← All calls
ARBORIST#95

Zebra 2.2.0 released

Zebra 2.2.0 was released and the FROST client and server went into audit.

Agenda summary 11

  1. Zebra update: Zebra 2.2.0 release

    Zcash Foundation · Alfredo

    • Zebra 2.2.0 was released this week, and the most important change is a consensus rule check on the branch ID, added for security hardening.
    • An index tracking spending transaction IDs, needed to replace the zcashd wallet, was added.
    • A verbosity setting was added to the getblock RPC, and the deprecated JSON RPC crate was migrated to jsonrpsee.
    • An external contributor fixed getblockchaininfo to return the genesis block when the state is empty.
    • RPC compatibility was improved, for example by bringing getblock error messages closer to zcashd's.
  2. Zebra update: changes since release and work in progress

    Zcash Foundation · Alfredo

    • After the release, a bug where Zebra did not announce newly mined blocks to the network was fixed, and the CI architecture documentation and a regtest transparent address bug fix were included.
    • Marek is refactoring Zebra's Dockerfile and entrypoint, and an external contributor has started implementing invalidateblock and reconsiderblock.
    • Arya is building a feature that tracks and bans misbehaving peers by score, and Alfredo is adding inbound connections to the getpeers RPC.
    • Replacing the Zcash script implementation is on the ZF side, mainly handled by Conrado.
    • Natalie is replacing Zebra's sinsemilla implementation with the new crate ECC added, and also extending getblockchaininfo to return more data.
  3. ECC update: transparent script, gap limit, Zallet

    ECC · Kris, Pacu

    • Greg Pfeil completed transparent script support, which was merged into zcash_script after ZF's review, and follow-up PR 197 is still a draft, so they agreed to take a look.
    • Transparent gap limit handling was implemented, so the seed phrase of a transparent-only wallet that used Bitcoin-style address rotation can also be recovered.
    • The ZSA ZIP review has exchanged feedback with QEDIT several times and continues, and work on the v6 transaction format spec has begun, with Arya also joining the discussion.
    • Zallet, which was at an initial alpha at the last call, now actually serves a few zcashd RPC APIs and has progressed enough to start work on distribution infrastructure.
    • Work on connecting to Zaino has not yet progressed, and Zallet is using a lightwallet server as its data source.
  4. zcashd retirement: Zaino update

    Zingo Labs · Zancas, Pacu, Blake, Pili

    • Zancas said Zaino is close to a replacement release, that productivity is high with added staff, and that there was a brief delay because of a community member's health problem.
    • Pacu asked for review of the Milestone 2 PR in the Zaino repository, centered on implementing the read state service features, and urged people to review each other's code.
    • Pacu raised that agreement is needed on Zaino PR 115, which allows zebrad connections with arbitrary hostnames.
    • Blake of Zec.rocks summed up that they value secure defaults but considers RFC-1918 local IP connections sufficient for Docker and cloud environments, so it is not a blocker.
  5. Zcash Shielded Assets (ZSA) update

    QEDIT · Vivek, Kris

    • The Zcash Note Encryption crate, generalized to support ZSA, was merged upstream after ECC's review, the first piece of the ZSA implementation to go upstream.
    • After one more round of ZIP editor review, one PR was merged, and further changes to the transaction format are being discussed in the new PR 976.
    • In Zebra, the new consensus rules, transaction structure, and implementation of state and asset supply management progressed, and the ECS node for the ZSA testnet is being set up and finished so it can be run easily with Docker and GitHub Actions.
    • All the Least Authority audit recommendations were addressed and confirmed in the updated audit report.
    • For asset swaps, after the Orchard implementation the librustzcash implementation draft was finished, and for the user control feature a forum design and a ZIP draft were prepared.
    • Kris said they posted a proposal to change how asset descriptions are handled (PR 975) in the ZIPs channel and asked people to take a look.
  6. ZSA tools and when wallet developers should prepare

