing ZSA with zcashd's network upgrade feature flag framework and using a separate testnet.
Detection keys and the recursion priority debate
After ECC said it will focus on payment scalability for a year, a debate broke out over the priority of Halo 2 recursion.
- ZIP 317 was implemented in Zebra rc.2, and getblocktemplate for mining pools was completed.
- Nate said PoS research will be put off for about a year while the team focuses on wallet scalability.
- The team agreed to compare and lay out the pros and cons of detection keys, out-of-band notifications, OMR and others.
- zcashd 5.3.2 reverted the headers-first download fix, and 5.4.0 is due in mid-to-late January.
ZIP 317 unpaid actions fix
An amendment to ZIP 317 capping unpaid actions per block and the Ledger app's v4 support issue were discussed.
- Daira proposed a per-block cap on unpaid logical actions to close a vulnerability that lets large low-fee transactions slip in.
- QEDIT will merge its ZSA fee proposal into ZIP 317 and deliver output for testnet connection by the end of January.
- Zondax's Ledger app supports only v4, which Ledger sees as a regression, so a meeting of those involved will be held.
- Zebra parallelized Sprout anchor checking with rayon, and zcashd 5.3.1 is due soon.
FROST final review and SDK unified addresses
The IRTF's FROST specification entered final review, and the mobile SDK will support unified addresses first.
- The FROST threshold signature specification v11 entered IRTF final review, and comments were requested on the CFRG mailing list.
- The next mobile SDK will support only transparent and Sapling UAs, with ZIP 317 applied in the release after that.
- zcashd stores block headers in LevelDB, cutting virtual memory by up to 2.3GB.
- Standardization of PLONK-family systems was discussed at the zkproof conference.
Zebra rc.1 and security audit preparation
Zebra released 1.0.0-rc.1, its second release candidate, to be sent to the security audit.
- Zebra 1.0.0-rc.1 came out as the candidate for audit submission, and the audit firm has not yet been confirmed.
- The first getblocktemplate, getblockhash and getblockcount RPCs were added to Zebra.
- zcashd is preparing an optimization that reads about 2.3GB of block headers from LevelDB instead of memory.
- The team will invite developers and service providers to the November 10 ZIP 317 wallet developer meeting.
Zebra 1.0.0-rc.0 tagged
Zebra tagged its first release candidate, and zcashd 5.3.0 shipped with memory optimizations.
- Zebra tagged 1.0.0-rc.0, and lightwalletd sync became about twice as fast.
- zcashd 5.3.0 caps batch scanner memory to prevent OOM during sync and adds Prometheus metrics.
- A rule was added to ZIP 317 that converts the script size of large transparent transactions into logical actions.
- The core team agreed to add fee calculation to the zcash_inspect tool.
ZIP 317 fee parameters revealed
The ZIP 317 logical action formula and the 5000 zat per action fee parameters were introduced in detail for the first time.
- The fee parameters were set at a marginal fee of 5000 zat and 2 grace actions.
- A 2-logical-action transaction pays 10,000 zat, the pre-ZIP 313 level.
- The daily fees for sandblasting transactions rise from about $0.42 to about $2,300.
- Nate said they will hold an explanatory meeting for wallet developers so wallets apply the new fees first.
Moving zcash_script to zcashd
A proposal to move the zcash_script crate into the zcashd repository and the cause of sync memory spikes were discussed.
- Zebra beta.15 parallelized cached state reads, and multi-threaded RPC is turned on through configuration.
- The zcashd sync memory spike was caused by how trial decryption results were passed, and was fixed by closing the channel.
- In the ZIP 317 discussion, Nate presented contacting wallet vendors and a staged rollout strategy as next steps.
- Conrado will create a WIP PR to move zcash_script into the zcashd repository.
ZIP 317 phased rollout roadmap
A roadmap for rolling out the ZIP 317 fee overhaul in stages, in the order wallets, relay, consensus, was discussed.
- Zebra beta.14 was released, and the start command became the default when running zebrad.
- Nate proposed rolling out ZIP 317 in the order of wallet adoption, relay rules, then consensus changes.
- The next mobile SDK will include the unified address migration and parallelized trial decryption, and the team will file UA issue #630 involving Orchard.
- The ZSA team said circuit implementation is about halfway done and the circuit size may exceed the target.
Responding to network load and ZIP 317
ECC shared the status of its response to the surge in network load, and the draft ZIP 317 fee proposal was introduced.
- Since mid-June the chain grew from about 30GB to 83GB, and the orphan rate came down to 1.8 to 2.8%.
- ECC made fast mobile SDK sync its top priority and pivoted toward fee mechanism research.
- On the unified address transition, it said the next SDK release may drop the Orchard component from addresses.
- Dodger proposed a lightweight wallet architecture using detection keys, and a workshop will be held.
Fee structure overhaul discussion
In response to network load, a proposal to switch to a fee structure based on the number of inputs and outputs was discussed.
- Kris proposed a fee scheme of 250 zat per input and output with a floor of 1000 zat.
- zcashd 5.2.0 includes a proof verification cache, multi-threaded trial decryption, and witness data pruning.
- Zebra rewrote verification concurrency with Rayon and reduced unnecessary block deserialization.
- Concerns were raised about a rollout order requiring wallets to be updated first before raising fees, and about mobile UX.
zcashd 5.1.0 performance and ZSA design
zcashd 5.1.0 cut block verification time by about 80%, and the ZSA design and FROST ZIP work were shared.
- Zebra fixed a bug that verified Halo 2 proofs per action, but sync was still slow.
- zcashd 5.1.0 cut Sapling and Orchard verification time by about 80%.
- Conrado is writing a ZIP specifying FROST for Zcash, with the goal of making it public before Zcon.
- QEDIT submitted ZSA issuance and issue PRs and explained design points such as the Sinsemilla gadget change.
Orchard load and batch verification
Orchard transactions surged after NU5 and blocked Zebra sync, while zcashd cut verification time with batch verification.
- Zebra 1.0.0-beta.12 was released, including changes such as automatic deletion of old cached state.
- Up to 500 Orchard transactions per block piled in, and Zebra adjusted timeouts and the number of parallel tasks.
- zcashd cut verification time by about 81% with Orchard batch verification.
- The team will pursue a knowledge-sharing presentation on CI and automated testing among ECC, ZF and grant recipients.
Zebra DNS seeder and Tokio
Zebra became able to serve as a lightwalletd backend, and the DNS seeder problem caused by Flux nodes was also resolved.
- Work to make Zebra usable as a lightwalletd backend is nearly done and was tested with Nighthawk and Zecwallet.
- A surge in Flux nodes made the DNS seeder malfunction, so a minimum protocol version and default port filter were applied.
- Support for Tokio Console, for inspecting async tasks, was added to Zebra.
- After NU5 activation, wallets and block explorers work normally, and zcashd 5.1.0 is due in about 6 weeks.