← All calls
ARBORIST#91

NSM poll, skepticism about ZIP-235

An NSM poll got under way, and some argued that ZIP-235's benefit is low relative to its complexity.

Agenda summary 7

  1. Zebra update: merged changes

    Zcash Foundation · Arya

    • They fixed several CI problems, and because Git-sourced crates got mixed in during the 2.0.0 release, they added a CI test that checks for this to the release PR.
    • They added the getblockheader RPC and updated the minimum protocol version required of peers during initial sync.
    • They merged a PR for validating a mempool transaction that spends the unmined outputs of another mempool transaction, so TEX transactions now work properly.
  2. Zebra update: RPC changes under review

    Zcash Foundation · Arya

    • They are reviewing a PR that brings the getblock and getrawtransaction RPCs closer to zcashd's output, and a PR that adds the createrawtransaction RPC.
    • They are also working on a change so that sendrawtransaction gives a success response only after the transaction enters the mempool.
    • Replacing the deprecated parity JSON RPC with a new crate supporting HTTP2 and SSE would allow moving the runindexer RPC to the regular endpoint.
    • A PR that tracks the ID of a spending transaction by consumed outpoint and revealed nullifier, and a Nix flake PR, are also open.
    • In QEDIT's Zebra fork they added state for ZSA-issued assets and are also adding an RPC to query it.
  3. Crosslink update

    Shielded Labs · Zooko, Jason McGee, Dodger, Alfredo

    • They updated the rationale, user experience goals and deployment goals in Shielded Labs' scoping.md document, and are increasing the number of GitHub issues linked to these goals.
    • These issues effectively serve as the current roadmap, and a separate roadmap document is being created.
    • Shielded Labs is looking for 2 Rust engineers at the intermediate level or above.
    • The cryptocurrencyjobs.com posting was of low quality, so they are using a UK-based recruiter, and some candidates have reached second and third interviews.
    • Alfredo suggested writing the specification in TLA+, and Zooko replied that it is not a bad idea and asked Alfredo to leave it as a GitHub issue.
  4. FROST update

    Conrado, Dodger

    • They added private-key-based authentication to the FROST server.
    • Since participants already create key pairs to encrypt communication, they made the server authentication use these too, removing the username and password feature and the database.
    • It is under review and will be merged soon.
    • They are also working on running DKG with the default server.
    • The server is now effectively stateless, but it needs hardening against denial-of-service attacks such as timeouts, and the problem of sessions disappearing when the server reboots can be addressed after the first version by storing sessions in a DB.
  5. NSM poll and Shielded Labs update

    Shielded Labs · Jason McGee

    • They started a poll asking about support for including NSM in NU7, bundling the three ZIPs as a package.
    • The ZecHub poll, in which 20 active community members took part, was unanimously in favor.
    • Results of the poll of the ECC, ZF and Shielded Labs core teams and of Zingo, QEDIT and ChainSafe developers will come early next week, and the coinholder vote will be held next week after registration.
    • Dodger and Josh said they are willing to run ZCAP and ZAC votes, and Shielded Labs asked for its own NSM webpage to be included in the supporting materials.
    • The ZIP editors will soon post feedback on each ZIP's feasibility, safety and usefulness.
    • Daira Emma worried that the 60% fee burn is too small to justify a consensus change, and Jason McGee replied that if core engineers feel that way, they would first test it as a node update.
  6. NSM discussion: the ZIP editors' view

    Zcash Foundation · Arya, Jason McGee

    • Arya explained that NU7 is already a big update so there are complexity concerns, and that ZIP 233 could be used to charge large fees for ZSA issuance.
    • Arya thought ZIP 235 is of low usefulness, because updating ZIP 317 to reject mempool transactions that do not burn a certain amount is a standard rule that remains possible after NU7.
    • Arya expected the ZIP editors to recommend including ZIP 233 because it is easy and useful.
    • For ZIP 234, they said they may recommend it if Shielded Labs handles the ecosystem update and the community wants smoothing.
    • Arya added the caveat that this is not yet a settled opinion.
  7. NSM polling approach and the need for ZIP 234

    Dodger, Jason McGee, Alfredo, Zooko, Arya

    • Dodger again took issue with the approach of polling on NSM as a whole package and with the term burn.
    • Dodger said that besides ZIP 234, other ways of reissuing burned funds are possible.
    • Zooko said ZIP 234's value lies in being a neutral automatic process with no discretion.
    • Arya said how the lockbox will be disbursed has not been decided yet, and that multisig and FROST have been discussed.
    • Arya said ZIP 233 alone is meaningless, so ZIP 234 will be absolutely necessary later even if it does not go in this time.
    • Dodger said that for the ZCAP vote they will present multiple options rather than all-or-nothing.

This summary is based on the original meeting notes; check them for exact details.