Positive ZSA audit, NU7 scope discussed
The ZSA audit came back positive, and the scope of ZIPs to include in NU7 was discussed.
Agenda summary 16
ECC update: Keystone integration
ECC · Daira Emma
- There is no new work on zcashd, and the Zashi and wallet SDK teams are making Keystone integration their top priority.
- The goal is a release before Christmas, but it depends on how long it takes to fix a Keystone firmware bug.
- They also plan to add debugging features such as testing with a simulator and exporting data to a file.
PCZT v1 finished and how to use it
ECC · Str4d, Pacu, Daira Emma
- The PCZT v1 format is finished, and the first PCZT crate release is coming soon.
- It supports only the v5 transaction format and P2PKH spends, and its transparent signing has the same capabilities as BIP 174 PSBT.
- FROST fields and ZSA support are not there yet; once the v6 format is settled, they plan to define PCZT v2 to support them.
- Zashi integrates through two new zcash_client_backend APIs: one that creates a PCZT from a proposal, and one that extracts and stores a transaction from a PCZT.
- By default the PCZT crate does not depend on other zcash Rust crates and needs only postcard and Serde.
Zebra update: the 2.0.0 NU6 bug and Zebra 2.1.0
Zcash Foundation · Marek, Daira Emma
- Zebra 2.1.0 raises the minimum protocol version so it no longer talks to outdated peers even during initial sync, adds the getblockheader RPC, and updates the getblock RPC to match.
- There was a bug during NU6 activation where the consensus branch ID check was missing for v5 transactions, and 2.1.0 fixes it so invalid transactions are rejected immediately.
- If a transaction carrying the NU5 ID entered the mempool, there was a denial-of-service risk that mining pools running Zebra would mine an invalid block.
- A hardening in which getblocktemplate applies the same checks as block proposals, excludes the problem transaction and retries is scheduled for after the next release.
- Daira Emma advised raising the priority, since the share of mining on Zebra will grow.
- They fixed sendrawtransaction returning a txid even for rejected transactions, and support TEX transactions through validation of transactions that use mempool UTXOs.
zcashd deprecation plan and outreach
ECC, Zcash Foundation · Str4d, Pili, Jon, Pacu
- Str4d plans to fill in the zcash/wallet binary skeleton after the PCZT work, using PCZT for sending to gain hardware wallet and HSM support.
- Pili said Zebra has finished reviewing the list of needed RPCs and only exposing them remains.
- Pili named the biggest source of concern as zcashd-using partners who have not yet been reached.
- Pacu is preparing more urgent-toned outreach and a Google survey form.
- Str4d said that in the next zcashd release they plan to mark RPCs that will not be migrated as deprecated, and disable them by default in the release after that.
- The EOS for 6.0.0 is January 22.
RPC disabling approach and wallet export format
ECC, Zcash Foundation, Zingo Labs · Daira Emma, Dodger, Arlo, Arya, Pacu
- Daira Emma suggested disabling some methods by default starting with this release in order to learn whether they are used.
- Dodger proposed making zcashd exit unless a config flag is set, to announce the deprecation, and they agreed to put a survey link in that message.
- Arlo opened issue 9082, where transactions in a block with coinbase funds are rejected on Zebra regtest, and Arya suspected a consensus branch ID mismatch.
- Pacu said they are discussing a wallet export format with Blockchain Commons and Zingo.
- Daira Emma pointed out that the new format must be able to represent addresses outside the ZIP 32 derivation tree and past transaction metadata.
FROST update
Conrado, Daira Emma, Str4d
- The FROST server now has timeouts, HTTPS support and other elements needed for real-world use, and review is done for the client's multi-session support and contact and group deletion features.
- DKG support in the server is the last remaining piece, after which they plan to have the server and client code audited together.
- The signing tool currently supports only Ywallet transaction plans, so they are also considering PCZT support.
- For the PCZT extensions FROST needs, they are thinking of a signing package containing signing commitments and a signature share field.
- Str4d replied that the proprietary section is only for prototypes and that a standard will be defined over the long term.
Crosslink update
Shielded Labs · Nate, Daira Emma, Pili
- Nate posted an update on the forum.
- The first pass at defining scope is done, and the engineering deliverables are a full node with proper APIs, a validator tool to be bundled with the node, a stake delegation tool for developers, and CI and documentation.
- They are following a strategy of connecting early with representative stakeholders such as wallet teams, exchanges and would-be validators to get feedback.
- They want to hire 2 to 3 engineers and need someone to guide them through Zebra CI, and Pili agreed to connect them with Gustavo.
- Daira Emma will mark the unfinished parts of the Crosslink 2 specification before their vacation and plans to post it that day.
- Nate said they will document in writing the design gaps that were filled in ad hoc during prototyping.
NSM update: poll results and schedule
Shielded Labs · Jason McGee, Daira Emma
- Following the ZIP editors' opinion, they decided to develop ZIP 234 and 235 behind separate feature flags and to demonstrate support by the March 1, 2025 testnet deadline.
- In the coinholder poll about 250,000 ZEC voted, and as in the ZecHub poll the support was unanimous.
- In the Helios ecosystem engineer poll, 53% of 34 people responded, with 12 in favor of including it in NU7 and 5 against.
- Daira Emma said they found it hard to answer the question bundling the three ZIPs, since they support 233 and 234 but not 235.
- Jason McGee said they will run item-by-item polls going forward.
Alternative NSM issuance approach and ZSA fees
Shielded Labs, QEDIT · Conrado, Nate, Jon, Daira Emma, Zooko
- Conrado proposed that instead of flattening issuance, tracking only the NSM deposits separately and reissuing them at the same rate would preserve the halving.
