Discussing a move to withdraw-only Sapling
Arguing that pools that are not quantum-safe must be frozen for quantum recoverability, this post discusses a plan to move Orchard, Sprout and Sapling users in stages.
The author says every ZEC user must be made quantum recoverable (QR) and the community has already overwhelmingly agreed. The plan is, at a minimum, to freeze every pool that is safe only against pre-quantum methods before a cryptographically relevant quantum computer appears. Orchard will soon become quantum recoverable, a wallet-only upgrade in which, after a wallet update, a single transaction makes long-held funds QR.
Once QR is applied to wallets, the next step is moving users off non-QR setups. The targets are the non-QR parts of Orchard, Sprout and Sapling. After the next network upgrade (NU7), the activity of wallets that are definitely QR Orchard can be tracked publicly, and the results will decide whether stronger measures, such as a circuit update, are needed. For Sprout, the author expects a coinholder vote to set the pool's final date.
Sapling will not be made QR, so the migration discussion should start now. Sapling is 11.8% of shielded ZEC and 18% of shielded activity, mostly from public mining pool payouts. Since January 1, 2024, shielded ZEC in Sapling has fallen from 1.1 million to 600,000 ZEC. The largest users are miners and YWallet, and miners have already begun switching to an Orchard mining pool built by zkclaudecoder in pure Rust on Zebrad (mainnet pool.zecminingpool.com, testnet pool.tazminer.com).
The author thinks that because Tachyon, the fourth shielded pool, is expected to arrive later this year, it makes sense to announce the Sapling withdraw-only process early. The proposal is to remove Sapling deposits and make it withdraw-only starting one year after the decision. The decision would come from a full coinholder vote and committee consultation, and if so the timing would be around June 2027. Finally, the author asks for feedback on this.
This summary is based on the original; check the original for exact details.