← All insights
GRANTZcash Forum · ebfull

Tachyon applies retroactively for Ironwood formal verification

Project Tachyon applied for a retroactive grant of $738,942 to cover its Ironwood emergency response, including external audit fees and its own engineering costs.

Project Tachyon announced on the forum that it applied to the Coinholder Retroactive Grants Program for a retroactive grant for its work in the Ironwood emergency response. The application is titled Ironwood zk-SNARK formal verification and requests $738,942. The breakdown is $225,000 in external audit and formal verification invoices, $506,942 for its own engineering at 2x the rate paid to outside vendors, and $7,000 in frontier model costs. It explains that the 2x is a premium for an unplanned emergency mobilization that started within days and was tied to a fixed activation deadline.

The background is that on May 29, Taylor Hornby found a soundness bug in the Orchard circuit that could allow undetectable forgery of ZEC. The bug was patched and disclosed, but because the pool is shielded, it could not be answered whether the supply was still sound. On June 6, Tachyon, together with Valar Group and in coordination with ZF, Shielded Labs and ZODL, publicly committed to the Ironwood response and said it would lead the formal verification of the Ironwood zk-SNARK. It then implemented the circuit changes and paid for two independent verification firms.

The deliverable was published on July 28, the day Ironwood activated. It shows, assuming cryptographic assumptions, that the Ironwood zk-SNARK has no vulnerability that would allow undetectable forgery in the new pool, and it consists of more than 2,700 Lean theorems at github.com/zcash/ironwood. The circuit implementation was opened as orchard PR #504 on June 12 and merged on the 23rd. External verification cost $150,000 for zkSecurity and $75,000 for Formal Land. Tal Derei led the Lean formalization, and Sean Bowe led the circuit implementation and verification overall.

The application states what the verification does and does not address. It rules out undetectable forgery bugs stemming from the zk-SNARK construction (the circuit or protocol specification), but it does not cover implementation bugs or failures of cryptographic assumptions. It does not bill for ZODL's independent work, additional verification after activation, or a roadmap delay of about two months. The funds were raised from private donations by past Zcash holders, and there was no separate donation or contract for this work. Jason McGee said this work greatly raised confidence in Ironwood's soundness and strongly supports the retroactive grant.

This summary is based on the original; check the original for exact details.