← All calls
ARBORIST#90

NU6 activation on November 23 approaches

NU6 is set to activate on November 23, and the NSM ZIP schedule was adjusted.

Agenda summary 10

  1. NU6 activation watch party plan

    Zcash Foundation, ECC · Pili, Kris

    • NU6 is set to activate on Saturday, November 23.
    • ZF proposed a watch party, opening a call with ECC to monitor Zebra and zcashd together around the activation time (mentioned as about 09:30 UTC).
    • Kris replied that ECC has no separate engineering plan for the activation, and the two sides agreed to coordinate the watch party.
  2. Zebra update

    Zcash Foundation · Marek

    • They finished the PR for validating transactions that use mempool UTXOs, and it is ready to merge.
    • They started work on replacing Zebra's JSON RPC server, which is no longer maintained.
    • They also plan to merge a fix for a getrawtransaction RPC bug soon.
  3. ECC update: NU7 ZIPs and note management

    ECC · Kris

    • They spent a lot of time over the past two weeks on editing the NU7 ZIPs.
    • Str4d has nearly finished PCZT and is testing it.
    • It will be used for hardware wallet integration with Keystone, and is also planned as the standard format for multi-party signing such as FROST.
    • They merged a rudimentary but sufficiently working note management system into the wallet backend to address the tip the barista problem.
    • They are also moving over CLI features used for internal testing to fill in the skeleton of a command-line version of the wallet app.
  4. zcashd deprecation update

    Zcash Foundation, Zingo Labs · Pili, Arlo, Kris, Pacu

    • ZF is focused on filling in the RPC methods that Zebra needs to support.
    • Pacu is handling outreach to find out which RPCs each partner needs.
    • Arlo pointed out that the getsubtreesbyindex RPC, which lightwalletd uses for the getsubtreesroots gRPC, is missing from the RPC list spreadsheet.
    • Kris confirmed that this is data derived from the chain that has to be indexed and served, so it is rightly within Zaino's scope.
    • Pacu is collecting answers from two or three exchanges that do not require KYC and compiling them into the spreadsheet.
  5. NSM update: ZIP 234 activation height

    Shielded Labs · Jason McGee, Kris, Zooko, Nate

    • After the Twitter Spaces, they moved the ZIP 234 activation height from the NU6 height to a later point, and all three ZIPs were submitted as NU7 candidates as consensus changes.
    • Kris said they did not document the halving-preserving reissuance approach Str4d proposed, because it is harder to explain and its benefits are not large.
    • They decided to set the ZIP 234 activation height at the midpoint between the previous and next halvings and not spend more time on it.
    • If burning occurs before then, the crossover point shifts slightly, but only by a negligible amount.
  6. How to include in NU7, and burning ZSA issuance fees

    ECC, QEDIT · Kris, Jon, Zooko

    • Kris said ZIP 233 and 234 are in good shape, and that whether to make ZIP 235 a consensus rule or a getblocktemplate standard rule needs community input.
    • Kris also offered the view that burning ZSA issuance fees could reduce MEV-like advantages among miners.
    • Jon said QEDIT also wants a decision as soon as possible given the fee consensus-change cycle, and that for now ordinary fees are paid to miners.
  7. Trailing Finality update

    Shielded Labs · Zooko, Nate, Jon

    • Zooko is incorporating feedback from ZF, ECC and others into the scope document, and the broad outline of what to solve and what not to solve has been stable since two calls ago.
    • Nate is moving the scope document's goals into GitHub issues and building a roadmap that traces back to sub-engineering goals.
    • They will support users' stake delegation but will not build their own wallet.
    • The goal is to satisfy at least one party each among wallet vendors, centralized exchanges, and DEXs and bridges, and the engineering centers on protocol design and Zebra patches.
    • Asked by Jon whether they consult people with staking experience, Nate answered that they are talking with some, and see people with PoS node experience as hiring candidates.
    • Nate plans to start on a prototype first even with gaps in the design.
  8. FROST update

    Conrado, Pacu, Pili

    • They merged the BIP-340 (taproot) ciphersuite PR, which is to be used for ZSA issuance.
    • It is split into a separate crate and will be included in the next frost-core release.
    • They also merged key share refresh using DKG.
    • However, this is not a cure-all; the existing shares are still valid, so the wallet is at risk if another participant is compromised, and if necessary all funds must be moved to a new wallet.
    • They also added a warning to the documentation.
    • The next task is to support DKG on the server and do the finishing for production use such as HTTPS, aiming to finish by the end of this year.
  9. Zcash Shielded Assets (ZSA) update

    QEDIT · Vivek, Jon

    • ZSA ZIP PR 854 was merged around the NU7 ZIP deadline and is under review as an NU7 candidate, and they opened a new PR 960 reflecting review comments.
    • They discussed a change adjusting the v6 transaction format to smoothly support ZSA swaps in the next upgrade, and the NU7 implementation burden is small.
    • In Zebra they split the work into stepwise PRs and are cross-reviewing with ZF, and work on issuance support and issuance state is in progress.
    • Swaps are nearly finished in the Orchard crate.
    • On the trade acceptance work, they gave an initial presentation to Daira Emma this week and will release a report soon.
    • Jon said the core protocol security audit is proceeding in parallel with the merge, and that they plan three 40-minute webinars.
  10. Public announcements: ZCG coinholder vote proposal and the Zaino RPC interface

    ZCG, Zingo Labs · Jason McGee, Pili, Arlo, Kris

    • Jason McGee asked core developers and node implementers to review the proof-of-balance coinholder voting 2.0 proposal submitted by Hanh.
    • The ZCG vote is on Monday, November 25, and they want an overall risk assessment of the change, and Pili replied that ZF will review it.
    • Arlo asked whether Zaino could implement in gRPC the JSON RPC service it will take over from zcashd.
    • Kris answered that JSON RPC is needed for existing exchange partners, but that a proxy structure layering JSON RPC on top of a modern gRPC service is also possible.
    • Kris said that regardless of gRPC, the needed operations should be defined semantically and their semantics fixed with something like Rust traits.
    • Kris said the lightwallet protocol grew organically rather than by design, so they should not be tied to it and should start from a foundation that can support it.

This summary is based on the original meeting notes; check them for exact details.