Proposal to replace ZCG elections with coinholder voting
Noting that the coinholder voting tool was used for the retroactive grant vote, a proposal suggests switching ZCG committee elections from ZCAP voting to coinholder voting.
A forum user proposed changing how ZCG committee members are elected to token holder voting (THV). The explanation is that on the road to fully token-holder-based governance for Zcash, off-chain methods were used until THV could be implemented safely, and a THV tool has since been built. The tool is still rough, but it was used to safely run the retroactive grant vote, and turnout in the last vote was about 7.5%.
ZCG currently has five committee members, and a ZCAP group estimated at 50 to 300 people elects candidates by vote. Eligibility comes from being active in the grants system or on the forum, which means mostly people who receive or review grants. The author says this system worked when it was introduced, but worries that as Zcash grows, the incentive structure linking ZCG, ZCAP and grantees makes a revolving-door economy unavoidable and could turn the Dev Fund into a corrupt tax on token holders.
So they propose using the already working THV system for ZCG elections and abolishing the existing panel voter group (written as FCAP in the original). It is an easy step that advances THV without much effort, and the ZCG committee itself does not change, only how it is elected. As a next step, the author asked for ideas on the concrete procedure to put to a token holder vote.
This summary is based on the original; check the original for exact details.