← All insights
GOVERNANCEZcash Foundation

NU7 poll results and the way forward

Project Tachyon received overwhelming support from every group. Orchard quantum recoverability won 90.5% approval from ZCAP and 94.6% from coinholders.

The Zcash Foundation summarized the NU7 sentiment poll results and the direction going forward. It thanked ZCAP members, coinholders, the Engineering Caucus, ZecHub, Zcash Brasil, Zcash Español and Zcash Türkiye for taking part, and said the results show both meaningful consensus and real disagreement. The Foundation said it will name both clearly rather than gloss over the gaps.

Four proposals drew strong support across all groups. Project Tachyon received overwhelming support from every group. Orchard quantum recoverability got 90.5% from ZCAP and 94.6% from coinholders, and explicit fees got 83.2% from ZCAP and 87.2% from coinholders. Of the NSM, fee burning was supported by 78% of ZCAP and 80.1% of coinholders. The Foundation judged that these four should be the foundation of NU7, and plans to assess technical readiness and scope.

There was also major disagreement. ZSA was supported by 70.4% of ZCAP but opposed by 98.6% of coinholders, and NSM issuance smoothing was supported by 84% of ZCAP but opposed by 83.5% of coinholders. Consensus accounts (77.9% of ZCAP in favor, 97.3% of coinholders against), memo bundles (76.8% in favor, 99.3% against) and Sprout deprecation (v4 transactions, 77.7% in favor, 84.6% against) were also split. For STARK verification via TZEs, it judged that under current sentiment there is no path to inclusion in NU7.

The Foundation candidly said that the coinholder vote drew only 7.25% of circulating ZEC and that the number of votes varied widely, from 210 for Tachyon to 55 for consensus accounts. This does not invalidate the results, but it means they should be read as strong views held by a small number of participants. It said ZSA needs a separate conversation to understand the coinholders' reasons for opposing, and that for NSM, fee burning and issuance smoothing should be evaluated separately.

The Foundation said that how to weight the groups when ZCAP and coinholder results diverge widely should be discussed separately from the NU7 decision. Its position is that the disagreements surfacing is not a failure of the process but its job. It stressed that a Zcash, even with a narrow scope, built on real consensus is better than one built on unresolved conflict.

This summary is based on the original; check the original for exact details.