Binance exchange address proposal approved
Binance technically approved the exchange address proposal, but development was put on hold until its review is complete.
Agenda summary 9
Zebra update: integrated mining support
Zcash Foundation · Arya, Marek, Dodger, Str4d
- Teor added experimental integrated mining (the internal miner feature) to Zebra, and Str4d helped make Zcashd's Equihash solver usable from Rust.
- With a few settings, blocks can be mined inside Zebra. This feature is test-only and was built to help QEDIT's testing.
- ASIC mining depends on the stratum protocol, and since pools are an intermediate layer between getblocktemplate and stratum, there are no plans to implement it in Zebra.
- Mistakes were reduced by introducing write typed batch and typed column family structs, which define the types of RocksDB column families only once.
- Zebra scan was improved to skip blocks before the Sapling activation height. Str4d plans to merge Teor's changes into their own Equihash crate PR (librustzcash PR 1088).
- Daira pointed out that the Tromp solver code has never undergone a memory-safety review.
ECC update: zcashd 5.8.0 and mobile SDK
Electric Coin Company · Kris, Str4d
- The zcashd 5.8.0 maintenance release came out, and the rest of the team is focused on mobile wallet support. Adding ZIP-317 and Orchard support to the mobile SDK is expected to finish within 1-2 weeks.
- A problem where builds broke on the latest Rust versions because of Android NDK changes was fixed with a linker setting, so from the next Android SDK release it can be built with stable Rust.
Zcash Shielded Assets (ZSA) update
QEDIT · Vivek, Dodger, Jon
- Teor's mining feature is expected to help with the Zebra test framework work.
- Mining directly to an Orchard shielded address is not yet supported in Zebra, so the team is working around it by mining to a transparent address and then shielding.
- The Orchard crate is being generalized to support both v5 and v6 transactions, and the circuit will use the same approach. ZIP editor comments have been addressed.
- The team aims within 1-2 weeks to post the initial asset swap design (zips issue 736) as a ZIP PR instead of a Google doc.
Trailing Finality Layer update
Electric Coin Company · Nate, Daira
- All documents were consolidated into the TFL book, and a short presentation for Zeboot in two weeks is being prepared along with the simulator work. A speculative roadmap to deployment, containing only stages and milestones without dates, will also be made. Str4d proposed a way to simplify Crosslink.
- Instead of the BFT chain taking arbitrary snapshots of the PoW chain, the rule is that without rollback each snapshot must be a descendant of the previous one. The safety of this variant follows from the existing design, but the liveness analysis remains.
- If it holds, implementation changes shrink and the safety of the dynamically available chain also becomes stronger.
FROST update and zkProof 6 announcement
Zcash Foundation / QEDIT · Conrado, Jon Rouach
- FROST resumed work after the holidays and is working on adding socket communication to the demo. Jon Rouach said that the ZKProof 6 standardization event will most likely be held in Berlin just before ETHBerlin, on May 20-24.
- It is not yet confirmed.
Out-of-band payments: zksend demo and URI-encapsulated payments
QEDIT / Zcash Foundation · Dodger, Jon Rouach, Daira, Str4d, Nate
- Dodger introduced the detection key proposal that Josh Swihart, appointed ECC CEO, posted on the forum, and said Zebra's viewing key support work will make detection key support easier later.
- Jon demonstrated Sui's zksend. With a Google-signed JWT and a zero-knowledge proof, funds in a link can be received without a seed, and the sender can revoke them before they are claimed.
- Daira said each component in the architecture diagram is a failure point for privacy and security and needs detailed review.
- Because of the trade-off of depending on a centralized identity provider, the consensus was that users should be able to choose how identity is designated, without being forced into any particular method.
- Str4d explained that in 2019 liberated payments were renamed URI-encapsulated payments and that the key was a UX that lets people receive without a wallet, and said it would be documented for comparison with other approaches.
- Dodger said a single ledger cannot permanently record every transaction, and presented out-of-band note transfer and a Mina-style succinct blockchain as long-term directions; they said a two-step transfer structure in which the sender can revoke is needed.
Binance exchange address proposal
Shielded Labs / ECC · Jason McGee, Kris, Daira, Str4d, Nate, Dodger, Pacu
- Jason McGee, Kris and Hanh discussed the exchange address proposal with Binance the night before. Binance technically approved it but told them to proceed with development only after its compliance review of all privacy coins is complete.
- Binance's February 29 deadline appears likely to be flexible, and the final decision is expected by January 19. If it is rejected, they believed it would be because of a hard-line stance toward privacy coins, not because of any shortcoming in the proposal.
- The proposal is a new address type that re-encodes the existing transparent address, so upgraded wallets cannot send to it directly from shielded.
- Kris explained that the SDK will implement it as two chained transactions: moving shielded funds to a temporary transparent address and then sending to the external recipient. UAs by design require a shielded component, which conflicts with this requirement.
- Nate raised the risk of requirements changing and suggested sharing this with crypto policy experts as a case study. Daira said that if the real requirement had been the ability to reject payments, this temporary-address approach would not have been needed.
Zebra full-node wallet proposal (Zenith)
Zenith · Rene Vergara, Dodger, Kris, Daira
- Rene Vergara described a ZCG proposal to build a full-node wallet on top of Zebra. It aims to fill the gap left by the Zecwallet full node and provide a frontend easier to use than zcash-cli.
- Dodger said the Zebra team has no plans to build a wallet and is developing features to support external wallets, so it is not duplication. With Zebra's light client RPC, the wallet can be on Windows and Zebra on Linux.
- Kris said the distinction between full-node wallets and light wallets is artificial, and that the goal should be a set of libraries that let you choose the data source.
- Kris offered zcash_client_backend as an alternative, and the technical discussion will continue in the #zebra channel on the R&D Discord.
- Dodger said that once detection keys are implemented, the lightwalletd stack could be replaced by moving to a new light client protocol. Daira said the nested-encryption approach requires protocol changes.
- Kris said ECC engineering is already busy and priorities need to be set.
Zeboot: ECC x community event
Electric Coin Company · Nate
- ECC's Zeboot, in two weeks, is a venue to discuss whether ECC will rearrange priorities around items such as detection keys. Others may attend, but each pays their own costs.
- They speculated that it is not recorded in order to allow free discussion about ECC.
This summary is based on the original meeting notes; check them for exact details.