← Home

ARBORIST CALLS

Zcash protocol calls, distilled

Call-by-call summaries of the Arborist calls hosted by the Zcash Foundation every two weeks. Open a card for the summary of each agenda item.

105 / 105
ARBORIST#134

ZSA catches up to NU6.3, Epoch team joins

ZSA finished catching up to NU6.3, and Shielded Labs launched Epoch, a post-quantum research team.

  • ZSA
  • Crosslink
  • Epoch
  • Dynamic fees
  • Formal verification
  • Akita
  • QEDIT's ZSA work was aligned to NU6.3 and is moving to a dedicated branch in the Zcash repository.
  • The Crosslink FeatureNet restarted with a BFT bootstrap and a 10% finalizer fee.
  • Zakura's 400 zat minimum fee differs from the ZIP, and Zebra has not yet made a decision.
  • A contradiction between ZIP 218 and ZIP 237 was raised that would remove 0.67 ZEC from issuance in NU7.
Topics 8 · VideoRead more →
ARBORIST#133

Zebra 6.4.2 advised, NU7 on November 5

An update to Zebra 6.4.2 was recommended, and Crosslink launched a new, feature-complete FeatureNet.

  • Zebra 6.4.2
  • NU7
  • NSM
  • Crosslink
  • UASF
  • Dynamic fees
  • Zebra advised using 6.4.2, which fixes a DoS vulnerability, and 6.4.x nodes will halt on November 2.
  • The NSM's ZIP 235 and 237 were merged into Zebra and Zakura for NU7.
  • Crosslink opened a new FeatureNet with activation phases and a finalizer fee.
  • Zakura wants to lower the minimum fee to 400 zat, which requires coordination with wallets.
Topics 6 · VideoRead more →
ARBORIST#132

NSM reissuance set for February 2031

The NSM vote chose the option that keeps halvings, and reissuance will start in February 2031.

  • NSM
  • ZIP-234
  • Nym integration
  • Crosslink restart
  • ZSA NU6.3
  • Formal verification
  • In the NSM vote, the ZIP-234 option that keeps halvings was supported, and the reissuance date was set to February 2031.
  • Shielded Labs will implement ZIP-234 and 235 in Zebra and Zakura by September 30.
  • Crosslink finished the finalizer fee and the Ironwood merge ahead of its first network restart at the end of September.
  • Nym released a mixnet SDK module for Zcash wallets and the Swizzle crate.
Topics 9 · VideoRead more →
ARBORIST#131

Major overhaul of Zebra's transaction type

Zebra merged a transaction type refactor of more than 5,000 lines, with fixes still needed before the next release.

  • Zebra refactor
  • Zallet Beta 3
  • ZIP-248
  • USD minimum fee
  • Zaino modularization
  • ZIP-316 rev2
  • Zebra's Transaction now wraps the zcash_primitives type, and a fix for a consensus difference is blocking the next release.
  • Zallet Beta 3 fixed the miner migration problem and findings from the Least Authority audit.
  • Kris proposed reviewing the ZIP-248 draft for merging and the idea of setting the minimum fee in USD.
  • Zaino is finishing a modularization refactor that makes indexes optional.
Topics 8 · VideoRead more →
ARBORIST#130

Debate over the fee parameter change process

A procedural debate broke out over reflecting fee parameters in implementations before a ZIP existed.

  • ZIP process
  • Dynamic fees
  • Zebra 6.3.0
  • ZSA review
  • Crosslink restart
  • Constant time
  • Mark posted a 2000-series ZIP draft that lowers the marginal fee from 5000 to 1000 zat.
  • Zakura raised the weight cap tenfold and a PR was also sent to Zebra, and Daira pointed out that the specification should come first.
  • Zebra 6.3.0 includes sync and peer scoring security fixes and an experimental lightwallet-compatible gRPC server.
  • Erys presented a grant proposal to specify constant-time operations in Rust cryptographic code.
Topics 8 · VideoRead more →
ARBORIST#129

Three Zebra security patches in a row

Zebra shipped three patches in two weeks, and the migration to Ironwood continued.

  • Zebra patches
  • Ironwood migration
  • Zallet Beta 2
  • Wallet D
  • Crosslink Season 2
  • Dynamic fees
  • Zebra's consensus fixes include banning peers that send invalid shielded proofs and checking ZIP-317 before expensive verification.
  • Wallet D 0.5.0 was the Ironwood-compatible version, followed by 5.1 and 5.2, and two major providers updated.
  • Zallet Beta 2 was released, and fixes for the security audit findings were delivered.
  • Crosslink is improving syncing with weekly releases and is preparing for the August 26 workshop.
Topics 6 · VideoRead more →
ARBORIST#128

ZcashD retires, Ironwood imminent

ZcashD retired and its repository was archived, and the Ironwood mainnet activation is imminent.

  • ZcashD retirement
  • Ironwood
  • Zebra 6.0
  • Zallet Beta
  • Note locking
  • Crosslink slashing
  • Zebra shipped five releases since the last call, and 6.0.0 fully supports Ironwood on mainnet.
  • About 61% of the organizations contacted reported migrating, and nearly all mining hashpower moved to the new software.
  • The ZcashD repository was archived a few days ago.
  • Crosslink users slashed an unresponsive finalizer with a new tool, and BFT resumed.
Topics 7 · VideoRead more →
ARBORIST#127

NU 6.3 testnet targeted for July 1

Activation of the NU 6.3 testnet, which includes Ironwood, was targeted for July 1.

  • NU 6.3
  • Ironwood
  • Zallet Alpha 4
  • 1000-block reorg
  • ZecD
  • Formal verification
  • The NU 6.3 deployment and the draft ZIP for the v6 transaction format were merged, and the testnet activation height is undecided.
  • Zebra increased the non-finalized state reorg window from 100 blocks to 1000 blocks.
  • Zallet Alpha 4 is complete, and testing of ZcashD wallet.dat migration was requested.
  • Runtime Verification presented a grant proposal for Lean formal verification of Zebra's arithmetic and parsing layer.
Topics 11 · VideoRead more →
ARBORIST#126

NU 6.2 activation and Ironwood

After the Orchard pool disabling soft fork and the NU 6.2 activation, the move to Ironwood was announced.

  • NU 6.2
  • Ironwood
  • ZcashD deprecation
  • Orchard pool
  • Dynamic fees
  • Sprout deprecation
  • Zebra carried out the Orchard pool disabling soft fork on June 2 and the NU 6.2 activation on June 3.
  • Pacu presented the move from Orchard to Ironwood in late July as the target line for ZcashD deprecation.
  • Mark reported the first priority-fee (4x marginal fee) transaction sent through a wallet feature.
  • Daira said a time for turning off Sprout must be set and recommended moving funds out through ZcashD now.
Topics 8 · VideoRead more →
ARBORIST#125

Dynamic fees: wallet experiments begin

Shielded Labs began priority-send fee experiments with wallets and proposed changes to ZIP-317.

  • Dynamic fees
  • ZIP-317
  • Crosslink FeatureNet
  • Zaino 3.1
  • ZSA Zebra PR
  • Rollback limit
  • Six to seven wallets agreed to experiment with 4x priority sends and short expiry times.
  • A proposal was made to change the ZIP-317 marginal fee from 5000 to 1000 and the weight cap from 4 to 10.
  • The Crosslink FeatureNet went through a BFT stall and a long PoW fork, and the team decided to decouple reboots from network state.
  • Zaino 3.1 was released, and achieving feature parity to deprecate lightwalletD became the top goal.
Topics 9 · VideoRead more →
ARBORIST#124

Talks on speeding up ZcashD deprecation

As AI-driven security findings continued, options for bringing forward the ZcashD deprecation schedule were discussed.

  • ZcashD deprecation
  • Security vulnerabilities
  • Crosslink FeatureNet
  • STP transport layer
  • ZSA demo
  • Formal verification
  • Zebra 4.3.1 was released, and an additional release to address security advisories was announced.
  • Daira explained the verification bugs fixed in ZcashD 6.12.0 and 6.12.1 and said deprecation must be hastened.
  • Pacu said the frictionless transition is being dropped and deprecation will be brought forward, centered on core use cases.
  • The Crosslink FeatureNet went live on April 16, and six people made 91 commits and used a custom UDP transport layer.
Topics 9 · VideoRead more →
ARBORIST#123

Crosslink always-on net and ZEC rewards

Crosslink moved to an always-on feature net with roughly six-week seasons and a ZEC rewards system.

  • Crosslink FeatureNet
  • Season rewards
  • Halo 2 verification
  • Zebra CI
  • ZcashD security
  • Lean 4
  • After the prototype's last workshop, Crosslink moved to an always-on feature net and allocated 25 ZEC to the first season.
  • A difficulty adjustment bug caused by the genesis timestamp led to resetting and relaunching the network.
  • Zebra speeds up CI builds with dynamic linking of RocksDB and is collecting performance improvement PRs.
  • Maven rain presented a grant proposal to formally verify the Halo 2 Orchard gadgets in Lean 4.
Topics 8 · VideoRead more →
ARBORIST#122

Zebra and ZcashD security patches in quick succession

Zebra 4.3 fixed two CVEs, and ZcashD also patched a Sprout proof vulnerability.

