Proposal to introduce EIP-1559-style dynamic fees
Warning that a transaction surge could make wallets hard to use as in spam attacks, it proposes introducing EIP-1559-style dynamic fees before Tachyon.
The author is very bullish on the ZEC price, believing it has passed its bottom, the trend has reversed and a virtuous cycle is starting. If the price keeps rising, Zcash adoption will accelerate, the shielded pool will grow substantially and transaction activity will rise sharply. But Zcash was not built to handle sudden growth, and if transactions rise a lot, a situation like the past spam attacks that effectively made wallets unusable could occur. Tachyon will solve scalability at the protocol level but will still take time, so the proposal is to deal with the risk in the meantime with dynamic fees.
The problem is that the current architecture was not designed to handle surges in transaction volume and is vulnerable to congestion and performance degradation. In the past, attackers filled the network with low-fee transactions, clogging nodes and slowing normal transactions, exploiting the fixed-fee model. ZIP 317 offered a partial solution by raising fees for large or complex transactions, but it is a static structure that does not adjust to real-time network conditions. So during congestion it cannot prioritize normal transactions over spam, and although it raises the cost of an attack, it falls short for stability during demand surges.
The solution is a dynamic fee mechanism similar to Ethereum's EIP-1559. It notes that the idea behind EIP-1559 grew out of discussions Vitalik Buterin had with the Zcash community. Fees adjust automatically with congestion, so costs rise when demand is high and transactions from users willing to pay more are processed first. It does not solve scalability itself, but it is a practical measure that can be implemented relatively quickly during Tachyon development. Unlike Bitcoin, it uses a single base fee for the whole network, so it is easy to understand, preserves privacy and simplifies wallet design.
It also adds fee burning. Permanently removing part of the fee from circulation reduces miners' incentive to create spam transactions to inflate fees. This also fits with the Network Sustainability Mechanism (NSM), under which burned fees could later be reintroduced as block rewards without exceeding the 21 million cap. Shielded Labs sees dynamic fees as an important priority and is ready to commit resources, and asks the community whether there is broad support for prioritizing this work in a future network upgrade. It thanked @shielded-nate for the idea.
This summary is based on the original; check the original for exact details.