← All calls
ARBORIST#126

NU 6.2 activation and Ironwood

After the Orchard pool disabling soft fork and the NU 6.2 activation, the move to Ironwood was announced.

Agenda summary 8

  1. Zebra update

    Zcash Foundation · Alfredo

    • The team made several releases over the past two weeks.
    • On May 29 it released Zebra 4.5.0 with a security fix reported through the bug bounty, and the same day also shipped a patch with an additional security fix.
    • On June 2 it did the soft fork that disabled the Orchard pool, and on June 3 the NU 6.2 activation turned the remaining fixes back on.
    • A bug in the sync code that stalled chain syncing was fixed in the previous day's release.
    • Because an update to the end-of-support date was missed, a patch to fix it is being made, which will also include widening the reorg window to reduce exposure, and will be released within a few hours.
  2. ZODL update

    ZODL · Pacu

    • Last week the team released zcashd with support for the NU 6.2 network upgrade.
    • The full story and next steps are in the Ironwood post on ZODL's X account.
    • The team thanked everyone for working together for a long time in response to the report from Taylor.
    • Most of the work on Zallet alpha 4 is done and it will be released soon.
    • It includes the sync engine refactoring, full block scanning, coinbase, and the getwalletstatus RPC, as well as the zcashd migration bundle with watch-only import, P2PKH private keys and Sapling key import.
    • With ZF's Alfredo, it made the integration test harness more stable and finished a test wallet builder for importing zcashd wallets into Zallet regtest.
    • It implemented full transfer coin tracking in zcash_client_backend, and only the chain view and the chain index migration remain.
    • As a follow-up to NU 6.2, it bumped the orchard crate to 0.14.0 and merged the z_importkey and z_exportkey RPCs and JSON RPC cookie file authentication.
    • There were also several ZODL wallet releases aligned with the NU 6.2 upgrade.
  3. zcashd deprecation update

    Electric Coin Company, Zcash Foundation, Zingo Labs · Pacu

    • The ecosystem plans to move from Orchard to Ironwood in about six weeks, at the end of July, and has set this as the finish line for zcashd deprecation.
    • New engineer Danny Williams, who joined, has been closing many PRs since the first week.
    • Valar Group built a wrapper around zcashd to help organizations that cannot easily move to z3's different APIs right away, and will soon show a testnet version.
    • The Zaino team is lightening its internal database and implementing a no-database approach that lets an instance come up faster without waiting for the index to complete.
    • The Zebra team is working on things like sync performance optimization.
    • For those who want to try Zallet, the speaker asked them to wait for the latest release, import a copy of zcashd's wallet.dat and give feedback.
    • It also helps in the case of testnet nodes.
  4. Network Sustainability Mechanism (NSM) update

    Shielded Labs · Judah

    • Last week the ZIP 234 PR was published and is awaiting review.
    • The ZIP 235 bug fix PR will also be posted soon.
    • Additional items from the audit of that code will be included in this PR.
  5. Crosslink update (Trailing Finality Layer)

    Shielded Labs, ZODL · Nate, Pacu

    • The second workshop of the feature net period is done.
    • It was conversation-focused rather than presentation-focused, and the setup guide session was left out.
    • It was a good sign that there were at least five new participants.
    • The team found that syncing for new users takes too long to finish within the workshop.
    • Since this was not a problem in the days of one-off networks, it is thinking about how to separate onboarding from update announcements.
    • It finished the scanning tool for distributing mainnet ZEC rewards, and will pay the first rewards within a few weeks.
    • Participants can export the viewing key of the Crosslink testnet (test prefix) and send it to Jason, and the deadline is June 17.
    • Many participants were on a PoW fork longer than 100 blocks, so which history to use to calculate rewards was a problem.
    • The reference chosen was the point just before where two community block explorers agree.
    • The next workshop is in about six weeks.
  6. Dynamic fees update

    Shielded Labs · Mark, Alfredo, Pacu

    • The first priority-fee (4x marginal fee) transfer as a wallet feature was successfully sent with Noisy Wallet (ZecHub's community wallet).
    • Network fees split broadly into the ZIP 317 5000 zat and others, and some pay even larger values.
    • A good share appears to come from NEAR intent swaps or the Solana bridge.
    • The plan is for two 2000-series change ZIPs: one lowering the marginal fee from 5000 to 1000 and one raising the weight cap from 4x to 10x.
    • On the fee estimation RPC, Alfredo answered that it can be added without a separate ZIP.
    • The team has talked with about 10 wallets, and many asked for RBF.
    • It has been persuading them that resending with a priority fee after a short expiry can sufficiently mimic the acceleration semantics.
    • Pacu introduced Google's quantum paper as a new argument against RBF, saying that it discussed how a quantum attacker could abuse RBF as a tool.
  7. Open presentation: Ironwood, formal verification and more

    Pacu, Mark, Nate, Daira Emma, Zooko, Alex

    • Pacu said that Daira Emma is doing formal verification related to Ironwood with the Tachyon team, and that Kris, Str4d and Daira Emma even worked 32 hours straight to mitigate the vulnerability.
    • ZF's Arya, Pili and others improvised a response procedure on the spot, and Pacu also thanked the miners who cooperated.
    • According to Daira Emma, Str4d was called back from sabbatical because of this incident, and the leave will be extended.
    • Zooko said the protocol rules and cryptography of Ironwood were agreed and that Taylor Hornby contributes to the assurance work.
    • Daira Emma said the elliptic curve model built in Lean has finished its proof, and that next they will connect it to the Zcash test vectors and later formalize the balance and binding signature arguments.
    • A formal verification coordination call is held the next day.
    • Mark announced they are holding a Merkle tree protocol explainer on the Zcash Global Discord on June 16 at 15:00 (UTC).
  8. Open discussion: deprecating the Sprout pool

    Daira Emma, Mark, Pacu

    • Daira Emma said Sprout must be deprecated and a time for turning it off must be set.
    • Mark proposed a poll on the deprecation date, but the NU 7 sentiment poll has been postponed indefinitely.
    • Pacu said that once zcashd is deprecated, interacting with the Sprout pool becomes much harder and Zallet's first version will not support Sprout either, so efforts to tell Sprout holders to move their funds should be stepped up.
    • Daira Emma urged that anyone who wants to get Sprout funds out should hurry and do it with zcashd.

This summary is based on the original meeting notes; check them for exact details.