  • Zebra 4.3
  • Security patches
  • ZIP-316 rev2
  • ZIP-248
  • Quantum threat
  • str4d sabbatical
  • Zebra 4.3 fixed two CVEs that could cause a chain split or a node crash and includes ZIP-235.
  • ZcashD 6.12 closed a vulnerability that let invalid Sprout proofs enter the chain.
  • str4d began a three-month sabbatical, so the Zaino chain index integration work needs community help.
  • ZIP-316 revision 2 creates two unified address prefixes, ZU and TU, and supports P2SH viewing keys.
Topics 9 · VideoRead more →
ARBORIST#121

Zebra 4.2.0, integration tests in place

Zebra 4.2.0 was released, and an integration testing setup tying together the whole z3 stack is now in place.

  • Zebra 4.2
  • Integration tests
  • ZIP-1206
  • Zaino RC
  • Crosslink season
  • Fee sensor
  • Zebra 4.2.0 includes expanded RPCs and zcashd-level mempool policy.
  • ZODL built z3 stack CI with an integration test repository and is working on NU7 ZIPs in parallel.
  • Kris asked for feedback on ZIPs PR 1206, which proposes revision 2 of the unified address standard.
  • Mark withdrew the dynamic fee ZIP and decided to start by building an RPC for a mainnet fee sensor.
Topics 7 · VideoRead more →
ARBORIST#120

Mood leans toward holding off ZSA mainnet activation

On the NU7 vote results, the direction discussed for ZSA was to keep it behind a feature flag and on testnet.

  • NU7 vote
  • ZSA
  • ZcashD deprecation
  • NSM split
  • Crosslink
  • Feature testnet
  • QEDIT proposed keeping the ZSA code behind a feature flag and deferring the mainnet activation decision.
  • Pacu said ZcashD deprecation is at the earliest around September 2.
  • Kris said they intend to put together NU7 with a minimal composition and propose it within a week or two.
  • Shielded Labs split the ZIP-234 and ZIP-235 PRs so that 233 and 235 can proceed first.
Topics 10 · VideoRead more →
ARBORIST#119

Zebra 4.1, switch to OpenRPC

Zebra released 4.1.0 and moved from OpenAPI to OpenRPC support.

  • Zebra 4.1
  • OpenRPC
  • ZODL
  • Zcash script
  • Crosslink seasonal net
  • NU7 vote
  • Zebra added the get transaction out RPC and a policy for AI agent code submissions.
  • The former ECC team is now called ZODL, and str4d got the z3 integration test framework in order.
  • Daira said a plan was agreed so that wallets that support ZSA and those that do not cannot tell Orchard v6 transactions apart.
  • Shielded Labs planned seasonal testnets that open anew at each milestone and donation-based rewards.
Topics 8 · VideoRead more →
ARBORIST#118

Shielded coinbase block on mainnet

The Zebra team mined a shielded coinbase block directly on mainnet to verify it.

  • Zebra 4.1
  • ZIP-213
  • Zallet RPC
  • ZSA review
  • Build flags
  • Crosslink 4c
  • Zebra 4.1 includes new Prometheus metrics and mempool script checks aligned with ZcashD.
  • With the ZIP-213 implementation, a shielded coinbase block was created and tested on mainnet.
  • PRs piled up on the easy issues of the Zallet contributor board, and a draft get wallet status API was posted.
  • It was suggested that a ZIP or process document is needed to set the NU7 build flag rules for the whole stack.
Topics 9 · VideoRead more →
ARBORIST#117

New transaction format and consensus accounts

The former ECC team presented draft ZIPs for an extensible transaction format and consensus accounts.

  • Zebra 4.0
  • Extensible tx format
  • Consensus accounts
  • Crosslink 4c
  • Dynamic fees
  • Engineer opinions
  • Zebra 4.0.0 was released, and the Shielded Labs DNS seeder was added to the default peer list.
  • ZIPs PR 1156 contains a new transaction format that lets NU7 features be split into smaller releases.
  • A consensus accounts ZIP that generalizes the lockbox is also being drafted.
  • Adding a separate engineer vote and for-and-against opinion papers to the NU7 sentiment poll was discussed.
Topics 8 · VideoRead more →
ARBORIST#116

Zebra pushes shielded coinbase

Zebra pushed ZIP-213 shielded coinbase mining and pre-Canopy block support.

  • Zebra
  • ZIP-213
  • Zaino release
  • ZSA review
  • ZIP-233 audit
  • Crosslink
  • Zebra is working on a PR to support mining with shielded coinbase (ZIP-213) and on pre-Canopy subsidy support.
  • Zaino is nearly done with the work needed for Zallet support ahead of its first official release.
  • QEDIT is nearly finished addressing str4d's review of the Orchard ZSA PR.
  • The next Crosslink milestone is targeted for January 28, and a review by a mechanism design expert is underway.
Topics 7 · VideoRead more →
ARBORIST#115

ZcashD retirement timeline and dynamic fees

A retirement roadmap anchored to ZcashD end-of-support dates and a dynamic fee design were presented.

  • ZcashD retirement
  • Dynamic fees
  • Feature testnet
  • Zallet
  • Light wallet 0.4
  • Inversed
  • Pacu pointed to January 21 as the end of support for ZcashD 6.10 and September 9, 2026 as the next end-of-support point.
  • The trial period of running ZcashD and the new stack side by side was estimated at about 16 weeks.
  • Mark presented a design that recalculates the ZIP-317 marginal fee from the median of recent blocks.
  • Nate said they would personally convene a discussion on a shared feature testnet for ZSA, Crosslink and Tachyon.
Topics 8 · VideoRead more →
ARBORIST#114

ZIP-233 merged, Zebra 3.0

The ZIP-233 implementation PR was merged into Zebra, and the 3.0 stable release will come within days.

  • Zebra 3.0
  • ZIP-233
  • NU6.1
  • ZSA testnet
  • Zallet
  • Crosslink 4b
  • Shielded Labs' ZIP-233 implementation PR was merged into Zebra, and the Zebra 3.0.0 stable release is coming soon.
  • Wallet developers were told they must update the consensus branch ID before NU6.1 activates.
  • QEDIT added a finalize operation to the ZSA testnet and demonstrated issuance, transfer, burn and finalization.
  • The external NSM development team ends in late November, and Shielded Labs takes over the ZIP-234 and 235 work.
Topics 7 · VideoRead more →
ARBORIST#113

ZcashD retirement delayed to early 2026

Emergency response to the price surge pushed the ZcashD retirement steps back to early 2026.

  • ZcashD retirement
  • Zebra release
  • Zaino
  • Transparent data
  • Crosslink
  • ZIP-233
  • Zebra published a release candidate for NU6.1, and initial sync dropped from 24 hours to about 8 hours.
  • Pacu said the ZcashD retirement steps slip to after early 2026 because of urgent response work.
  • Work to put transparent data into compact blocks is under way in lightwalletd and Zaino.
  • Crosslink finished milestone 4a and moved to its own BFT implementation; the 4b workshop is targeted for early December.
Topics 8 · VideoRead more →
ARBORIST#112

Zebra 3 RC cuts sync time sharply

The Zebra 3 release candidate is out, and a full sync now takes 8 to 16 hours.

  • Zebra 3 RC
  • Sync speed
  • Zashi user surge
  • Crosslink workshop
  • Emergency patch
  • The Zebra 3 RC was published for NU6.1, and a full sync took 8.5 to 16 hours.
  • ECC focused on fixing wallet-backend bugs after the surge of new Zashi users.
  • In the Crosslink demo a node joined the roster through PoW headers, and a workshop was announced for October 22.
  • An issue was raised to prepare an emergency patch for Crosslink that turns PoS off and returns to PoW.
Topics 8 · VideoRead more →
ARBORIST#111

NU6.1 lockbox P2SH address generated

The P2SH address keys for lockbox disbursements are done, so the NU6.1 release is imminent.

  • NU6.1
  • Lockbox P2SH
  • ZIP-48
  • ZIP-255
  • Confirmation policy
  • Zebra health check
  • Str4d ran the key-generation procedure with the key-holding organizations, and the P2SH address was created.
  • The NU6.1 activation height was due to be reflected in ZIP 255 that day.
  • Zallet's default confirmations were set at 3 for trusted UTXOs and 10 for untrusted UTXOs.
  • A health-check endpoint for Kubernetes was merged into Zebra.
Topics 5 · VideoRead more →
ARBORIST#110

Zallet alpha released

The Zallet alpha is out and can be installed as a Docker image or Debian package.

