Should ZCG grant recipients elect ZCG committee members?
vaspholdings proposed first checking what share of ZCAP voters are ZCG grant recipients. If the share is high, they would support excluding recipients from voting while they are being funded.
ZCAP was created in 2018 as an advisory panel, and eligibility has since widened to include developers, ZIP authors, forum members and grant recipients. ZCAP also elects the five ZCG committee members. This post asks whether people who receive ZCG grants should be allowed to elect the committee that can fund them.
In an earlier post, the author cited Maxime Desalle's analysis showing that 72 of 201 ZCAP members (36%) are grant recipients or belong to recipient teams. What matters is the share among actual voters. Since ZF holds ZCAP participation records, the author suggests combining them with FPF's grant records so the share can be found from totals alone, without revealing any individual's votes.
If the recipient share is significant, the author would support a proposal to exclude current recipients from voting for as long as their funding continues. Removing only the "grant recipient" eligibility category is not enough, since people could re-enter as developers or forum members, so indirect support must be covered too. The author draws a line that developers and ZIP authors should not be excluded because of that work. Separately, the author said they would also propose a ZIP barring committee members and related parties from receiving new ZCG grants during their term and for 12 months afterward.
The author supports reforming ZCAP rather than abolishing it, and separately put forward a proposal in which ZCAP elects 3 seats and coinholders elect 2. The author disclosed being a candidate in the December ZCG election and a ZCAP member, and closed by urging that the facts be established before the rules are changed.
This summary is based on the original; check the original for exact details.