Dynamic fees: wallet experiments begin
Shielded Labs began priority-send fee experiments with wallets and proposed changes to ZIP-317.
Agenda summary 9
Zebra update
Zcash Foundation · Pili
- The Zebra team is investigating reports of degraded sync performance, so Pili presented in its place.
- Many reports on Discord and the forum said that some Zebra nodes had stalled, and the team is looking into them.
- The team is tied up with several security issues and plans to publish a security release later that day.
ZODL update
ZODL · Daira Emma
- The team made a fix to the rewind method and an SDK release.
- There are an internal release to support the next coinholder polling in ZODL, multi-server transaction broadcast, and some private security work.
- On mobile, it released ZODL 3.3.1 (iOS) and 3.4.0 (both platforms).
- It fixed a Keystone import problem where not all previously received funds were visible, and the approach is to enter a birthday height and scan from that point.
- It is now focusing on testing coinholder polling and improving wallet server and sync problems on iOS.
- Harry joined as senior mobile QA, and Danny will join as principal cryptography engineer.
Zaino update
Zingo Labs · Hazel
- The team released Zaino 3.1.
- It fixed the version value returned by get block range and updated to the latest Zebra version, which had previously fallen behind.
- With a flood of lightwalletd vulnerability reports, deprecating lightwalletd became a short-term priority, and the goal is to ship a release that regains parity with lightwalletd this week or next.
- Daira Emma asked about the lightwalletd deprecation timeline and also mentioned the bug Str4d had described a few weeks earlier that blocks the Zallet beta.
- Because of audio problems, they agreed to sort it out offline.
zcashd deprecation update
Electric Coin Company, Zcash Foundation, Zingo Labs · Pacu, Daira Emma
- Several milestones of the Zaino completion grant were achieved.
- The block explorer RPCs are mostly done, and the ones not implemented are RPCs marked as low priority in the survey and usage spreadsheet, and will be implemented if there is demand.
- Some integration tests verifying parity between lightwalletd and Zaino were completed, and these tests led to changes in Zaino and also exposed possible bugs in zcashd.
- Mempool tests are not done yet because they need more setup.
- The aim is lightwalletd parity between the Zaino 0.40 and 0.50 releases, and enough testing is needed between feature completion and the actual replacement of infrastructure.
- Zaino and ZODL are sorting out the Zallet and Zaino integration gaps that Str4d left behind.
- Daira Emma urged people not to make new requests, to avoid burning out Kris, who is handling an enormous workload, and to ask instead whether there is anything they can help with.
- Pacu and Hazel plan to organize the Zaino area of the ZODL core DAG and show progress through a public link.
ZSA update
Qedit · Vivek
- This is the first Arborist call after meeting many people in Rome.
- The team strengthened Orchard's ZSA issuance validation logic and improved edge cases, error handling and documentation.
- Most of the comments on the Orchard PR have been answered and merging the ZSA branch is getting close.
- It closed the existing Zebra PR and opened a new, more recent upstream PR, and is discussing the approach with ZF to prepare for code review.
- The transaction tool was also updated to match the new latest Zebra version.
- There is an open grant proposal, which was discussed with ZCG the day before, and the proposal will be revised in line with that.
Network Sustainability Mechanism (NSM) update
Shielded Labs · Judah
- The merge conflicts of the refactoring PR are being resolved, and it will be merged into main.
- The ZIP 234 PR, which split up the original implementation, required reimplementing a few parts, and will be published that day.
Crosslink update (Trailing Finality Layer)
Shielded Labs, ZODL · Nate, Daira Emma
- The Crosslink feature net, started about six weeks ago, is a shift from creating a one-off testnet for every workshop to a persistent network.
- Through 2026 it will be reset when necessary to improve, and participants will be paid real ZEC rewards matched to consensus usage.
- Early on, a considerable share of the stake went offline and BFT stalled.
- In the current design, PoW continues indefinitely in this case, which differs from the specification in the TFL book.
- Performance problems and bugs in the new transport layer combined with default CPU mining to make PoW forks long, hitting Zebra's reorg limit.
- The plan to reset the network every six weeks was dropped; the team will reset only when there is an engineering motive and will focus on software improvements and bug analysis.
- Workshops and rewards will proceed on a six-week cycle regardless of network state.
- This Monday, v6 added BFT peer discovery and a connected-finalizer visualization.
- The team is collaborating with ZF's Zebra developers on the transport protocol and sync diagnostics, and is also working on the integration with Nym.
- The ZIP PRs are two ZIPs, an overview and the Crosslink configuration, polished from an AI draft, and ZIPs for BFT, the staking rules and the transport protocol are still needed.
- Daira Emma explained that to be partition-resistant, 2/3 of the registered stake is needed rather than the connected stake, so it is hard to avoid BFT stalls entirely.
- They also said that rollback limit handling differs, as Zebra does not roll back more than 100 blocks and stays on its own chain while zcashd shuts down, so it needs to be sorted out.
- Daira Emma said there is a proposal in the group to raise the rollback limit to 600 blocks and cut the block time from 75 seconds to 25 seconds, and that nodes should be made not to mine by default.
- Nate proposed stress testing with the lowered limit, and Pili said they would set up a session to share learnings with ZF's Zebra developers.
Dynamic fees update
Shielded Labs · Mark, Daira Emma, Pacu, Nate
- The speaker introduced the blog and forum post published the day before.
- The goal is to mitigate sandblasting while lowering fees for ordinary users, and to support ZEC and network sustainability through dynamic fees.
- There is a lot wallets can do even with the current mainnet parameters, so six to seven wallets agreed to experiment, starting with Unstoppable.
- The proposal is a 4x priority option that touches the ZIP 317 weight cap, and cutting the transaction expiry time to 2 minutes (2 blocks under current parameters, 5 blocks if ZIP 218 passes).
- After that the team plans to design a z_get_standard_fee RPC and envisions a ZIP 317 change that moves the marginal fee from 5000 to 1000 and the weight cap from 4x to 10x.
- Daira Emma explained that splitting the anonymity set only by whether priority is used exposes minimal information, and that the 4x cap was set to prevent a situation where only the rich can send, and said that since they allowed it when they wrote ZIP 317, it is fine.
- Mark answered that early on, when few wallets use priority, the anonymity set is split into two and about 1 bit of leakage is expected.
- Nate relayed a point from Valor Group.
- Short expiry is a problem when collecting signatures takes time, as with multisig.
- Mark said one can pay the priority fee at the time of the last signature.
- Daira Emma explained that if signing takes long, an old anchor must be used, which creates a privacy problem.
- Penumbra allows anchor updates, and they said it could also be solved with Tachyon's recursive proofs and an approach that approves only minimal conditions (intents).
ZODL R&D update and announcements
ZODL, Shielded Labs · Daira Emma, Mark
- Pacu has also joined ZODL.
- The final changes to quantum recoverability ZIP 2005 were merged and it became a proposed ZIP, and the team is improving its security response and triage policy and wants to discuss a common policy with other organizations.
- Keystone developers merged a PR supporting SLIP 39 secret sharing, which will be included in a future firmware update.
- Daira Emma also introduced the shaman project, which helps Claude remember across sessions.
- ZK Summit, Zcash Summit, ZK Proof and Eurocrypt were held in Rome, and they said the nuanced discussions about AI and the discussion of the post-quantum timeline were impressive.
- Mark announced a follow-up office hour on the notes, commitments and nullifiers protocol explainer on June 2 at 15:00 (UTC).
This summary is based on the original meeting notes; check them for exact details.