  • Zallet alpha
  • Zashi cross-pay
  • Zebra state backup
  • Crosslink staking
  • 30-day unbonding
  • ECC released the Zallet alpha, with a Docker image and a Debian package.
  • Cross-chain payments through NEAR arrived in Zashi.
  • Zebra backs up the last 100 blocks of the non-finalized chain to a file and restores them on restart.
  • Investor feedback on Crosslink's 30-day unbonding design was discussed.
Topics 8 · VideoRead more →
ARBORIST#109

Orchard ZSA spec completion report

Qedit said Orchard ZSA is complete by the spec and will go into review soon.

  • Orchard ZSA
  • Zebra configuration
  • Crosslink staking
  • Quantum-resistant ZIP
  • Zallet alpha
  • Qedit said Orchard ZSA is spec complete and will soon turn to review.
  • Zebra replaced Sapling verification with librustzcash and added support for environment-variable configuration.
  • Daira Emma suggested drawing on Penumbra's private design for Crosslink staking.
  • Whether to ship the quantum-resistance change alongside NU7, and whether it is a consensus change, was discussed.
Topics 9 · VideoRead more →
ARBORIST#108

Small NU7 proposal draws pushback

ECC-side participants opposed Shielded Labs' proposal for a smaller NU7.

  • Small NU7
  • NSM
  • Explicit fees
  • Zebra 2.5.0
  • Halo 2 merge
  • Crosslink M3
  • Shielded Labs proposed a smaller NU7 centered on NSM and explicit fees.
  • Daira Emma opposed it, saying the benefit is small and moving transaction format changes forward is risky.
  • Kris worried that a plan including all transaction format changes is risky for zcashd.
  • Zebra 2.5.0 deployed NU6.1 to testnet, and Qedit's Halo 2 PR was merged.
Topics 8 · VideoRead more →
ARBORIST#107

zcashd 6.3.0 prepares for NU6.1

zcashd 6.3.0 was released, with NU6.1 testnet activation and the NSM merge under way.

  • zcashd 6.3.0
  • NU6.1 testnet
  • NSM merge
  • Zebra 2.5.0
  • PCZT ZIP
  • Crosslink M3
  • ECC released zcashd 6.3.0 for the NU6.1 testnet.
  • Shielded Labs' core NSM PR was merged into librustzcash.
  • Zebra 2.5.0, containing the NU6.1 testnet activation height, was due for release that day.
  • A new core team member, Schell, joined ECC, growing the staff by a third.
Topics 6 · VideoRead more →
ARBORIST#106

Debate over per-organization Zebra forks

A proposal to develop post-NU7 upgrades in per-organization forks sparked debate.

  • Zebra 2.4.0
  • NU6.1 schedule
  • Fork proposal
  • Zaino
  • Crosslink design
  • A DB upgrade bug in Zebra 2.4.0 led to that release being withdrawn and 2.4.1 being issued.
  • ECC said it plans the NU6.1 mainnet activation for October or November.
  • Zaino restructured non-finalized and finalized state as first-class objects.
  • Arya said forks are fine but releases from each fork are costly.
Topics 8 · VideoRead more →
ARBORIST#105

Zebra 2.4 DB upgrade announced

With the Zebra 2.4 release announced, backing up state was advised because of the DB upgrade.

  • Zebra 2.4
  • Zaino state
  • NSM review pending
  • Crosslink testing
  • Zingo wallet
  • Zebra 2.4 includes a DB upgrade, so state must be backed up in order to roll back.
  • Prometheus metrics become enabled by default in Zebra.
  • Zaino is finishing the representation of non-finalized and finalized state and improving its error-handling structure.
  • The NSM PR is waiting for ECC review, so the security audit schedule slipped.
Topics 5 · VideoRead more →
ARBORIST#104

Zebra RPC expansion and IPv6 default

Zebra added value pool queries and mempool change notifications, and IPv6 is now on by default.

  • Zebra RPC
  • IPv6 default
  • zcash_script
  • Qedit ZSA
  • Zallet alpha
  • Zebra added value pool queries to getblock and introduced a mempool change notification method.
  • Newly configured Zebra has IPv6 addresses enabled by default.
  • The zcash_script Rust implementation is compared against the C++ result and logs a warning on mismatch.
  • Qedit reported a ZIP change for issuance key rotation and the Halo 2 ZSA PR.
Topics 7 · VideoRead more →
ARBORIST#103

NU6.1 lockbox multisig keys requested

Testnet multisig key generation for the NU6.1 one-time lockbox disbursement was requested.

  • NU6.1
  • Lockbox disbursement
  • Zallet alpha
  • Crosslink M3
  • FROST key derivation
  • Kris asked the lockbox key-holding organizations to generate testnet multisig P2SH keys.
  • A NU6.1 network upgrade variant was added to Zebra and the lockbox disbursement PR was opened.
  • ECC implemented the NU6.1 lockbox one-time disbursement consensus change in zcashd.
  • The Zallet alpha is to include zcashd wallet migration and z_sendmany.
Topics 6 · VideoRead more →
ARBORIST#102

Crosslink Milestone 2 complete

Crosslink Milestone 2 is done, creating a one-way link from PoS to PoW.

  • Crosslink M2
  • ZSA Zebra PR
  • NSM
  • Excavator
  • zcash_unstable
  • Shielded Labs finished Crosslink Milestone 2 and put tokenomics at the top of its priorities.
  • Qedit opened the first Zebra PR that verifies ZSA transactions.
  • Str4d pointed out that the NSM Zebra PR must sit behind a flag so it cannot affect mainnet.
  • Zingo Labs released Excavator v0.
Topics 7 · VideoRead more →
ARBORIST#101

NU7 delay strains ZCG finances

The NU7 delay increased ZCG's burden of funding ZSA, and a clearer schedule was requested.

  • ZCG finances
  • NU7 delay
  • Zewif
  • Zebra 2.3.0
  • Zallet Zsend
  • Mainnet shadowing
  • ZCG said it has funded Qedit at $105,000 per month for five months.
  • Kris answered that the NU7 schedule cannot be set on the spot and that ZSA PR review is slow.
  • With Crosslink Milestone 2 in its final stage, a mainnet shadowing workshop was announced.
  • Zebra 2.3.0 was released and Zsend was merged into Zallet.
Topics 6 · VideoRead more →
ARBORIST#100

zcashd-to-Zebra migration tool proposed

A draft migration tool that moves zcashd block data into Zebra state was shown.

  • zcashd migration
  • OpenRPC
  • Zebra 2.3
  • Zaino M3
  • Crosslink BFT
  • Wishlist
  • Str4d opened an initial example that turns a zcashd node into Zebra state, as PR 9472.
  • OpenRPC support was added to Zallet so the RPC schema can be queried.
  • In Zebra 2.3 the RPC endpoint of the Docker image is disabled by default.
  • Crosslink's BFT blocks now carry a real payload containing an array of PoW headers.
Topics 8 · VideoRead more →
ARBORIST#99

Quantum-resistant design explained in detail

Str4d explained in detail the design for hardening note commitments against quantum attacks.

  • Quantum resistance
  • zcashd 6.2.0
  • Zallet
  • FROST keys
  • ZSA upstream
  • zcashd 6.2.0 was released, and an upgrade was advised ahead of the end of support for 6.1.0.
  • The Zallet team said it is migrating zcashd wallet.dat with the Zewif tool.
  • Str4d said there is still a chance to align the FROST key structure with quantum resistance.
  • Str4d wants to ship this change with NU7 and said the only consensus change is shielded coinbase.
Topics 9 · VideoRead more →
ARBORIST#98

Note construction change for quantum readiness

A proposal to change note construction so notes remain usable after quantum computers was introduced.

  • Quantum readiness
  • Orchard notes
  • FROST key generation
  • Zebra Docker
  • Crosslink M2
  • Daira Emma introduced a proposal to change Orchard note construction to make post-quantum use possible.
  • FROST key generation also needs to change to match, and Daira Emma agreed to handle the fix.
  • Zebra Docker was changed so the RPC endpoint is disabled by default.
  • Zallet syncs the chain using Zingo as a data source and has begun work on z_send.
Topics 8 · VideoRead more →
ARBORIST#97

ZIP security and privacy sections debated

The lack of security and privacy sections in most NU7 candidate ZIPs was discussed.

  • Crosslink M1
  • ZIP process
  • ZIP-231
  • Zenith FROST
  • Notetaker
  • Shielded Labs finished Crosslink Milestone 1 and set June 1 as the target for Milestone 2.
  • Zallet now syncs the chain using Zaino as a library.
  • Kris acknowledged that ZIP 231 has no security and privacy section and agreed to add one.
  • Jason said that day was the last day of the community notetaker.
Topics 7 · VideoRead more →
ARBORIST#96

NU7 config flag convention discussed

The account metadata key ZIP 325 and the config flag approach for NU7 were discussed.

