← All calls
ARBORIST#101

NU7 delay strains ZCG finances

The NU7 delay increased ZCG's burden of funding ZSA, and a clearer schedule was requested.

Agenda summary 7

  1. Zebra update: Zebra 2.3.0 and Zaino integration problems

    Zcash Foundation · Alfredo

    • Zebra 2.3.0 was released over the past two weeks.
    • A problem with the optional get tree state field in getrawtransaction was fixed, resolving a stack integration problem with Zaino.
    • At the community's request, size and time fields were added to the transaction object, but since the new fields can cause problems for Zaino and Zallet, how to manage this going forward is under discussion.
    • Repeated log messages on the Zebra side found while testing Zallet and the full stack, and a CI problem found during the release, were fixed.
    • A problem where an HTTP middleware bug misordered the upgrades field of getblockchaininfo was fixed, and validateaddress was extended to support TEX addresses.
    • Adding value pools to getblock, an RPC for subscribing to mempool changes, and shielded coinbase support in Zebra are each in progress.
  2. ECC update: Zallet z_send and the lockbox one-time disbursement plan

    ECC · Kris

    • z_send was merged into Zallet and can be tested; it does not support all of zcashd's z_sendmany functionality, but simple cases work.
    • Adding mempool scan support to Zallet is in progress.
    • Automatic address rotation was added to the ECC mobile wallet SDK and propagated through the FFI.
    • An implementation plan for the lockbox one-time disbursement, reflecting the recent vote results, is in place, and at this week's ECC weekly R&D meeting the team discussed the requirements and options for the long-term lockbox disbursement protocol to go into NU7.
    • Key rotation and the rest of the lockbox disbursement mechanism will be refined next week, so interested community members were asked to take part.
    • Work on zcashd wallet import continues.
  3. Zingo Labs news (reported by proxy)

    Zingo Labs · Pacu, Alfredo

    • Zingo is wrapping up Milestone 3 of its current grant and starting a follow-up grant that includes block explorer support and more.
    • Alfredo reported that the Zebra PRs sent by Zingo on transaction and block deserialization were merged.
    • Pacu said that at the biweekly overlapping zcashd retirement meeting there was no agenda this time.
  4. NSM update

    Shielded Labs · Jason McGee, Kris

    • Three PRs implementing ZIP 233, in librustzcash, Zcash test vectors and Zebra, were rebased.
    • Kris left comments about two weeks ago and Mariusz replied this week; so far only the librustzcash PR has been reviewed.
    • Once ZIP 233 is merged, the PRs for ZIP 234 and 235 will be opened.
    • Kris said the links to review are scattered around, and asked people to post them on the R&D Discord in the channel matching each PR (libraries, Zebra, ZIPs).
  5. Crosslink update: Milestone 2 and the mainnet shadowing workshop

    Shielded Labs · Nate, Mark, Alfredo

    • The Milestone 2 release is being wrapped up, and only Nate's documentation remains.
    • Milestone 2 puts a BFT system into the Zebra fork, connects nodes to each other over the BFT protocol and also to Zcash mainnet, and includes a mainnet shadowing mode in which BFT agrees on the PoW block headers it sees.
    • Signatures and full PoW block verification are placeholders and still rough.
    • Next week a workshop will be held on the Zcash Global Discord where participants with a public IP and port connect nodes to the BFT network and test it; even without a public IP, people can observe or learn how to run the software.
    • Alfredo shared their TLA+ work for Crosslink as a personal project and asked for feedback.
  6. Open discussion: ZCG's funding burden from the NU7 delay

    ZCG, ECC · Jason McGee, Kris, Alfredo

    • Jason McGee said the NU7 schedule slipping has increased ZCG's funding burden; ZCG has paid QEDIT $105,000 per month for the past five months for ZSA integration and is planning a similar follow-up grant through the end of the year.
    • It is now an eight-engineer team averaging $15,000 per person per month, a scale premised on completion by summer, so it cannot be sustained indefinitely.
    • ZCG asked for a more realistic NU7 schedule and for the core team to give a fixed scope of the work needed for ZSA integration.
    • Kris answered that they cannot set a schedule on the spot, that the ZSA integration PR is huge and takes time to review, and that several things are competing for attention.
    • QEDIT meets with Str4d and Daira Emma once or twice a week; Kris said they cannot attend because it is early morning for them and so do not know the details.
    • Kris said that once only ZIPs 230 and 246 (transaction format and sighash) are rebased and merged, most of the other small ZSA ZIP PRs are merged and the library merges are unblocked.
  7. Open discussion: Zewif and zcashd wallet migration, retirement schedule

    ECC, Zcash Foundation · Kris, Pacu, Jason McGee

    • Kris said that the Blockchain Commons Zewif format was designed as a direct serialization of zcashd's internal representation, so they stripped out thousands of lines.
    • Kris said they have chosen to implement zcashd wallet import first on top of the wallet.dat parsing tool Blockchain Commons built, and then export to Zewif.
    • Pacu said partners such as large exchanges need a retirement schedule to set priorities, and asked Zingo, ZF and ECC for a timeline that need not be exact.
    • Pacu said the vote results confirmed that people want NSM before NU7, so the inputs for the timeline discussion are now in place.
    • Jason McGee said they would check QEDIT's scope of work with Str4d and Daira Emma, and help the core team review and scope the Blockchain Commons and Zingo grants.
    • Kris pointed out that if the deliverables had been split more incrementally (for example, integrating key material first in zcash devtool), the mismatches would have surfaced earlier.

This summary is based on the original meeting notes; check them for exact details.