← All insights
RESEARCHShielded Labs

Orchard forgery vulnerability disclosed

On May 29, Taylor Hornby found a critical forgery vulnerability in the Orchard pool and reported it to ZODL, and the ecosystem completed an emergency response by June 2.

Shielded Labs published an account and assessment of the Orchard forgery vulnerability under the joint names of Zooko Wilcox, Jason McGee and Taylor Hornby. On May 29, 2026, Taylor Hornby found a critical forgery vulnerability in the Orchard pool and told Zcash Open Development Lab (ZODL), and ZODL coordinated an ecosystem-wide emergency response that completed the fix on June 2.

The vulnerability would have allowed unlimited counterfeit ZEC to be created inside Orchard without detection. The Orchard circuit's constraints were insufficient, so checks passed even when arbitrary false inputs were fed into the elliptic curve multiplication. With help from Opus 4.8, Taylor wrote a complete exploit and confirmed on a local regtest that unlimited counterfeit ZEC could be created. The vulnerability existed from Orchard's activation in May 2022 until the emergency fix was deployed on June 1.

Whether it was exploited cannot be proven by cryptography alone, because of Orchard's privacy properties and the nature of the bug. Even so, the authors assess prior exploitation as unlikely. The reasons are that the vulnerability evaded review by the world's best cryptographers for years, the discovery came from deliberate research by Taylor, whom Shielded Labs brought on in April, and the window for attack was short thanks to the rapid response of ZODL and the ecosystem after discovery. They add, however, that users need not rely on this assessment.

To that end, Shielded Labs is exploring, with other developers, a network upgrade that deploys a new shielded pool and applies turnstile accounting to all coins in the Orchard pool. The aim is to let anyone verify supply integrity and prove there are no counterfeit coins inside Orchard. It plans to explain in detail in a follow-up post next week, and activation requires user support and the standard governance process.

It is also strengthening security research. With the help of Taylor Hornby and Anthropic, it started the next phase of AI-based research, is launching a formal verification project for the Orchard circuit, and is opening hiring for a head of security and a cryptographer. The authors thank Taylor for their work and ZODL, the Zcash Foundation and others who took part in the response, and are confident Zcash is in a position to recover.

This summary is based on the original; check the original for exact details.