  • ZIP-325
  • Tor transport
  • Livestream dispute
  • Config flag
  • Zebra peer banning
  • ECC wrote ZIP 325, which defines account metadata keys.
  • The mobile SDK now fetches and submits transactions over Tor.
  • Zebra finished score-based peer banning and was asked to document it.
  • Daira Emma strongly objected to livestreaming the Arborist call on X.
Topics 10 · VideoRead more →
ARBORIST#95

Zebra 2.2.0 released

Zebra 2.2.0 was released and the FROST client and server went into audit.

  • Zebra 2.2.0
  • Zallet
  • ZSA
  • FROST audit
  • Crosslink
  • Zebra 2.2.0 includes a branch ID consensus rule check and the switch to jsonrpsee.
  • Zallet began actually serving some zcashd RPC APIs.
  • The FROST audit began, and a presentation is scheduled for the February 19 community call.
  • The generalization of Zcash note encryption for ZSA was merged upstream.
Topics 9 · VideoRead more →
ARBORIST#94

NU7 October at earliest, Sprout alternative

An outlook that NU7 comes in October at the earliest and a ZSA-based Sprout redemption idea were discussed.

  • NU7 schedule
  • Lockbox extension
  • Sprout retirement
  • Zallet
  • Zaino delay
  • Str4d said a network upgrade including ZSA is hard before October.
  • Josh proposed extending the lockbox by one year and either putting it in NU7 or splitting it into a separate upgrade.
  • ECC presented a plan to turn Sprout balances into a synthetic asset via ZSA and redeem it for ZEC.
  • Zallet aimed to have its surrounding infrastructure in place by the end of February.
Topics 10 · VideoRead more →
ARBORIST#93

NSM "burn" terminology dispute

A terminology dispute arose over what NSM's "burn" does to the supply cap.

  • NSM
  • ZIP-233
  • zcashd 6.1.0
  • FROST DKG
  • ZSA audit
  • Zebra moved its JSON RPC server to a new framework and skipped redundant verification.
  • zcashd 6.1.0 was released, and 6.0.0 loses support in about two weeks.
  • The FROST DKG implementation is done, leaving only adding a broadcast channel and the audit.
  • Dodger agreed to the term "retraction" proposed by Kris instead of "burn".
Topics 9 · VideoRead more →
ARBORIST#92

Positive ZSA audit, NU7 scope discussed

The ZSA audit came back positive, and the scope of ZIPs to include in NU7 was discussed.

  • ZSA
  • NU7
  • PCZT
  • NSM
  • Zebra 2.1.0
  • zcashd deprecation
  • It was reported that Least Authority's ZSA audit report came back without major issues
  • The PCZT v1 format is finished and the first crate release is coming up
  • Zebra 2.1.0 fixed a mempool bug in consensus branch ID validation
  • Daira said they support ZIP-233 and ZIP-234 but oppose ZIP-235
Topics 10 · VideoRead more →
ARBORIST#91

NSM poll, skepticism about ZIP-235

An NSM poll got under way, and some argued that ZIP-235's benefit is low relative to its complexity.

  • NSM
  • ZIP-233
  • ZIP-235
  • Crosslink
  • FROST server
  • Zebra
  • In the ZecHub poll, 20 active community members unanimously supported including NSM in NU7
  • Arya expected the ZIP editors to recommend including ZIP-233
  • Some argued ZIP-235 is better added as a standard rule after NU7
  • The FROST server was changed to authenticate with key pairs, so it no longer needs a database
Topics 5 · VideoRead more →
ARBORIST#90

NU6 activation on November 23 approaches

NU6 is set to activate on November 23, and the NSM ZIP schedule was adjusted.

  • NU6 activation
  • NSM
  • Zaino RPC
  • PCZT
  • FROST
  • ZSA ZIP
  • NU6 is set to activate on Saturday, November 23, so ZF and ECC agreed to watch it together
  • Kris judged that ZIP-233 and ZIP-234 are polished enough to go into NU7
  • They decided to move the NSM ZIP-234 activation height to a later point
  • For Zaino, a structure was raised of building a semantics-focused gRPC and layering JSON RPC on top of it
Topics 9 · VideoRead more →
ARBORIST#89

NU7 ZIP draft deadline nears

Ahead of the NU7 ZIP draft deadline, a scaled-down NSM proposal and a Sprout deactivation proposal emerged.

  • NU7 ZIPs
  • NSM
  • Zallet
  • PCZT
  • Zebra 2.0.1
  • Memo bundle
  • It was announced that Zebra 2.0.0 panics at NU6, so 2.0.1 must be used
  • ECC started a binary tentatively named Zallet as the zcashd wallet replacement
  • The NSM team proposed an alternative of including only the ZIP-233 burn feature in NU7
  • Daira submitted a ZIP that blocks v4 transactions, effectively switching Sprout off
Topics 10 · VideoRead more →
ARBORIST#88

ZSF renamed NSM, NU7 candidate

ZSF was renamed NSM, and there was an intention to put it forward as an NU7 candidate.

  • NSM
  • zcashd 6.0.0
  • PCZT
  • Crosslink
  • Zebra 2.0
  • ZCG process
  • zcashd 6.0.0 was released with NU6 support, and upgrading before November 5 was recommended
  • ZSF is renamed Network Sustainability Mechanism, using the terms burn and reissue
  • Daira and Kris objected to the burn terminology and to the ZIP consensus rules
  • ZIPs must be submitted as PRs by November 5 to have a chance of inclusion in NU7
Topics 10 · VideoRead more →
ARBORIST#87

Cause of the testnet stall identified

The cause of the testnet stall was explained, and preparation for the zcashd 6.0.0 release was wrapped up.

  • testnet bug
  • zcashd 6.0.0
  • Zebra 2.0.0
  • zcashd deprecation
  • wallet RPC
  • Sean Bowe
  • The testnet stall came from a difference in header sync combined with a block time limit bug
  • ECC said the 6.0.0 release is the version that sets the NU6 activation height
  • Sean Bowe left ECC and will research Zcash scalability under independent funding
  • Kris and Daira differed on how far to keep zcashd wallet RPC compatibility
Topics 7 · VideoRead more →
ARBORIST#86

CLI wallet and Zaino indexer architecture agreed

Participants agreed on the Zaino indexer architecture for the CLI wallet that replaces zcashd.

  • zcashd deprecation
  • Zaino
  • Indexer
  • NU6 audit
  • CLI wallet
  • ZSA
  • Least Authority's preliminary NU6 audit report had two suggestions on documentation and error handling
  • Zingo Labs adjusted the grant to drop wallet development and take on only the Zaino indexer
  • Most agreed with a structure in which Zaino also provides the lightwallet gRPC
  • The ZSA team said it is discussing the Orchard ZSA audit with Least Authority
Topics 8 · VideoRead more →
ARBORIST#85

NU6 testnet activated, mining stopped

NU6 activated on testnet, but the miners disappeared and the chain stalled.

  • NU6 testnet
  • zcashd 5.10.0
  • testnet mining
  • Crosslink
  • zcashd deprecation
  • FROST
  • The NU6 testnet activation succeeded and zcashd 5.10.0 was released
  • Existing testnet miners did not upgrade, so the chain stalled and needed recovery
  • Zebra 1.9.0 came out with the testnet activation height
  • Shielded Labs said it plans to build a Crosslink prototype in stages
Topics 7 · VideoRead more →
ARBORIST#84

Crosslink v1 requirements published

zcashd 5.10.0-rc1 came out, and Zooko presented the Crosslink v1 requirements.

  • zcashd 5.10.0
  • NU6 testnet
  • Crosslink v1
  • ZSF
  • FROST server
  • Zebra 1.9
  • zcashd 5.10.0-rc1 contains the full NU6 consensus rules and 2 security patches
  • From NU6, blocks must claim all fees and balance exactly
  • Zooko published the target feature list for Crosslink v1 and asked for input
  • ECC put full transparent wallet history recovery into the SDK
Topics 9Read more →
ARBORIST#83

NU6 testnet activation delayed

The NU6 testnet activation was postponed, and the ZSA fee structure was discussed.

  • NU6 testnet
  • lockbox
  • ZSA fees
  • Shielded Labs
  • Zooko
  • FROST
  • The NU6 testnet activation was pushed back until after zcashd debugging and private testnet verification
  • Zebra implemented the lockbox funding stream and the ZIP-236 coinbase balance rule
  • Zooko joined Shielded Labs as head of product and announced TFL collaboration
  • Vanilla ZSA can be deployed after an audit, and fees are expected to be paid in ZEC
Topics 9Read more →
ARBORIST#82

NU6 lockbox implementation and zcashd deprecation

NU6 lockbox implementation is progressing in both nodes, and collaboration on the zcashd deprecation was discussed.

