← All insights
GOVERNANCEZcash Forum · vaspholdings

ZIP draft: apply the ZCG and CCF funding caps together

vaspholdings proposed a 'both-taps' ZIP draft that sets a cap on CCF as well as ZCG using the same standard, sending any excess to the NSM.

The author, vaspholdings, criticized the current proposals for asking only ZCG to give something up, and presented a 'both-taps' ZIP draft that applies a single standard to both grant funds. The ZCG advisory vote starts on November 16, and the author said this draft cannot be added to the current vote.

Under the draft, each program calculates its required amount every quarter as already committed payouts plus a reserve of two years of its own spending (with a minimum). The funds it can use are converted to USD at the 6-month average ZEC price (or the lower recent 1-week average), and any amount above the required amount is sent to the NSM within a quarterly limit.

The limit is based on the 50,000 ZEC for ZCG proposed in the lockbox ZIP, and applying an 8:12 ratio gives CCF 75,000 ZEC. The minimum reserves use the same ratio, at USD 25 million and USD 37.5 million. The 8% and 12% allocations in ZIP 1016 and the November 2028 end date do not change, and approved work is protected.

The author argues that fixed figures fail depending on the ZEC price. A comparison table shows that at USD 100 ZCG would send nothing to the NSM, and at 5,000 it would send about 129,000 ZEC, while the lockbox ZIP always sends 50,000 ZEC. This is the author's rough estimate, and the author added that CCF's actual figures are needed.

The author asked why the NU7.1 schedule excluded transaction format changes, since NSM transfers need the ZIP 233 implementation and ZIP 248. The author asked that this technical change be handled in a separate advisory vote, and said they would vote for keeping the status quo (question 4) in this advisory vote. The author also disclosed being a ZCAP member and running in the December ZCG election.

This summary is based on the original; check the original for exact details.