← All insights
GOVERNANCEZcash Forum · joshs

joshs's counter-proposal to end the Dev Fund early

joshs, who proposed ZIP 1016, opposed keeping the coinholder fund while removing only ZCG, and argued for ending the entire Dev Fund before November 2028.

joshs criticized the proposal to remove ZCG while keeping the coinholder fund (the End ZCG post on the forum) as a half-measure. The author argued that the existing Dev Fund should either run as designed until it expires in November 2028 or be ended immediately, and that handing 100% to coinholders does not solve the "taxation without representation" problem and concentrates power in one group.

Of the current 20%, coinholders control 12% and vote on retroactive grants every quarter, and ZCG, a five-person community-elected committee, controls 8%. According to the post, this structure was chosen after discussion in May 2025 and put into code in November of that year as NU6.1, and joshs themselves proposed ZIP 1016. Funds were short at the time, but new privately sponsored teams have arrived and the author now considers funding no longer scarce.

The main argument is about incentives. The value of the two funds has risen above $300 million with the recent rise in the ZEC price, and control of large funds amounts to control of Zcash's direction. The author worries that supporting teams through quarterly votes makes teams move to suit grants rather than the market, and that stake-based power can be bought, so actors such as states might try to buy influence. The author cited the Steem case and said there is already a chilling effect, with grant recipients reluctant to criticize.

The conclusion is to end the Dev Fund entirely before the November 2028 end set in code, so as to realign incentives. The author believes large holders who want influence can sponsor directly, and explained that the current streams expire around November 2028, after which all of the block reward goes to miners.

This summary is based on the original; check the original for exact details.