  • NU6
  • lockbox
  • zcashd deprecation
  • ZSA asset swaps
  • ZCG
  • FROST
  • ECC and ZF are implementing the lockbox feature so that only a configuration value needs to change
  • Opinions were raised that the August 8 NU6 testnet activation is a tight schedule
  • ECC merged Tor-based exchange rate lookup into the Rust crates
  • ZCG will attend the Arborist Call from now on to introduce proposals
Topics 10Read more →
ARBORIST#81

Zebra 1.8.0 and the scanner split

Zebra 1.8.0 came out, and NU6 testnet activation was added to the agenda.

  • Zebra 1.8.0
  • ZIP-320
  • Zebra Scan
  • FROST refresh
  • TZE
  • Z|ECC Summit
  • Zebra 1.8.0 was released with the default free action limit changed to 0
  • The Zebra scanner was split into a separate binary and returns only txids
  • August 8 was mentioned as the target date for NU6 testnet activation
  • ECC said it will publish its roadmap next week after the July summit
Topics 7Read more →
ARBORIST#80

ZSF excluded from NU6, ZSA encryption dispute

ZSF will not be in NU6, and opinions differed on ZSA verified encryption.

  • ZSF
  • NU6
  • ZSA verified encryption
  • FROST 2.0
  • Zebra 1.8.0
  • Zcash script
  • It was confirmed that the ZSF team is not targeting NU6 and announced this on the forum
  • FROST 2.0.0-rc0 was released with no_std support and simplified serialization
  • Zebra split the scanner out of Zebrad and previewed the 1.8.0 release
  • Daira and Kris voiced concern that the issuer key could become a honeypot
Topics 8 · VideoRead more →
ARBORIST#79

NU6 ZIP deadline and the Dev Fund

A deadline for NU6 ZIP submissions was proposed, and the design space for the Dev Fund lockbox was discussed.

  • NU6
  • Dev Fund
  • lockbox
  • ZIP-317
  • Arti
  • FROST
  • Kris proposed getting the NU6 ZIPs to proposed status by the July 16 ZIP editors' meeting
  • Daira will share a design space document for the Dev Fund lockbox approach on the forum
  • ECC will lower the default free action limit to 0 in the next zcashd release
  • Str4d finished a prototype that looks up exchange rates over Tor via Arti
Topics 8 · VideoRead more →
ARBORIST#78

zcash script API simplified

Conrado's simplified zcash script API entered the review stage.

  • zcash script
  • zcashd 5.9.1
  • Zashi exchange rate
  • Zebra Scan
  • Plonkish
  • zcash script was changed to compute the sighash through a callback instead of a transaction pointer
  • zcashd 5.9.1 came out including the TEX address validation API for Binance
  • For Zashi exchange rate lookup, signed data and a lightwalletd proxy are being considered in parallel
  • ECC described a plan to run the Rust script interpreter in parallel for verification in NU6
Topics 7Read more →
ARBORIST#77

Memo key: note plaintext vs KDF debate

Participants debated whether to put the memo bundle key in the note plaintext or derive it with a KDF.

  • Memo bundle
  • Zebra 1.7.0
  • Binance TEX
  • ZSA ZIPs
  • Zashi exchange rate
  • Zebra 1.7.0 was released with regtest and custom testnet support
  • The proposal to extend Zebra's end-of-support period was withdrawn and reverted to 16 weeks
  • At Binance's request, ECC will add a TEX address check RPC to zcashd
  • Many attendees thought the original design of putting the key in the note plaintext is simpler
Topics 8Read more →
ARBORIST#76

Memo bundle design overview published

The requirements and a draft design for the NU6 memo bundle were presented for the first time and discussed.

  • Memo bundle
  • Zashi Android
  • zcashd deprecation
  • ZSA testnet
  • FROST refresh
  • Zashi 1.0 Android launched and recorded roughly 1,600 installs
  • The memo bundle proposal replaces the 512-byte per-output memo with a 32-byte key
  • Zebra's minimal regtest works and Windows support was restored
  • The ZSA team began building a testnet for ZSA
Topics 9Read more →
ARBORIST#75

NU6 candidates and the zcashd deprecation plan

Participants held a long discussion of NU6 candidate features, the ZIP process and the zcashd deprecation schedule.

  • NU6
  • ZSF
  • zcashd deprecation
  • Memo bundle
  • Transient testnet
  • ZIP process
  • zcashd 5.9.0 RC1 was tagged, with the final version due the next day
  • ZSA, ZSF, an explicit fee field and the memo bundle were mentioned as NU6 candidates
  • ECC said it put a June transient testnet for NU6 on its roadmap
  • They decided to hold an additional NU6 meeting and make the zcashd deprecation an agenda item at every call
Topics 9 · VideoRead more →
ARBORIST#74

Zashi 1.0 iOS launched

Zashi 1.0 for iOS launched on the App Store, and resuming ZSF work was discussed.

  • Zashi 1.0
  • ZSF
  • ZSA compatibility
  • Zebra testnet
  • ZconV
  • Zashi 1.0 iOS is out on the App Store, and the Android version is in testing
  • Zebra's ZSF implementation is 60-70% complete, with the goal of progressing before the halving
  • The ZSA team is finishing backward compatibility work and began discussing a protocol audit
  • A PR with network parameters for custom testnets was opened in Zebra
Topics 5 · VideoRead more →
ARBORIST#73

Routine zcashd maintenance release announced

Orchard support stabilization is in its final stretch, and a zcashd maintenance release was announced.

  • Orchard support
  • zcashd
  • Zebra regtest
  • FROST
  • Zebra scan
  • Orchard support in ECC's mobile SDK has entered the final stabilization stage
  • A zcashd maintenance release is coming soon to update librustzcash and extend the EOS
  • An OpenAPI specification generator for the Zebra RPC was added and the regtest work continues
  • The FROST re-randomized paper was published on ePrint
Topics 3Read more →
ARBORIST#72

ZSA stablecoin roadmap discussion

The ZSA team said it will include stablecoin support in its 2024 roadmap.

  • ZSA
  • Stablecoin
  • Zebra 1.6.0
  • TEX addresses
  • Crosslink
  • Zebra 1.6.0 was released and Windows support in zcash script was restored
  • zcash_address 0.3.2 recognizes ZIP-320 TEX addresses and returns an unsupported error
  • Daira reported having a Comet BFT technical meeting with Zaki Manian
  • The ZSA team proposed exchange compatibility and verifiable encryption for issuers as 2024 work
Topics 5Read more →
ARBORIST#71

FROST 1.0 release and TEX addresses

The stable FROST 1.0.0 was released, and the Binance response was settled on a TEX address approach.

  • FROST 1.0.0
  • ZIP-320
  • TEX address
  • Zashi 1.0
  • Zebra scanner
  • Experimental features
  • FROST 1.0.0 fixed a vulnerability where DKG commitment lengths were not verified (reported by Trail of Bits).
  • ECC expects Zashi 1.0 in late March, and security audits are underway starting with iOS.
  • The Binance response will be finalized using the TEX-encoded address approach of ZIP-320.
  • The ECC and Zebra teams held a first meeting on the features needed to replace zcashd.
Topics 5 · VideoRead more →
ARBORIST#70

Asset swap ZIP-228 draft submitted

QEDIT submitted an asset swap ZIP draft, and Daira became an ECC engineering manager.

  • ZIP-228
  • Asset swap
  • Zebra scanner
  • SDK 2.1
  • ZconV
  • ZKProof 6
  • QEDIT posted the asset swap draft as ZIP-228, PR 780.
  • A gRPC frontend is being attached to the Zebra scanner, and a Docker Compose file is being added.
  • QEDIT's transaction testing tool was requested to be merged upstream.
  • Daira became ECC's R&D engineering manager and steps down as a ZIP editor at the end of February.
Topics 8Read more →
ARBORIST#69

Nate leaves ECC; TFL overview

Nate said they are leaving ECC, and an overview of the Trailing Finality Layer and Crosslink was presented.

  • TFL
  • Crosslink
  • UA revision
  • Zebra 1.5.2
  • FROST 1.0.0
  • Nate's departure
  • Nate said they will leave ECC after Zeboot next week.
  • Crosslink is a hybrid design that combines PoW and BFT to obtain finality.
  • The team decided to call for proposals for a new HRP for the UA revision that uses Must Understand metadata.
  • FROST will soon make its 1.0.0 stable release, and review of ZIP-312 is underway.
Topics 7 · VideoRead more →
ARBORIST#68

Binance exchange address proposal approved

Binance technically approved the exchange address proposal, but development was put on hold until its review is complete.

  • Binance
  • Exchange address
  • Zebra mining
  • zksend
  • URI payments
  • Zenith wallet
  • Binance passed the technical review but will approve development only after its compliance review is finished.
  • An experimental, test-only built-in mining feature was added to Zebra.
  • ZIP-317 and Orchard support in the SDK is expected within a week or two.
  • Jon showed a revocable payment method with a zksend demo based on Sui zkLogin.
Topics 11 · VideoRead more →
ARBORIST#67

zcashd maintenance and NU6 deadline discussion

Discussion that the NU6 deadline makes the move to Zebra urgent led to a decision to recruit a task force to maintain zcashd.

