← All calls
ARBORIST#69

Nate leaves ECC; TFL overview

Nate said they are leaving ECC, and an overview of the Trailing Finality Layer and Crosslink was presented.

Agenda summary 7

  1. ECC update: mobile SDK and Unified Address revision

    Electric Coin Company · Str4d, Kris

    • Over the past two weeks, several specific performance problems that kept spend-before-sync from performing as it should were found and fixed.
    • The unfinished Orchard work is gated in the Rust crate, and the remaining changes will be published to the crate first.
    • A two-step API that creates a transaction proposal from the light client wallet state and then turns it into a final transaction is also included in this release. The mobile SDK release is expected in a few days to a week.
    • As part of the Binance exchange address proposal work, a new metadata item and a new typecode range designated 'Must Understand' were defined in Unified Addresses.
    • A wallet that does not understand such an item must reject the whole UA. To keep existing wallets from ignoring Must Understand items, the plan is to create UA Revision 1 using a new human readable part (HRP).
    • The team will ask for community participation in choosing the HRP.
  2. Zebra 1.5.2 update

    Zcash Foundation · Arya, Dodger, Str4d

    • Zebra 1.5.2 was released. Crates that depend on git references cannot be published, so the internal miner feature was temporarily removed until the next equihash release; it can be used by building 1.5.1 from source.
    • The Zebra scan MVP result reader was updated for the latest JSON RPC crate, and a CI test was added that resumes scanning after shutdown and restart.
    • A gRPC crate and tower service were also added, taking a step toward a gRPC API for scan. Two RPC methods are being planned for now.
    • One lets scan register a list of viewing keys or authenticate access to registered keys by key hash and return results as a raw transaction stream; the other deletes registered keys or results.
    • Str4d said they could handle the equihash PR around next week's Zeboot, and QEDIT, the main user, said it is not urgent.
  3. FROST update

    Zcash Foundation · Conrado

    • The team is finishing stage 1, which adds socket communication to the demo of signing Zcash transactions with FROST so it can be used over the internet. For stage 2, an HTTP server that only relays messages, to which both participants and the coordinator connect, was started.
    • After the release candidate last December there has been no particular feedback on the API, so the team plans to release the stable 1.0.0 soon. FROST ZIP-312 received another round of review, and the comments are being addressed.
    • The security proof paper written by Chelsea is expected to be published on ePrint this week or next.
  4. Nate's announcement of leaving ECC

    Electric Coin Company · Nate, Dodger

    • Nate announced on the forum that they will leave ECC after Zeboot next week. Nate is taking a break from Zcash work to focus on their family, and said they can still be found on Discord.
    • Dodger asked people to keep contributing and attending calls so that institutional knowledge is not lost from the ecosystem.
  5. Trailing Finality Layer overview and goals

    Electric Coin Company · Nate

    • Together with Daira and Sean, the team is designing the Trailing Finality Layer to transition Zcash to a hybrid PoW/PoS protocol in a future upgrade.
    • With PoS, more participants contribute to security, assured finality enables trust-minimized bridging and wallet simplification, and resource use is lower. The idea is to introduce the hybrid first and later move to pure PoS.
    • It is less disruptive, creates a period in which miners and stakers coexist, and the success of Ethereum's PoS transition is also cited as a basis. The first version aims at user staking and the prerequisite stage for a trust-minimized bridge, and does not build the bridge itself.
    • Exchange deposit confirmation times could also become faster. The ecosystem stability goals are to minimize mining disruption, keep the existing 21M ZEC cap and issuance schedule, and make non-breaking upgrades to the full-node RPC and SDK APIs.
    • They warned that mining rewards will decrease because of staking rewards. The security goal is for the estimated attack cost to be the same as or higher than today, with a reasonable level of privacy for staking as well, while avoiding radical innovation.
  6. Crosslink design explanation

    Electric Coin Company · Nate

    • Crosslink is a design that starts from Snap-and-Chat in the ebb and flow paper and extends what it lacks. PoW has dynamic availability, in that mining continues even during a network partition, but it has only probabilistic safety.
    • BFT is finalizing, but halts during a partition. In the hybrid, each PoW (BC) block points to the previous PoW block and to a known final BFT block header, and BFT blocks also point to recent PoW blocks.
    • Following these pointers shows up to which point the chain is final. Users can choose between waiting for finality and the lower latency based on recent blocks. Exchanges can use the finalization point as the criterion for confirming deposits.
    • The security analysis showed that if the PoW chains satisfy prefix agreement, the finalized log (Log fin) has the same relation.
    • There is also a variant in which a rollback crosses the finalized view, and a security argument for a simpler variant that does not allow this is being studied.
    • When Conrado asked whether PoW could be removed later, the answer was that a two-step upgrade to pure PoS is envisioned, with options of replacing it with a PoS component or moving beyond Crosslink.
  7. TFL Q&A and BFT light clients

    Dodger, Nate, Str4d, Arya

    • Dodger asked about creating a new chain with the new consensus and having funds moved over from the existing chain.
    • Nate said a new chain could shed baggage such as transparent addresses but would require migrating users and infrastructure, whereas swapping only the consensus, as Ethereum did, keeps the existing ecosystem working as is.
    • Str4d said that since the BFT side is effectively a header-only chain, room should be left in the design for separate transactions on the BFT side. Str4d also mentioned that Crosslink plays half of the role needed for light clients and bridges.
    • Nate compared that a BFT chain requires validators to restart manually when it halts, while with PoW miners can resume mining without coordination, making it more resilient.
    • Short-term milestones and a rough roadmap to mainnet deployment were added to the TFL DAG. ECC's priorities for the coming six months to a year are expected to become clear after Zeboot.

This summary is based on the original meeting notes; check them for exact details.