    QEDIT, ECC · Pacu, Vivek, Dodger, Daira Emma

    • Pacu asked when wallet developers should start preparing and what tools exist, since ZSA turns a wallet into a multi-asset wallet on a single chain.
    • Vivek answered that issuance, transfer and burn transactions can be made with QEDIT's zcash_tx_tool, and that Docker and GitHub Actions support is being built there too.
    • This tool is a starting point for checking ZSA interactions rather than production grade, and the ZSA testnet is being prepared by connecting to Zebra nodes in the cloud.
    • Dodger said wallets can start work only once the changes are merged into core libraries such as librustzcash, and that it would be easier if a CLI wallet supported ZSA.
    • Vivek said QEDIT's fork is behind upstream and the rebase burden is growing with changes like PCZT, so they welcome progress on merging.
    • Daira Emma shared the schedule document used for ECC's roadmap estimates, explaining that it is also optimistic but more realistic than before.
  7. NSM update

    Shielded Labs, Eiger · Jason McGee, Mariusz

    • Shielded Labs is focusing on integrating the three ZIPs.
    • Mariusz of Eiger has nearly finished rebasing the NSM ZIP implementation PR.
    • The next step is to introduce transaction version 6 and remove the feature flag set up early on, and the same will be done in the librustzcash PR.
  8. Trailing Finality / Crosslink update

    Shielded Labs · Zooko

    • Shielded Labs is onboarding new employees Sam and Mark, and building a reduced CI for Zebra that does less than upstream and is easier to understand.
    • Because Crosslink is a change that is not backward compatible, it cannot be connected to the upstream CI that runs mainnet integration tests.
    • The first milestone is a prototype that imitates half of BFT and always fails.
    • Zooko is replying to comments from Andrew Arnott and Arya in the crosslink-deployment repository.
  9. FROST client tool and server

    Zcash Foundation · Conrado, Pili, Pacu

    • Work on the FROST server and the command-line client for key generation and signing is all finished, and the audit kicked off on Monday and has begun.
    • The plan is to release the final version of the tools after receiving the audit results.
    • Since it is an implementation using the FROST reference implementation library rather than a simple demo, the team is thinking of renaming the repository.
    • Pili said most of what wallets need is done and only feedback on how wallets use it is needed.
    • The team plans to introduce it at the February 19 community call and hopes many people will try it and give feedback.
  10. Public announcements: ZconVI registration, Dev Summit, Zec.rocks workshop and Hosh

    Zcash Foundation, Zec.rocks · Pili, Dodger, Blake

    • Pili said ZconVI has been announced and told people to register.
    • Dodger announced the last call for sign-ups for the Sofia Dev Summit, to be held alongside Real World Crypto, and said someone other than ZF will lead it.
    • Zec.rocks is running Zebra 2.2.0 on nodes around the world, and more than 40 people are taking part in the workshop on running a light wallet node yourself.
    • Zec.rocks runs Hosh, a tool that tracks light wallet node uptime, and will add infrastructure for anyone who wants to be tracked.
    • Pili said the Zebra 2.2.0 blog and forum posts will be announced soon.
  11. Open discussion: ML-KEM, account security, an unspendable bug

    ECC · Daira Emma, Pili, Andrew, Kris

    • While trying to prove that ML-KEM, the NIST-standard quantum-resistant cryptography, is key private, Daira Emma learned that a paper had already proved it.
    • Daira Emma said that, as a result, ML-KEM could be used for note encryption in a future upgrade.
    • Daira Emma advised that crypto workers and activists can be targets, so they should enroll in Google's Advanced Protection Program, which uses hardware security keys.
    • Andrew said the unspendable bug in librustzcash issue 1609 has gone on for months and affects the users of their wallet app, and Kris answered that Str4d has a reproduction environment but could not prioritize it.
    • Resolving this bug was recorded as a decision and action item.

This summary is based on the original meeting notes; check them for exact details.