  • NU6
  • zcashd maintenance
  • Zebra scanning
  • Crosslink
  • ZSF
  • ZSA regulation
  • Kris said the move to Zebra is needed within 5-6 months for NU6 before the halving.
  • Zebra 1.5.0 included an MVP for scanning the blockchain with Sapling viewing keys.
  • The ZSF 60/40 fee split was estimated at about 800 ZEC per year, or $24,000.
  • An in-depth Crosslink presentation by the TFL team will be given on the February Arborist call.
Topics 7 · VideoRead more →
ARBORIST#66

First mainnet block mined with Zebra

Marek shared the first case of mining a mainnet block with Zebra, and FROST 1.0.0-rc.0 was released.

  • Zebra 1.5.0
  • FROST rc.0
  • Crosslink
  • Sandblasting
  • Zebra mining
  • Zebra 1.5.0 will include experimental shielded scanning and network fixes following Ziggurat.
  • FROST 1.0.0-rc.0 was published and is collecting API feedback.
  • Crosslink stays safe as long as only one of its two subprotocols is secure.
  • Str4d said mempool spam has almost disappeared since mid-November.
Topics 8 · VideoRead more →
ARBORIST#65

DZFE working group decided

ECC is pursuing a working group for technical decentralization, and news on Zebra 1.4.0 was shared.

  • DZFE
  • Zebra 1.4.0
  • SDK Orchard
  • ZIP-317
  • TFL Book
  • ZSF implementation
  • The ECC SDK does not yet support Orchard or ZIP-317, and Orchard support is the top priority.
  • The official repositories for the Zashi app and the SDK were moved to the Electric Coin Company organization.
  • Eiger started the ZSF implementation in Zebra, and Pili will be the point of contact for collaboration on Zebra.
  • TFL Book 0.1.0 was released, putting Crosslink into the documentation.
Topics 8 · VideoRead more →
ARBORIST#64

ECC emergency mode officially ends

ECC declared the end of emergency mode, and the NU5 retrospective will begin in four weeks.

  • End of emergency mode
  • Zebra 1.4.0
  • Crosslink
  • NU5 retrospective
  • ZSA
  • FROST audit
  • Emergency mode ended after all three wallets shipped SDK 2.0 and users regained access to their funds.
  • Zebra 1.4.0 puts the mining RPCs in the production build and embeds the proving parameters.
  • The FROST audit report was published on the NCC site.
  • QEDIT is building a pseudo-v6 transaction tool for testing ZSA in Zebra.
Topics 6 · VideoRead more →
ARBORIST#63

Zebra 1.3.0 and SDK 2.0.3

Zebra 1.3.0 fully supports Spend-before-Sync, and the SDK 2.0.3 release is imminent.

  • Zebra 1.3.0
  • SDK 2.0.3
  • Edge wallet
  • ZSA
  • Crosslink
  • FROST
  • Zebra 1.3.0 put the progress bar in the default build and fixed a mining RPC performance bug.
  • Edge's Paul Puey said Edge will follow the SDK's supported scope and aims for a store release early next week.
  • QEDIT posted ZSA circuit optimization PRs to halo2 and orchard.
  • The Crosslink draft now includes a liveness argument, and the simulator simtfl was published.
Topics 5 · VideoRead more →
ARBORIST#62

Crosslink design first shown

Daira introduced the Crosslink design that improves on ebb and flow, and the NU5 retrospective schedule will be revisited in four weeks.

  • Crosslink
  • zcashd 5.7.0
  • ZSF ZIPs
  • Issuance curve
  • NU5 retrospective
  • FROST
  • zcashd 5.7.0 was released, and 5.6.1 halts at EOS on October 11.
  • The activation timing and rationale for issuance curve smoothing, one of the three ZSF ZIPs, was discussed.
  • An opinion was raised that including v6 transactions, ZSA and ZSF would fill the upgrade complexity budget.
  • The Minor Grants vote has 20 applications totaling over $225,000 against a budget of $75,000.
Topics 8 · VideoRead more →
ARBORIST#61

Mobile SDK 2.0 RC3 released

The iOS and Android SDKs reached the RC3 stage, and the official 2.0.0 release is set for Monday.

  • SDK 2.0.0
  • zcashd bundle
  • FROST audit
  • TFL
  • ZSA circuit
  • ZIP editors
  • SDK 2.0.0 uses a fixed fee of 10,000 zatoshi, with ZIP-317 postponed to the next release.
  • The zcashd update bundles the proving parameters in the binary, so no separate download is needed.
  • Zebra finished spend-before-sync support and is starting work on a Sapling scanning wallet.
  • Adi joined the ZIP editors, making the editors Daira, Str4d, Conrado, Adi and teor.
Topics 7 · VideoRead more →
ARBORIST#60

Deirdre leaves; SDK release candidate imminent

The mobile SDK release candidate is imminent, and Deirdre said they are leaving the Zcash Foundation.

  • Mobile SDK
  • Zebra 1.2
  • ZIP editors
  • Detection Keys
  • TFL
  • FROST
  • Deirdre leaves the ZF after their last day on September 13 and also steps down as a ZIP editor.
  • Zebra 1.2 added an automatic DB upgrade framework and subtree root support.
  • Adding ZIP editors and formalizing editor-consensus decision-making were proposed.
  • Jack Gavigan put Detection Keys and Liberated Payments on the formal agenda.
Topics 9 · VideoRead more →
ARBORIST#59

ZIP-317 wallet outreach discussion

A discussion that wallet vendors need to be contacted ahead of ZIP-317 enforcement led the ZF to take it on.

  • ZIP-317
  • Zebra DB
  • FROST audit
  • ZSA
  • ZSF
  • Detection Keys
  • Zebra reduced its DB from 278GB to 244GB by deduplicating note commitment trees.
  • Zooko said they are taking over ECC engineering management and product after Nick's departure.
  • The FROST audit found only medium and low issues, all of which were fixed.
  • The second round of ZF Minor Grants opened, supporting up to $25,000.
Topics 10Read more →
ARBORIST#58

SDK fast spending and ZIP-317 support

ECC said it will soon release Spend-before-Sync and ZIP-317 support in the mobile SDK.

  • Spend-before-sync
  • ZIP-317
  • Mobile SDK
  • TFL
  • ZSF
  • The SDK changes to show a transaction proposal first and create the transaction after approval.
  • Zebra stopped storing note commitment trees per height and posted a PR to clean up existing trees.
  • Nate is designing a trailing finality protocol for the move to PoS.
  • Shielded Labs will post the first ZSF ZIP draft to the forum next week.
Topics 5Read more →
ARBORIST#57

Spend-before-Sync completed

ECC finished the Rust work for Spend-before-Sync, and Zebra 1.1.0 was released.

  • Spend-before-sync
  • Zebra 1.1.0
  • lightwalletd
  • FROST audit
  • zcashd 5.7.0
  • ECC finished the Rust components of Spend-before-Sync and announced crate publication next week.
  • lightwalletd's getsubtreeroots had a bug that returned an empty result when given 0.
  • Zebra 1.1.0 refuses to start on an invalid subcommand and upgrades the DB while running.
  • The FROST audit found no critical issues, and the final report is targeted for the end of August.
Topics 6Read more →
ARBORIST#56

Ledger app lacks ZIP-32 support

An audit of the Ledger app raised the issue that it does not support ZIP-32 key derivation.

  • Ledger
  • ZIP-32
  • Zebra 1.0.1
  • ZSF
  • FROST v14
  • Ziggurat
  • Taylor Hornby pointed out that the Ledger app is based on BIP-32, which breaks seed compatibility.
  • Shielded Labs started ZSF development, with writing two ZIPs as its first goal.
  • Zebra 1.0.1 fixed connection security bugs and panics and reduced CPU usage.
  • The Ziggurat red team found 4 Zebra bugs, and the late slot moves to 21:00 UTC.
Topics 9Read more →
ARBORIST#55

Zebra audit report published

NCC Group published the final Zebra audit report, and the zcashd 5.6.1 hotfix was released.

  • Zebra audit
  • zcashd 5.6.1
  • ZSA
  • FROST
  • hacspec
  • DAGSync
  • zcashd 5.6.1 fixed a note commitment tree bug in the Orchard wallet introduced in 5.6.0.
  • The Zebra audit found one medium-severity issue, and the rest were low or informational.
  • QEDIT changed how nullifiers are derived for ZSA split notes and prepared a circuit PDF.
  • Daira announced that they are looking for a third ZIP editor volunteer.
Topics 8Read more →
ARBORIST#54

Zebra 1.0.0 official release

The stable Zebra 1.0.0 was released, and zcashd 5.6.0 was published the day before.

