← All insights
GOVERNANCEShielded Labs

Thoughts on polls and governance

Shielded Labs explains how it reads the NU7 sentiment survey results and what they mean for projects such as NSM and dynamic fees.

Jason McGee of Shielded Labs described how they read the recent governance vote results and what they mean for its own projects, such as NSM and Dynamic Fees. They stress that because Zcash has no formal on-chain governance, such votes should be understood not as mechanically deciding outcomes but as inputs to a rough-consensus process, a useful signal of sentiment.

They explain the changes in governance by halving era. Early on it was relatively centralized around the Zcash Company (later ECC) and its CEO, and around the first halving the trademark agreement between ECC and the Zcash Foundation effectively created 2-of-2 multisig governance. Around the second halving, as ECC dropped out of the agreement, it moved to a model of gathering sentiment from several panels such as ZCAP, ZAC, ZecHub and regional communities, and later coinholders were included in sentiment gathering. The current coinholder voting method is still cumbersome but improving.

Anyone can currently propose a protocol change through the ZIP process, and for a change to go forward it generally needs broad support from several panels and coinholders. But panel and coinholder votes are not governance itself, and final authority lies with those who run and depend on the network: miners, node operators, exchanges, wallets and users. Contentious forks are a core property of a permissionless system, and they think Zcash is unlikely to go through conflicts like Bitcoin's block size war, because there is already an established process for gauging support.

Their reading of the results is as follows. Issuance smoothing had broad support from the panels but not from coinholders, while burning 60% of fees had broad support from both the panels and coinholders. On this basis, they see clear support for ZIP 233 and ZIP 235, the components that remove ZEC from circulation, and want to include them in the next network upgrade. For smoothing, they read some coinholders as seeing the existing issuance schedule as a monetary identity similar to the 21 million cap, and leaves open an alternative design that keeps the halving schedule. They say Dynamic Fees had low support and was never a final proposal but a starting point for discussion.

They stress that the vote results are only sentiment at a particular moment, shifting with market conditions, and not a final decision on long-term direction. ZSA says that even if mainnet activation is uncertain, it can continue work by running testnets, improving the implementation and sorting out use cases. Coinholder opinion is an important economic signal, but coinholders have no formal veto over the protocol. Since coinholder voting is currently used mainly by a small number of large holders, they propose improving it for lower-friction participation or replacing it, and holding votes more often.

This summary is based on the original; check the original for exact details.