- Nate worried that two kinds of unissued balances would arise and could be mistaken for a discretionary fund.
- Jon said QEDIT wants to know early whether the burn feature will be in NU7, in order to design the ZSA fees.
- Daira Emma summarized that burning issuance fees requires ZIP 233, not 235.
- Zooko said ZSA could use ZIP 235 or build a similar mechanism with reference to it.
NSM and ZSA interaction, and the NU7 decision process
Paul Dann, Daira Emma, Jason McGee, Str4d, Jon
- Paul Dann asked how the rule in ZSA's Orchard bundle, which allows burning tokens but not ZEC, fits with the burning introduced by ZIP 233.
- Daira Emma answered that there is a single mechanism, with ZEC burned via the burn amount field and non-ZEC assets via the burn bundle, and that there is no conflict because blocks and transactions balance exactly since NU6.
- When Jason McGee asked whether ZIP 233 will be in NU7, Str4d answered that technically nothing has been decided yet, and that those classified as viable in the ZIP editors' viability assessment are likely to be included.
- ZIP 233 is low-cost because its transaction format change is small.
- Daira Emma pointed out that from NU7 on Zebra will be the only main consensus node implementation, so ZF needs a process to specify what to implement and accept objections.
- Str4d explained that ECC maintains librustzcash and ZF maintains Zebra, and that librustzcash changes made before a specification is finalized are kept behind configuration flags.
Zcash Shielded Assets (ZSA) update
QEDIT · Vivek, Jon, Nate
- They rewrote the ZIP's consensus rule descriptions to match the protocol and resolved most of the issues.
- For swaps they introduced action groups into the transaction format and reflected them in Orchard, librustzcash and the Python test vectors, and also implemented the reference notes in Orchard.
- The asset swap transaction tool is not fully supported yet and is under development, and a matcher that pairs up trades is also needed.
- In Zebra they are developing and testing new RPCs with ZF and building a demo with the transaction tool.
- Least Authority's audit report arrived that day, with no critical issues.
- Jon said they will run a Zebra ZSA node on the live network to test backward compatibility.
The shielded sighash proposal and ECC's position
ECC · Daira Emma, Str4d
- In issue 967, Daira Emma, Kris and Str4d proposed using an Orchard flag to set each bundle's signing target to either the whole transaction or the action bundle.
- This lets the sighash algorithm be managed separately from the transaction version, avoiding an incompatible change in NU8.
- If the choice turns out wrong, that variant can be turned off with a restriction change, so the complexity and security analysis cost are also low.
- Daira Emma said that, as ECC's R&D engineering manager, they strongly favor including ZSA.
- Daira Emma saw the only obstacle to merging as reviewing that NU6 has no unintended consensus changes while the work is behind a feature flag.
Public announcements: Zcash Dev Summit and the ZK event
Zcash Foundation · Dodger, Daira Emma, Jon, Str4d
- The December 26 Arborist call will be skipped, and the next call will be held at an early time on January 9.
- ZF is holding a developer summit (Dev Summit) in Sofia in March, just before ZK Proof.
- The agenda is an unstructured format set by attendees.
- A scheduling overlap with Hacks and ZK Proof was raised.
- Jon explained that they coordinated with the ZK Proof organizers so the first day is mostly light workshops and keynotes, and the third day covers topics such as ZKVM and formal verification that everyone will attend.
zec-sqlite-cli released
ECC · Str4d
- The example CLI for zcash_client_sqlite, built four years ago for testing, has been split out into a separate crate and released now with improved key management.
- It is a command-style CLI wallet that runs a command and exits, with no resident process.
- The seed phrase is stored on disk encrypted with an age key, and a YubiKey can also protect the seed via age-plugin-yubikey.
- Str4d said that with the YubiKey backend it can be trusted with up to five-figure dollar amounts but not yet six figures.
Open discussion: how to decide NU7 ZIPs and the ZIP 233 format
Zcash Foundation, ECC · Dodger, Jason McGee, Str4d
- Dodger said they see no agreement among the ZIP editors, the core teams and the proposers on the NU7 ZIPs, so the community should be asked about priorities.
- Dodger expected ZSA to take priority over NSM, and was cautiously optimistic that ZF could include both if ZIP 235 is excluded.
- Jason McGee worried that because the transaction format cannot be opened often, if ZIP 233 misses NU7 it may be hard for NU8 too.
- Dodger presented an option of splitting 233 into a minimal change that adds only a placeholder burn amount field.
- Str4d said the field is simple so it is likely to go into the v6 format, and that it is better to add asset groups and the sighash version byte now as well.
- The de facto deadline is when the testnet activation height is set.
Open discussion: unifying transaction implementations and poll design
Zcash Foundation, ECC · Marek, Daira Emma, Nate, Dodger
- Marek said they discussed with a QEDIT engineer the option of replacing Zebra's transaction implementation with the librustzcash implementation.
- Daira Emma mentioned a plan to make Zebra's types simple wrappers around librustzcash types.
- Nate reminded everyone of the option of first testing ZIP 235 as an opt-in or opt-out standard rule instead of a consensus rule.
- Dodger said ZF will implement the community's wishes within reason but has a limited number of engineers.
- Daira Emma said to put the contentious questions, ZIP 235's 60% burn requirement and the ban on v4 (no spending Sprout), in separate questions.
- Dodger said they will first post a draft of the Helios survey on the forum to get feedback.
This summary is based on the original meeting notes; check them for exact details.