  • Zebra 1.0.0
  • zcashd 5.6.0
  • Emergency mode
  • FROST
  • lightwalletd
  • Zcon4
  • zcashd 5.6.0 was released as the first of three steps to resolve emergency mode.
  • Zebra 1.0.0 was published on crates.io and Docker Hub.
  • Nighthawk released a Zcash testnet block explorer.
  • A change to the late slot time was postponed until after Zcon.
Topics 6Read more →
ARBORIST#53

ECC restructuring and zcashd 5.6.0

ECC's restructuring was mentioned, and zcashd 5.6.0 is being prepared around the fast sync API.

  • ECC restructuring
  • zcashd 5.6.0
  • ZSA fees
  • FROST
  • ZIP editors
  • The ZF decided to bring forward a second minor grants round for affected staff.
  • Applying multi-scalar multiplication to FROST group commitments made it more than 50% faster.
  • QEDIT proposed 1 ZEC for ZSA issuance and a transfer fee indistinguishable from ZEC's.
  • Nighthawk unveiled infrastructure with four clusters in North America, Europe, Asia and Brazil.
Topics 7Read more →
ARBORIST#52

Zebra rc.8 and ZSA stablecoins

The Zebra audit is wrapping up without major problems, and the possibility of ZSA stablecoins was discussed.

  • Zebra rc.8
  • zcashd 5.5.1
  • FROST
  • ZSA stablecoin
  • Network upgrades
  • Zebra rc.8 added a feature that stops running 16 weeks after release, like zcashd.
  • zcashd 5.5.1 fixed a ZIP-317 fee calculation error and a crash bug.
  • The core features of the FROST library are complete and will soon be audited.
  • It was decided to begin discussions on coordinating network upgrades among organizations starting in June.
Topics 5Read more →
ARBORIST#51

zcashd 5.5.0 and ZIP-317

zcashd 5.5.0 was released with ZIP-317 proportional fees, and the Zebra audit entered its second phase.

  • zcashd 5.5.0
  • ZIP-317
  • Zebra audit
  • ZSA
  • FROST
  • Network crawler
  • zcashd 5.5.0 includes ZIP-317 fees and a unified approach to wallet transaction creation.
  • Zebra entered audit phase 2 and implemented a default that shuts down after 120 days, like zcashd.
  • Equilibrium said there are about 200 mainnet nodes, with Zebra under 10%.
  • QEDIT posted its ZSA asset swap plan on the forum, targeting a testnet before Zcon4.
Topics 7Read more →
ARBORIST#50

ZIP-317 in zcashd 5.5.0

The zcashd 5.5.0 release candidate, which includes the ZIP 317 changes, was approved and is due for release next week.

  • zcashd 5.5.0
  • ZIP-317
  • FROST crates
  • Technical collaboration forum
  • NU5 retrospective
  • NUP overhaul
  • The zcashd 5.5.0 release candidate was approved and is expected to ship early next week once CI passes.
  • The Zcash Foundation published all FROST implementations on crates.io, and the IRTF chair passed the specification.
  • The Zcash R&D category on the Zcash forum was opened for anyone to read and will be used as a technical collaboration space.
  • The NU5 retrospective was postponed until after June, and the team discussed overhauling the network upgrade process before NU6.
Topics 7Read more →
ARBORIST#49

DAGSync non-linear sync design

The DAGSync design for fast sync was shared, and it was corrected that Zelcash/Flux, not Firo, had been confusing the network.

  • DAGSync
  • ZIP-317
  • zcashd 5.5.0
  • Zebra audit
  • lightwalletd
  • Flux nodes
  • Kris described a sync approach that fetches recent blocks first instead of syncing linearly, so existing notes can be spent right away.
  • Whether to put ZIP 317 fee enforcement in zcashd 5.5.0 was not yet decided because wallet adoption is lacking.
  • As audit findings, Zebra limited the number of unconfirmed chains and excluded fake nodes from its address book.
  • With no dedicated maintainer for lightwalletd, the team will discuss having ECC and ZF take it on together.
Topics 7Read more →
ARBORIST#48

Halborn vulnerability and network monitoring

After the response to the memory exhaustion vulnerability was completed, the Ziggurat crawler and public network monitoring were discussed.

  • Halborn disclosure
  • Network monitoring
  • Ziggurat
  • Firo nodes
  • Zebra audit
  • The memory exhaustion DoS vulnerability found by Halborn was disclosed, and ECC and ZF finished the mitigation work.
  • The Zebra audit has so far turned up only low-severity or informational issues.
  • The Ziggurat crawler saw about 6000 nodes, but it was pointed out that Firo nodes may be mixed in.
  • The team will schedule a meeting with the ECC infrastructure team to discuss open-sourcing the monitoring tools.
Topics 4 · VideoRead more →
ARBORIST#47

Orchard circuit layout bug fix

A Halo 2 circuit layout bug that made Orchard proofs fail on 32-bit environments was resolved and will be included in the next crates.

  • Orchard circuit bug
  • zcashd 5.5.0
  • ZIP-317
  • FROST
  • Zebra audit
  • Halo 2
  • A circuit layout bug that relied on an unstable sort function blocked Orchard spends in 32-bit wallets, but no funds were lost.
  • zcashd 5.5.0 supports ZIP 317 in both the wallet and block generation and is due for release in 3 to 4 weeks.
  • The FROST crates were published as 0.1.0, and the RFC is going through review by the CFRG chair.
  • The first results of the Zebra security audit came in and are being turned into issues; the auditor is NCC.
Topics 8 · VideoRead more →
ARBORIST#46

Feature-specific testnets and Zebra rc5

Zebra became ready for mining pool testing, and how to stand up feature-specific testnets was discussed at length.

  • Zebra rc5
  • zcashd 5.4.1
  • Feature-specific testnets
  • ZIP-317
  • Minor Grants
  • FROST
  • Zebra rc5 finished the mining-related RPCs, so mining pools can now test it.
  • zcashd 5.4.1 fixed a problem where settings for features slated for deprecation did not take effect in the config file.
  • Zebra said it implements only ZIP-317 and has already implemented the block construction part.
  • The Zcash Foundation launched Minor Grants of up to $25,000 each, with a total of $75,000.
Topics 8 · VideoRead more →
ARBORIST#45

Zebra mining success and zcashd 5.4.0

Testnet blocks were successfully mined with Zebra, and zcashd 5.4.0 exposed the total supply and the transparent pool balance.

  • Zebra rc.4
  • zcashd 5.4.0
  • FROST
  • ZIP-216
  • ZSA
  • PoS
  • The Zebra team mined several blocks on the testnet using a modified s-nomp and a CPU miner.
  • zcashd 5.4.0 shows the total supply and transparent pool size in getblockchaininfo on reindexed nodes.
  • Some RPCs slated for deprecation, such as getnewaddress, are now disabled by default, and 5.5.0 centers on ZIP 317 support.
  • ZIP-216 is being applied retroactively, and QEDIT submitted a PR implementing ZSA transfers.
Topics 6 · VideoRead more →
ARBORIST#44

zcashd 5.4.0 and supply tracking

zcashd added tracking of the total chain supply and the transparent pool balance, and unclaimed fees were confirmed at about 368.58 ZEC.

  • zcashd 5.4.0
  • Total supply
  • Posterity Fund
  • Zebra mining RPCs
  • Wolfram
  • FROST
  • zcashd tracks the transparent pool and chain supply, and unclaimed fees were confirmed at 368.5844552 ZEC.
  • Zebra added RPCs for mining pools, including getblocksubsidy and the getblocktemplate proposal mode.
  • FROST specification v12 was released and is going through the IRTF approval process.
  • Wolfram Blockchain Labs introduced a plan to integrate Zcash into the Wolfram Language.
Topics 5 · VideoRead more →
ARBORIST#43

612-byte ZSA note ciphertext

A 32-byte ZSA asset identifier is added to the note ciphertext, and Zebra released rc.3.

  • ZSA
  • Zebra rc.3
  • FROST
  • shardtree
  • TZE
  • DAGSync
  • QEDIT said it will grow the ZSA note plaintext from 580 to 612 bytes while keeping the memo at 512 bytes.
  • Zebra rc.3 includes RPCs for mining pools and ZIP 317-based transaction selection.
  • Kris described the shardtree structure, which updates the note commitment tree out of order.
  • Str4d proposed implementing ZSA with zcashd's network upgrade feature flag framework and using a separate testnet.
Topics 5 · VideoRead more →
ARBORIST#42

Detection keys and the recursion priority debate

After ECC said it will focus on payment scalability for a year, a debate broke out over the priority of Halo 2 recursion.

