← All calls
ARBORIST#83

NU6 testnet activation delayed

The NU6 testnet activation was postponed, and the ZSA fee structure was discussed.

Agenda summary 11

  1. ECC update: NU6 lockbox and exchange rate lookup

    ECC · Kris

    • ECC is focused on three things: implementing the NU6 lockbox funding stream, improving the Zcash client backend's handling of full transparent history, and Tor integration in the wallet backend.
    • Exchange rate lookup over Tor is already implemented and being tested in the Zashi wallet.
    • Str4d opened a PR to fetch transaction data over Tor, aiming to reduce the wallet activity exposed to the lightwallet server.
    • After discussions with Zcash hardware wallet developers, they are planning work to improve the signing process so hardware wallets can easily use the transaction builder in Zcash primitives.
  2. Zebra update: lockbox funding stream

    Zcash Foundation · Alfredo

    • In the Zebra consensus code they added a funding stream that computes the lockbox and tracks the amount in state, which required DB changes.
    • The initial implementation required a full resync after the upgrade, but they are working on a workaround so users do not have to resync.
    • They fixed a value balance deserialization problem, added an NU6 variant, and merged related code into librustzcash as well.
    • The getblocksubsidy RPC for NU6 is still in progress.
    • They implemented ZIP-236, which requires the coinbase to balance exactly right after NU6 activation.
    • The lockbox PR went through a lot of review by external reviewers and internal discussion.
  3. ECC and ZF NU6 progress

    ECC, Zcash Foundation · Dodger, Kris

    • The testnet activation target, originally set for today, slipped.
    • ECC aims to finish the final debugging of the zcashd changes and be ready early next week.
    • ECC's Yasser is working on a private testnet running zcashd and zebrad nodes together, so confidence can be established before the real activation.
    • They will first put out a release candidate with no testnet activation height set, activate on a private fork and confirm funding stream payments, then set the real height and release.
    • Kris said setting the activation height next week is possible, but actual activation will take more time until enough node operators upgrade.
  4. ECC and ZF zcashd deprecation

    ECC, Zcash Foundation · Dodger, Kris

    • Dodger suggested skipping the zcashd deprecation because of NU6 priorities, but Kris corrected that most of last week's work actually went toward the deprecation.
    • In particular, there was big progress on making the Zcash client backend support full transparent history.
    • NU6 has taken almost no time right now apart from debugging.
  5. FROST update

    Conrado, Dodger

    • They turned the Zcash transaction signing demo tool into a standalone tool that does not need a Ywallet fork, and only PR review and merging remain.
    • They have been discussing the best flow for creating a Zcash wallet with FROST, and will resume the ZIP work to spell it out in the ZIP.
    • Key share refresh for DKG is in progress, and they finished designing authentication encryption, the last piece of the FROST server.
    • Once authentication encryption is done, users can actually try the server.
    • They plan to review the transaction plan formats of ECC and Ywallet and create a standard proposal.
    • Dodger pointed out that FROST is already usable in Zcash and the server is work to make it easier to use.
  6. Zcash Shielded Assets (ZSA) grant and roadmap

    QEDIT · Jon, Jason McGee, Alfredo, Dodger

    • Jason McGee asked about the status of ECC's internal review of QEDIT's asset swap and trade acceptance grant, and Jon answered that they do not know the content of that review and that the feature was already discussed in the 2023 roadmap.
    • Jon explained that the asset swap ZIP has already been reviewed, that the trade rejection feature got a positive response with no security concerns, and that the forum criticism was about ZSA's speed and funding, not the feature.
    • QEDIT has been researching asset swaps, trade rejection and verifiable encryption since February, and intends to publish the verifiable encryption results separately from the grant.
    • Alfredo thanked the QEDIT team for agreeing to review Zebra's lockbox PR and to help with NU6 testing.
  7. Zcash Sustainability Fund and Trailing Finality update

    Shielded Labs · Jason McGee, Zooko

    • Eiger's new developer Paul Dan (Discord nickname Giddy) joined the ZSF implementation for zcashd, working with Tomek, and they agreed to give a technical update on the August 22 call.
    • Shielded Labs announced that Zooko is joining as head of product, that it will cooperate with ECC to accelerate TFL and crosslink development, and that it is pursuing the hybrid PoW/PoS transition.
    • Zooko said they will make a list of the tradeoffs of several approaches and present it on the August 22 call, and from now on will give the engineering community updates at this time slot every two weeks.
  8. Public announcement: inclusion proof progress

    QEDIT · Jon, Dodger

    • Jon relayed that at a conference people from another privacy token described a method of proving membership in a set of billions of records in milliseconds.
    • Dodger asked whether it is a technology that replaces ring signatures, and was interested in whether scalability changes significantly given the anonymity set limits of other privacy coins' ring signatures.
    • Jon said they would post the related link on the forum and ask for community opinions.
  9. Open discussion: ZSA deployment readiness and fee approach

    QEDIT · Jon, Dodger

    • Jon said the key for ZSA is mainnet deployment, that the protocol is ready but needs a deeper security audit than so far.
    • The circuits, features and test tools are in place, and all that remains is merging into Zcash and activating it in an upgrade.
    • Dodger proposed holding an Arborist call on the ZSA fee structure after the NU6 testnet activation, and said the expectation is that fees are paid in ZEC.
    • Jon explained that the ZIP proposal is based on block occupancy, like the existing fee formula.
    • Jon named as a concern that ZEC holders bear the cost of privacy through inflation while wrapped assets do not.
  10. Open discussion: ZSA issuance fees and top-heaviness concerns

    Kris, Dodger

    • Kris said the ZIP-317 transfer fee is fine, but designing an issuance fee that allows both trivial experiments and large asset inflows is hard.
    • Kris also pointed out that Nate's shielded hosting fee proposal does not suit NFTs.
    • Kris mentioned the top-heaviness risk of ZSA asset value greatly exceeding the total value of ZEC, and said there is no problem early on so they should watch it.
    • Dodger thought that if a problem arises, a consensus change could be deployed quickly in the single Zebra implementation.
    • Kris said that with several zebrad forks coming, they hope protocol consensus is also reached in the community.
  11. Open discussion: zero-knowledge proofs and passport-based voting

    Jon, Dodger

    • Jon introduced the case of an open-source group that used biometric passports and zero-knowledge proofs to let Russian and Iranian citizens prove they voted only once in a mock election.
    • It is at the alpha stage, but even the app is public.
    • Dodger asked whether this could give Sybil resistance to fully anonymous governance.
    • Jon answered that it is relevant in the long term but it is unclear whether it is a real solution for Zcash.

This summary is based on the original meeting notes; check them for exact details.