Shielded Labs' position on the Dev Fund
In the debate over continuing the Dev Fund, Shielded Labs said it supports the Dev Fund. It also explains that it is the only major organization that has never received Dev Fund money.
Jason McGee of Shielded Labs weighed in on the debate sparked by Maxime's Dev Fund essay and proposed a framing for the conversation. Shielded Labs is the only major Zcash organization that has never applied for or received Dev Fund money, whether by direct allocation or grants, and most of its funding comes from donations by holders and supporters. They worked as a ZCG member for four years and also took part in designing the Coinholder-Directed Retroactive Grants program. They said that relying on private funds does not mean they agree with the essay's conclusion.
Shielded Labs supports the Dev Fund. It credits the fund with producing Zcash's core achievements such as Sapling, Orchard, Halo 2, Zebra and Zashi, and with keeping top-tier teams going through two bear markets and regulatory pressure. In 2016-2020, 20% of the block reward went to the Founders' Reward; under ZIP 1014 it was split among ECC, the Foundation and ZCG; and after a 2024 vote ended direct support for organizations, 8% now goes to ZCG and 12% to coinholder grants. They see each change as moving in a more decentralized and accountable direction.
They say the Dev Fund must be distinguished from the grant programs that execute it. The Dev Fund is a protocol rule that sends 20% of the block reward to ecosystem development, while ZCG and coinholder grants are the programs that decide how that money is used. Even if the Dev Fund ended tomorrow, both programs would keep operating on their existing treasuries, which hold about 200,000 ZEC and millions of dollars in cash. They say 20% that made sense at a $500 million market cap means something entirely different at $50 billion, so how large the grants should be needs to be discussed separately.
Their argument is that the discussion should start from outcomes and work backward to means, not be a good-versus-evil debate about the Dev Fund. They judge that ZCG has delivered a fairly good track record, citing ZecHub, Zcash Brazil, mobile and hardware wallet teams, and the coinholder voting mechanism as examples. The reason coinholders do not elect ZCG members is historical: there was no coinholder voting when it launched in 2020, and they explain that the method could be changed through a ZIP if desired. They add, though, that it should also be weighed whether concentrating all decisions in one group is a good idea.
The Dev Fund currently expires at the next halving in 2028, and if nothing is done, 100% of the block reward goes to miners. For the period in between, they list alternatives including keeping the current setup, sending all 20% to a coinholder lockbox, letting it expire, recycling through the NSM, keeping a price-linked reduced version, a phased wind-down that shrinks it at each halving, paying Crosslink stakers, alternative mechanisms such as an assurance contract, and combinations. With about two years of time, they say we should start now, and ask people to leave opinions, new ideas and objections on the forum.
This summary is based on the original; check the original for exact details.