  • Zebra rc.2
  • FROST
  • Detection keys
  • Halo 2 recursion
  • DAGSync
  • zcashd 5.3.2
  • ZIP 317 was implemented in Zebra rc.2, and getblocktemplate for mining pools was completed.
  • Nate said PoS research will be put off for about a year while the team focuses on wallet scalability.
  • The team agreed to compare and lay out the pros and cons of detection keys, out-of-band notifications, OMR and others.
  • zcashd 5.3.2 reverted the headers-first download fix, and 5.4.0 is due in mid-to-late January.
Topics 7 · VideoRead more →
ARBORIST#41

ZIP 317 unpaid actions fix

An amendment to ZIP 317 capping unpaid actions per block and the Ledger app's v4 support issue were discussed.

  • ZIP-317
  • Unpaid actions
  • Ledger
  • ZSA fees
  • zcashd 5.3.1
  • Daira proposed a per-block cap on unpaid logical actions to close a vulnerability that lets large low-fee transactions slip in.
  • QEDIT will merge its ZSA fee proposal into ZIP 317 and deliver output for testnet connection by the end of January.
  • Zondax's Ledger app supports only v4, which Ledger sees as a regression, so a meeting of those involved will be held.
  • Zebra parallelized Sprout anchor checking with rayon, and zcashd 5.3.1 is due soon.
Topics 5Read more →
ARBORIST#40

FROST final review and SDK unified addresses

The IRTF's FROST specification entered final review, and the mobile SDK will support unified addresses first.

  • FROST
  • IRTF
  • Mobile SDK
  • Unified addresses
  • zkproof
  • The FROST threshold signature specification v11 entered IRTF final review, and comments were requested on the CFRG mailing list.
  • The next mobile SDK will support only transparent and Sapling UAs, with ZIP 317 applied in the release after that.
  • zcashd stores block headers in LevelDB, cutting virtual memory by up to 2.3GB.
  • Standardization of PLONK-family systems was discussed at the zkproof conference.
Topics 4 · VideoRead more →
ARBORIST#39

Zebra rc.1 and security audit preparation

Zebra released 1.0.0-rc.1, its second release candidate, to be sent to the security audit.

  • Zebra rc.1
  • Security audit
  • Zebra RPCs
  • Mobile SDK
  • ZIP-317
  • Zebra 1.0.0-rc.1 came out as the candidate for audit submission, and the audit firm has not yet been confirmed.
  • The first getblocktemplate, getblockhash and getblockcount RPCs were added to Zebra.
  • zcashd is preparing an optimization that reads about 2.3GB of block headers from LevelDB instead of memory.
  • The team will invite developers and service providers to the November 10 ZIP 317 wallet developer meeting.
Topics 3Read more →
ARBORIST#38

Zebra 1.0.0-rc.0 tagged

Zebra tagged its first release candidate, and zcashd 5.3.0 shipped with memory optimizations.

  • Zebra RC
  • zcashd 5.3.0
  • ZIP-317
  • Mobile SDK
  • Fee enforcement
  • Zebra tagged 1.0.0-rc.0, and lightwalletd sync became about twice as fast.
  • zcashd 5.3.0 caps batch scanner memory to prevent OOM during sync and adds Prometheus metrics.
  • A rule was added to ZIP 317 that converts the script size of large transparent transactions into logical actions.
  • The core team agreed to add fee calculation to the zcash_inspect tool.
Topics 4 · VideoRead more →
ARBORIST#37

ZIP 317 fee parameters revealed

The ZIP 317 logical action formula and the 5000 zat per action fee parameters were introduced in detail for the first time.

  • ZIP-317
  • Logical actions
  • zcashd 5.3.0
  • Halo 2 recursion
  • Zebra RC preparation
  • The fee parameters were set at a marginal fee of 5000 zat and 2 grace actions.
  • A 2-logical-action transaction pays 10,000 zat, the pre-ZIP 313 level.
  • The daily fees for sandblasting transactions rise from about $0.42 to about $2,300.
  • Nate said they will hold an explanatory meeting for wallet developers so wallets apply the new fees first.
Topics 4 · VideoRead more →
ARBORIST#36

Moving zcash_script to zcashd

A proposal to move the zcash_script crate into the zcashd repository and the cause of sync memory spikes were discussed.

  • zcash_script
  • Zebra beta.15
  • ZIP-317
  • Memory spike
  • Trial decryption
  • Zebra beta.15 parallelized cached state reads, and multi-threaded RPC is turned on through configuration.
  • The zcashd sync memory spike was caused by how trial decryption results were passed, and was fixed by closing the channel.
  • In the ZIP 317 discussion, Nate presented contacting wallet vendors and a staged rollout strategy as next steps.
  • Conrado will create a WIP PR to move zcash_script into the zcashd repository.
Topics 5 · VideoRead more →
ARBORIST#35

ZIP 317 phased rollout roadmap

A roadmap for rolling out the ZIP 317 fee overhaul in stages, in the order wallets, relay, consensus, was discussed.

  • ZIP-317
  • Zebra beta.14
  • Mobile SDK
  • ZSA fees
  • Unified keys
  • Zebra beta.14 was released, and the start command became the default when running zebrad.
  • Nate proposed rolling out ZIP 317 in the order of wallet adoption, relay rules, then consensus changes.
  • The next mobile SDK will include the unified address migration and parallelized trial decryption, and the team will file UA issue #630 involving Orchard.
  • The ZSA team said circuit implementation is about halfway done and the circuit size may exceed the target.
Topics 7 · VideoRead more →
ARBORIST#34

Responding to network load and ZIP 317

ECC shared the status of its response to the surge in network load, and the draft ZIP 317 fee proposal was introduced.

  • Network load
  • ZIP-317
  • Mobile SDK
  • Detection keys
  • DAGSync
  • Zebra
  • Since mid-June the chain grew from about 30GB to 83GB, and the orphan rate came down to 1.8 to 2.8%.
  • ECC made fast mobile SDK sync its top priority and pivoted toward fee mechanism research.
  • On the unified address transition, it said the next SDK release may drop the Orchard component from addresses.
  • Dodger proposed a lightweight wallet architecture using detection keys, and a workshop will be held.
Topics 5 · VideoRead more →
ARBORIST#33

Fee structure overhaul discussion

In response to network load, a proposal to switch to a fee structure based on the number of inputs and outputs was discussed.

  • Fee structure
  • zcashd 5.2.0
  • Zebra concurrency
  • FROST ZIP
  • DoS mitigation
  • Kris proposed a fee scheme of 250 zat per input and output with a floor of 1000 zat.
  • zcashd 5.2.0 includes a proof verification cache, multi-threaded trial decryption, and witness data pruning.
  • Zebra rewrote verification concurrency with Rayon and reduced unnecessary block deserialization.
  • Concerns were raised about a rollout order requiring wallets to be updated first before raising fees, and about mobile UX.
Topics 4 · VideoRead more →
ARBORIST#32

zcashd 5.1.0 performance and ZSA design

zcashd 5.1.0 cut block verification time by about 80%, and the ZSA design and FROST ZIP work were shared.

  • zcashd 5.1.0
  • Zebra performance
  • FROST ZIP
  • ZSA
  • Halo 2
  • Zebra fixed a bug that verified Halo 2 proofs per action, but sync was still slow.
  • zcashd 5.1.0 cut Sapling and Orchard verification time by about 80%.
  • Conrado is writing a ZIP specifying FROST for Zcash, with the goal of making it public before Zcon.
  • QEDIT submitted ZSA issuance and issue PRs and explained design points such as the Sinsemilla gadget change.
Topics 6Read more →
ARBORIST#31

Orchard load and batch verification

Orchard transactions surged after NU5 and blocked Zebra sync, while zcashd cut verification time with batch verification.

  • Zebra beta.12
  • Orchard load
  • Batch verification
  • zcashd 5.1.0
  • CI testing
  • Zebra 1.0.0-beta.12 was released, including changes such as automatic deletion of old cached state.
  • Up to 500 Orchard transactions per block piled in, and Zebra adjusted timeouts and the number of parallel tasks.
  • zcashd cut verification time by about 81% with Orchard batch verification.
  • The team will pursue a knowledge-sharing presentation on CI and automated testing among ECC, ZF and grant recipients.
Topics 6 · VideoRead more →
ARBORIST#30

Zebra DNS seeder and Tokio

Zebra became able to serve as a lightwalletd backend, and the DNS seeder problem caused by Flux nodes was also resolved.

  • Zebra
  • DNS seeder
  • Tokio Console
  • NU5 ecosystem
  • zcashd 5.1.0
  • Work to make Zebra usable as a lightwalletd backend is nearly done and was tested with Nighthawk and Zecwallet.
  • A surge in Flux nodes made the DNS seeder malfunction, so a minimum protocol version and default port filter were applied.
  • Support for Tokio Console, for inspecting async tasks, was added to Zebra.
  • After NU5 activation, wallets and block explorers work normally, and zcashd 5.1.0 is due in about 6 weeks.
Topics 5 · VideoRead more →

Source: ZcashCommunityGrants/arboretum-notes